Product Reviews Rated 3.17 out of 5 stars
1168 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review AMAZING! Never been... AMAZING! Never been able to wear liquid eyeliner I've always wore pencil eyeliner!! I love this product!!! Easy to use and goes on so smooth!!! Thank you so for such amazing products! I use nothing but NYX cosmetics now!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Only okay I got this product probably a month or so ago and I though it would be a lot bolder. In reviews or tutorials for this product it seems to be bolder than the one that I purchased. I'm unsure why but it comes out on my skin super faint and I'm order to get it hold and black at all I need to literally press down with it really hard which obviously isn't very comfortable on my eyelid. What I do like about it is the softness of the felt tip and how skinny it is. I can see this being a potentially great product if this were fixed. It must only be mine but I wouldn't want to purchase another for it could turn out the same.
Reviewed by 1168 customers Price was high 4
Princess 1 from OH
Price was alittle high but would buy again. Makes a nice thin line not smearing like pencil. Just wish it stays in longer
Buy anything else 1
lslmrynhrn from Seattle
Literal garbage. Streaky, unpigmented, dried out immediately. Don't waste your money. Literally any other eyeliner would be better.
Dried Out after 3 days.. 1
Lindsay from Orlando,Fl
After First Opening it worked amazing! Color was on point with one application and very easy to make the perfect line… but after just A FEW DAYS the marker WENT DRY.. and the TIP FRAYED… I'm going to flip the tip to try and get the most out of what I purchased.. but WILL NEVER BUY AGAIN. I am VERY DISAPPOINTED, EXPECTED MORE from NYX.
Smudges very easy 2
Angie from New York
I knew it wasn't waterproof when I bought it but it still smudges very easily!! I have tried many non waterproof eyeliners and this has probably got to be one of the worst. Don't by this if you want half of your wing to smudge in the blink of an eye
Smudges very easy 2
Angie from New York
I knew it wasn't waterproof when I bought it but it still smudges very easily!! I have tried many non waterproof eyeliners and this has probably got to be one of the worst. Don't by this if you want half of your wing to smudge in the blink of an eye
Great 5
Hann from New orleans, LA
Good pigment
I would not buy this again. 1
Kay from Fredericksburg Va
This "eye marker" is terrible. When trying to apply it does not go on smooth, it is almost like it is dried out.
Fades easily, BUT.. 3
KW from Bay City, MI
Fades easily, but is great for those of us who struggle with getting winged liner right! It's thin enough to give you control over the wing w/o having to wipe off and start all over again. But I do recommend going over the outline with something like a gel or liquid liner after.
Constantly had to reapply 2
Taylor from Tacoma, WA
This is the only NYX eyeliner that has failed me. I had to constantly reapply it to my wing because it just kept coming off even with setting spray.
Good, but a little disappointed. 4
Tara Lou from Fort Wayne
When I apply the product, even after storing upside down, it appears more faint than I expected. Hard to build on it, too, because when I try to, it starts to remove the product underneath, making it harder to fix the faintness.
Disappointed 2
Doralex from Cookeville
I ordered some NXY products for Halloween. I was happy with everything but this.
Terrible 1
Gabi from Pittsburgh
Comes out very faint, and feels almost like there's no product in the tube or it's dried out from day one.
Read!!! 3
ฅ^•ﻌ•^ฅ from Maine
So originally this eyeliner pen was not the best. It would run dry and take a lot of pressure to apply. But when you flip the felt tip it works amazingly!
This was THE WORST waste of money!! 1
Jessica from Albuquerque, NM
Since NYX discontinued my favorite eyeliner of theirs, I figured I would try something else from them. This eyeliner pen is straight garbage. There was a shadow of a line. A mere suggestion. I thought hey maybe this is my fault so I made sure to stand it up to have all the eyeliner sink to the tip and the next day it *still* didn't work. Don't bother buying this.
About to return it 1
Ayye from Pennsylvania
As a black woman, I wouldn't recommend it. It is really weak
I Don't Like This Very Much... 1
Hopey from Waxhaw, NC
I am good at wings. I don't normally struggle so much to get them clean and even, I take my time, but with this eyeliner it was really hard. I was doing my sister's makeup before going out to dinner and I regretted trying this product on her. It was a little frustrating to use as it was easy to smudge and blot, and it was hard to get a clean stroke. I won't be using it again in a hurry, unless I'm up for a struggle.
Cheap and Effective 5
Lela from MN
I like the tip on this eyeliner, applies smoothly. I don't have to swipe over the same area again and again to apply it. It doesn't clump or peel. I like it much better than a similar type of eyeliner I bought that was E.L.F. brand.
Not pleased 2
Jbamb from Idaho
It took several swipes for the eyeliner to be dark enough, and even once it dried it smudged and flaked on my upper lids and eyeshadow even with a primer. Would not recommend
NOT MY FAV ... 1
AWTIZ7 from MICHIGAN
I GOT THIS THINKING IT WOULD BE A GOOD ALTERNATIVE TO STLIA AND MAN WAS I WRONG. MAYBE SOME PEOPLE HAVE BETTER LUCK BUT THIS APPLICATOR WAS HARD AND HURT MY EYES AND THE FORMULA WAS SO THIN IT DROPPED INTO MY EYE!
Skinny eyeliner 4
Shoe queen 2 from Nashville NC
Will take me practice to get it as close to lashes as I want This is easy to get a cat eye or uplift. I like that with practice you can get a thin line. I don't need a thick line with my hooded eye
Dry and ink exploded out when trying to revive 1
Stella from Kent, WA
I was really hopeful for this product was sadly disappointed. The applicator is great, but is the only redeeming aspect of this product. The liquid would not come out of the marker tip so I gave it a few shakes and the ink came out all at once, completely ruining the product. Do not recommend unless you want your eyeliner dry and explosive.
Exactly what I expected 5
Ultafan from Leesburg, VA
I am not an expert on eyeliner application, but this is easy to use and gives a fine line at my lash base for definition.
Perfect 5
Angel from San Antonio, TX
Makes the sharpest wing I've ever done easy to use my 13 year old loves It too
Tip is great, the product itself not so much 3
Jules from Boston MA
This is the exact opposite of their thats the point liner, the applicator on this is perfect but the formula just doesn't come through. Its so thin and see through and you can tell its not opaque even if you aren't standing close. Also you absolutely can't sweat at all in this or it will transfer. I'm also ghostly pale, so I can't imagine it would show up well on darker skin tones. Added a photo to prove I actually own this liner.
Probably not 3
Aya from New York
It is very easy to apply but is sticky for some reason