Rated 4.39 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great sheer color!
I got the Butterscotch color and it looks and feels great! True to color, super comfortable, and long-lasting just like their Velvetines.
Most Helpful Critical Review Dried My Lips Way Out
I wanted to love this lip product, I really did. I've followed Lime Crime's social media for a while. When I saw that Ulta was carrying Plushies I thought, "What better way to try something new than to earn points with the purchase?" I followed the recommendations to exfoliate my lips, apply a lip balm, apply the Plushies, then pat down. It looked amazing for about 2 minutes then immediately left my lips looking super parched. I knew going in that the result aims to be a powdery-stain finish. But this is way too dry + uncomfortable on my lips.
Reviewed by 157 customers Color is completely off
Grace from CA
I ordered Milk Tea, a sheer mauve but instead I received a deep gray toned brown instead. If you decide to order please order from Ulta and not LimeCrime because LimeCrime has horrible customer service.
Tay from Tampa, FL
I really like that this gloss lasts longer than other glosses I've tried but it does need a layer of clear gloss on top because it made my lips look dry.
Heather from USA
I love the velvetines, they are my go to liquid lipstick formulas. So I wanted to try this. I do like it, I got the shade rosebud and it's beautiful and easy to wear everyday. It's not as long lasting as a velevetine but more long lasting than lipstick. It's kind of in between and soft. I'm definitely prefer the velvetines for pinks and nudes. But I would probably prefer this in a red shade as it be a little more subtle and soft than a vibrant liquid lip
Favorite Brand for Lips
Nora from Berkeley
My favorite by far.I like the other like crime products too but Rosebud in the Plushies like, I stock up on.
Had to learn how to use it and wait till it dries, never smudge it just dab it and always get overflow off the teeth. Once I got the hang of it it doesn't rub off and it has great coverage.
The BEST liquid lipstick
dailydaisyrose from Texas
My favorite lipstick-ever. I've tried many liquid lipsticks looking for the perfect one, many too dry, too heavy- etc etc- but this one is by far superior. It's so lightweight you forget you have it on, and it's very transfer proof, even under masks. The colors are sheer and soft, very lovely for finding your everyday lipstick shade. Butterscotch is the perfect shade I keep rebuying- but I would definitely love to see more shades added by them in the future!
Love the color and feel
Sammie from Mississippi
So to start, I have a light complexion with pink undertones, and I gravitate more towards berry colors, so Lavender Honey is what I got. I absolutely love the color. It goes great with my skin, isn't too dark. I feel like I can wear it with everyday looks or more dressed up looks, so it's a versatile color. But what I LOVE about this lipstick is the way it feels. It's not drying. I normally apply chapstick before lipstick, but with this stuff, even if I forget that step or am in a rush, my lips don't feel dry. I like the way matte lipsticks look, but usually hate the way they make my lips feel, but this feels like you don't have anything on, at least in my opinion. I find that it stays on well, doesn't transfer after it's dry, even while eating and drinking. I've been looking for a new fav lipstick ever since having trouble finding the Too Faced Melted liquid lipstick in the color Fig (not sure if it's been discontinued or what), and I stumbled across this when it was on sale. This is officially my new favorite!
Sheer and pigmented
Shelby from TN
I love this, I got the berry one and it gives that super popular popsicle lip look.
Alyssa from Atlanta
I absolutely love this. Lightweight, no transfer and stays on all day. Which as a mom with a toddler, that's exactly what I need. If I had to gripe about one thing, the initial smell is really strong. It goes away pretty quickly but it just kinda surprised me the first time I used it.
Favorite Lipstick Formula
Emaline from Indy
I bought the shade Marmalade, a sheer peach. It is a pretty color definitely less orange on lips than it appears in tube. Applies nicely and it's a nice nude for pale skin.
Formula is really comfortable - not thick at all
Hannah from Oklahoma
Love this formula. I only have one shade but i'm looking to get more. Definitely one of the more comfortable lip sticks i've tried.
No mask transfer!
Zoom teacher from Rosemead, CA
Perfect color. Stays on under a mask. It lasts all day. Eating and drinking are no problem. Dries quickly with no stickiness.
Stays on but super dry
SS from Massachusetts
This would easily be my absolute favorite lipstick ever if it weren't so drying. It goes on sheer so you can build up the color. It stays on FOREVER, like way longer than all the other liquid matte lipsticks I own. And the cherry soda color is just so pretty, it's really flattering. It's just so crazy drying that I only wear it on special occasions when my lips are 100% hydrated and ready.
Liza from Wisconsin
I've always been interested in this brand and now this is my favorite lipstick. Goes on very easy, easy to clean up, and dries perfectly matte. Amazing tbh, never been so impressed by a liquid lipstick.
