Rated 3.81 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Works really well, for a great price!
I had been using the ABH Brow Wiz, which I love, but when I heard about this cheaper alternative, I decided to give it a try. I was not disappointed! This is a great dupe for the ABH Brow Wiz, and such a great bargain at $5! I will say I had to do a little research on the shade choices first, after reading the reviews about pigment issues and shades not being dark enough. I use Medium Brown in ABH, and was going to order the Colourpop Brow Boss in Brunette, but after seeing some swatch comparison pictures, I ordered Ash Brown. The Ash Brown on my looks very close to the ABH Medium Brown. If you are going to try this pencil, I would suggest researching the shades first, so you are not disappointed. I found this product very easy to apply, and did not have any issues with it being dry, as people had mentioned in other reviews. I apply using very little pressure compared to ABH, but can achieve the same brow coverage and look.
Most Helpful Critical Review Packaging sucks
I got my auburn brow pencil and was so excited, it matched better with my copper hair color, I used it almost every day for about two weeks. although I had to use a bit more pressure than I would with other brow pencils such as Anastasia, because it just wouldn't go on pigmented enough unless I did so. After about that 2 weeks the retractable part gave out a bit and wouldn't hold my product out anymore, so it kept sliding back in if I used any sort of pressure. That went on for a few days and then it completely broke and won't let me twist the product up at all anymore, meaning more than half of the product is stuck inside. It's a huge waist of product and I'm disappointed because of this.
Reviewed by 616 customers ehhhhh
Aileen from the internet
It has good staying power throughout the day. I also like the brush that comes with it. HOWEVER you have to push down hard against your skin for it to show up. Personally I'd stick the the nyx brow pencil for a drugstore option.
I'd give it a zero if I could
AmyB from Ohio
Very disappointed after seeing this product turn up on a couple best brow product lists. So hard and dry that it broke as soon as I started applying enough pressure to get SOME color on my brows. Just bad.
Love this pencil
Trina from Chicago, IL
I love this brow product hands down my favorite. Doesn't leave your brows looking waxy more hair like than most pencils. Love the longevity of wear. I will say this pencil breaks/get unaligned which means you don't always get to use all of the product
Really great and easy to use!
Alex from El Paso, TX
I used to use pomades but i wanted to give a pencil a try. Not really in pencil form it's sort of has a gel-like feeling at least to me (not like super gel but i'm not sure if you all understand haha). I love it, it keeps me looking natural but can give you an extra pop as you build up. I think it's super easy to use especially for people who struggle shaping (like me hehe).
Finally a neutral taupe
Makeup Addict from NYC
It's so hard to find a neutral taupe at the drugstore. This is a perfect match and the texture is not too dry or too creamy. It's not waxy. Lasts all day. Only downside is not much product. Even though it's cheap, I go through them like 3x as fast as ABH pencils.
Decent for price
LLX1000 from IL
Good price for pencil, hard to get to twist at first. Also the pencil is kind of hard to put on as it doesn't show much difference maybe I got too light but it just seemed like the pencil wouldn't go on my brows
Doesn't melt off
Sjdubya from Peoria
I love using a pencil/crayon for my brows because it gives me more control of where I need to fill in patches.
It stays all day and doesn't melt off. Would by again and again.
My favorite brow pencil
Megan from Virginia
You can't get much better for the price. The color isn't too drastic so it looks very natural if you use small strokes.
Absolutely love this brow pencil
Liz from Arlington, Texas
The best thing to fill in your brows
Amory from Mesa
The product is great I love it but I always have a problem with the brush end always falling off ? I always have to use nail glue or something so it will stop with every pencil I buy but it's cheap so I guess it's what I can expect ?
Jess from HI
This is such a good brow pencil for an amazing price. It's not too creamy so it's easy to outline my brows and it's easy to blend out.
Love the texture and color!
Roselin from Miami
Lexi from Bettendorf
I have dark red hair, that's why I got the auburn but it looks more like a light brown and doesn't match my eyebrows. I like the product though to fade my brows at the front and then use a different brow product for the rest. Makes it look a bit more natural.
No definition or lasting color
Violet from Somewhere over the rainbow
I bought this because one of my favorite youtubers raved about it ( and looked great on her) however, this pencil did not give me the coverage, color, or definition I wanted. I did not like the formula.
Good color, gone fast
khb17 from Tennessee
Color is true to what you'd expect. Have to use more product since pencil is so thin. Ran out in less than a month.
eye brow pencil from colquitt georgia
this is really good you kinda have to warm it up to get some pigment at first but after that it's really good stays on a while and i recommend
Ash Brown is actually ash!
Millie from Texas
Brow pencils always pull warm on me, but this ash brown is actually ash. It works great. And it's a fraction of the price of the higher end brow pencils and they have the same amount of product.
A from Oh
I mean it's alright. Really gave me like the feathered brow look and a lot of hair like strokes, but the pencil was way too thin for me. I also like the Spooly on the end.
does what it's supposed to
maddie from california
is it revolutionary? no, but it's great for the price. it's very similar to the anastasia brow wiz and i would recommend it
Very natural looking and such a cheap alternative!
Mimi from Tx
If the anastasia pencils aren't on sale, this is my go-to! I wouldn't recommend this product for "box brows" because the way it appears. But natural strokes for hairs, this is perfect!
Favorite brow pencil
kels from Oregon
Best brow pencil. Wish it had more product. Perfect color and tip.
Noëlia from Saint Paul MN
Very easy to work with and blends great. Didn't smudge even though I didn't use a gel to set it. Looks very natural.
jordyn from kentucky
its exactly what it said however i got the darkest shade and it was still too light for my eyebrows, but its super smooth and easy to use so im just going to use it on light make up days.
I love it in Soft Black
Christina from FL
I have bought this over and over again. Its perfect for me because its quick and easy to use. Easy to take with you. I like that you can sort of build it up so you can go for either an intense dark or a slightly more natural look.
My only problem was that the last time I got it from the Ulta store the product was broken into a bunch of pieces and was totally unuseable. :(
Perfect for a natural brow
wvyrv from Palmdale
I purchased this brow pencil on a whim during a visit at my local Ulta. I was looking for an Anastasia BH pencil but because they were about to close I decided I'd grab this one instead and let me tell you; it is THE best eyebrow pencil I've ever purchased.
I have medium thick brows with the occasional sparse spot and these make my eyebrows look freshly done and natural! It's the perfect amount of pigment and for those saying that it's not enough pigment, why would you want to have full pigment as soon as you touch your brow? You're gonna end up with sharpie brows. Anyway, this is literally the only brow pencil I'll be purchasing from now on. Period!