Product Reviews Rated 3.94 out of 5 stars
2993 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review most favourite lip liners!! NYX pencil lip liners are my absolute favourite. affordable yet so smooth, pigmented, and very long-lasting! also love supporting a cruelty-free brand. i see in previous reviews that there's a lot of confusion/disappointment regarding how one should sharpen them. the slide on lip pencils are not retractable, but rather have a plastic casing as opposed to the conventional wooden lip pencil. i heard NYX sells a sharpener specifically made for this purpose but i personally use the wet 'n' wild dual pencil sharpener and it works just fine (: hope this helps! NYX lip pencils will forever be my go-to!
Most Helpful Critical Review These were a hit or... These were a hit or miss for me. Out of the four that I purchased two were excellent and two were horrible. I got Taupe to use for my brows and it is the perfect match, blends like a dream and makes it super easy to fill in sparse areas. Yellow has great color payoff. However the Sky Glitter and Silver Glitter are just plain awful. The points break off immediately upon contact, even with the barest touch. I also found them difficult to sharpen. I'm willing to try many of the other colors though I'll hesitate before trying another of the glittery ones.
Reviewed by 2993 customers Wonderful formula, just not for me :( 5
Theresa from Bellevue
I think this product didn't work for me because I have oily skin? It went on just fine, very smooth and with beautiful color but the lines weren't sharp or believable after a couple minutes of wear. The lip lines went from sharp at first to blurred out after a few minutes of wear to the point where it looked like I had smudged my lips all over like a toddler with makeup. I do have oily skin especially around my mouth/chin area so maybe its just my skin type? I'll definitely stick to the hard pencil liners from NYX. The formula is wonderful and I can see why people would love it, unfortunately its too creamy for me.
Great color 5
Bingo from Binghamton NY
Easy to use
horrible 1
lese from surprise
lasted one time, horrible
awful 1
scribble liner from Massachusetts
The liner goes on chalky and not at all what i had wanted. I have ordered the pale pink and loved that look and effect but the store did not have that particular color in stock.I gambled and purchased the white. I tried it and looked terrible on with this color selection.
Great lower cost option 4
Jburrry from Atlanta
Lots of colors and lasts pretty well on the lips.
Love them 5
LR from Greeley
Glide on super easy& last a good amount of time!
Sugar glass is a dupe for Marc Jacobs' 'Nudist' liner 5
janedo from Maryland
A lot of lighter nude lip liners have orange undertones on my lips but this one doesn't. I was a loyal Marc Jacobs fan just for their lip liner in shade 'nudist' and was devastated it was discontinued. This shade is a pretty good dupe. ProTip for those saying it's a lot of money for such a small amount of product: you can sharpen this liner just like you would a regular lip pencil.
my favorite eyeliner! 5
jshanep from tennessee
great pigment, blends well, & doesn't budge throughout the day!! i have 4 colors and plan on getting more. worth every penny.
Doesn't measure up 2
Jessi O. from Worcester, MA
Very disappointing product. The color is beautiful but that's the only good thing about it. It's not very creamy so I had to press down hard to apply it.
The cover won't stay on. I prefer twist up liners anyway. Needless to say, I won't be repurchasing.
Goes on smoothly, nice color and wears well 5
Girl Marie from NH
Gave this a try for a more natural look with a dark brown instead of black and am pleased with the color, wear and application ease of this pencil
Love the green color for the holidays 5
Watson from Alabama
Love the green color for the holidays, I already have green mascara
Love this brand! 4
Mimsy from Arlington Virginia
Pretty colors goes on smooth
Been using this eyebrow shade as lip liner for 20 yrs 5
Jul from Whittier
Love it
Yes! 5
Bernie from New York
I use this on my brows, it's my fav
I wouldn't buy this again 1
nicole from seattle,wa
The color of the product In the pictures is way different than the color of the lip liner in person. I got the Cheeky color which looks to be a little bit of a darker purple with pink tones but I received a super light pink lip liner. and this was after them already forgetting to put the lip liner in my other package.
Don't Buy 3
TYP from OR
Horrible formula! It has a super chalky, crayon-like texture, and it does not last even 5 minutes. I bought the color Timid.
Love this Lip Liner 💋 5
Gia from Phoenix, AZ
This is my go to lip liner 😍 it's long lasting and goes on smoothly definitely will be buying more 💕
Great LIP liner 5
RN2007 from Alabama
I noticed a lot of reviews mentioning using on the eyes. I wouldn't recommend that as it's a lip liner. It's a fantastic lip liner. I don't think you can go wrong with an NYX lip liner. I love this formula and the suede matte formula as well. Beautiful LIP liner it glides on easily and lasts well on my lips.
Train the Cosmetic Specialist 1
Ms.B from Concord, NC
I asked the cosmetic specialist for a fine black eye liner and when I open the product it was not what I told her what I was looking for. If I lived closer I would have taken it back. Very disappointed.
Wonderful lip liner TERRIBLE PACKAGING 3
MakeupLove from Houston, TX
Please make this a twist up
Great eyeliner 5
Renee from Mentor OH
I really like this eyeliner. It goes on smoothly and lasts all day without smearing.
It was alright 4
Nana from Winchester
I had to go over few times for good pigment but expected since it's cheap wouldn't mind buying again for quality of price
Survived a Shower 5
Shan from CT
Great product at a great price. Liner has good longevity. As a test run, I applied it before taking a shower (did not wash / scrub my face in the shower) and it stayed on and still looked perfect coming out - so it's definitely waterproof. This has really amplified my day to day look and I love that I need not worry about it coming off. V happy with this purchase.
I would buy it again 5
Leslie from Tampa
Store clerk
read… just read 5
one who looks at product details from Virginia
It is A LIP LINER Y'ALL! I'm literally shaking my head right now reading some of these reviews. Stop using it on your eyes and wondering why it's tugging so hard! It is for your LIPS!!! It doesn't last on day on your eyes because it is a LIP LINER. This stuff is the business when used in the proper area.