Buildable, beautiful coverage
Nate from US
The first thought I had when I bought this was wow, this packaging is adorable - as I'm a huge sucker for cute packaging and products. Because it is matte, I suggest using a lip scrub for best application, especially if you have dry lips like mine. The Blackberry shade has a fruity, berry-like scent, and I will update this when I receive Milk Tea. It applies like a gloss and it gives you a moment to clean up if you accidentally apply too much. After it dries, the color lightens very slightly, giving a translucent overlay to your natural shade, and turns matte. I have not eaten with it on yet, but it stays on when I touch it with my fingertips. So far I am satisfied with it, but if you are sensitive to scents then this is not the best option for you!
my favorite lipstick!
jade from ohio
limecrime will always take the cake for my favorite lip products < 3
the best liquid lipstick
Marsha09 from New York
This is my absolute favorite. Wears nice, feels great & lasts all day
PLEASE NEVER stop making this
Aurayne from Pittsburgh, PA
I have tried so many liquid lipsticks & even love the matte Velvetines by Lime Crime. HOWEVER, these Plushies are the most comfortable liquid lipstick I've ever tried. They look matte but super soft on the lips and they do stay on for hours. obviously anything oily that you eat will make them come off sooner.
I have these in 6 shades now & I want them all.
They are pretty opaque on the first layer yet not extremely bold but I will say, sometimes adding a second layer for more boldness is needed. Still, its an excellent liquid lipstick.
You get comfort, soft matte look, lasts hours & it is easy to get that soft diffused look (how they are advertised) or add a small second layer for more boldness.
these are FANTASTIC
Aurayne from Pennsylvania
I have tried millions of matte liquid lipsticks. While I do love the Matte Velvetines, I wanted to try these. SOO glad I did. These Plushies are my favorite! Super, super comfortable & long lasting. They somehow make your lips look soft and matte but not dry. And trust me I've put these one when I was lazy and forgot to moisturize my lips. They still looks great and also do not feel drying AT ALL.
I bought the colors Dragon Fruit which is beautiful, Lavender Honey (a staple! holy moly its gorgeous & super wearable), Milk Tea & Chocolate Milk. Chocolate Milk is insanely flattering for a soft nudey light-medium brown. Not too light on me but not too dark. perfect nude brown shade. (I'm a Fenty Beauty 140, so like a light complexion with yellow undertones for reference).
Julianna from Rochester NY
Love this lipstick! doesn't feel too drying which is my biggest complaint with most liquid lipsticks. My favorite shade is lavender honey it's absolutely stunning. i also love how well this stays put on the lips i drink water, kiss my boyfriend, apply lip gloss etc and it's still holding up!
Jukie from Helotes, Texas
I love this! It doesn't feather or feel heavy in the lips
My favorite everyday lip
Jess from Dallas, Tx
The shade butterscotch is my favorite!! That shade looks like my natural lip shade. I use it as my everyday lip & I am in love with the formula. I have to constantly hydrate and exfoliate my lips and I like that this product does not dry out my lips but stays on a good amount of time.
Milk tea is the best color
K from North Carolina
This product is amazing, I love the plushie lipsticks. They are comfortable, they are light, they are not super heavy on my lips. It looks a lot more of a natural wash of color then a bold lip.
I own so many of the colors and cannot say enough.
I am a HUGE fan !!!!
Boba from Nyc
For starters, I absolutely love lime crime. I have so many of thier products. All of them are amazing and such perfect shades. Specially i love these the most
I have the shades
Milk tea- light warm nudeish brown. Literally looks like milk tea
Rosebud- light dusty pink. Not bright at all. Its like a warm pink nude. Its not dark or tacky. Its light and soft.
Turkish delight- a little warm. A mix between milk tea and rosebud. Mauve.
Lavender honey- one of my favorites, this color is just like rose bud, but a little darker and more pinkish. Still warm and soft.
Chocolate milk. - a nice warm nude dark brown. Not too dark not to light, but definitely a good choice if you want something on the darker side
Cola- a earthy brown. Sorta red, a browner version of brick.
Jam- a dark red, but its also sorta brown. This color is unique and is a brown with a hint of red. Sorta like a red wine or a brick, but a nudeish. It is so nice and isnt your typical dark red. Its also not too dark. Its also soft, not clashy or tacky or too dark or bright.
This product isnt too drying. I have many liquid and matte lipsticks but this is my fave. It stays on all day no matter what. If i drink, eat or wear a mask. It also doesn't leave my lips too dry. I sometimes put on something hydrating before and after if i need.
The color usually needs only one coat. I never have to go more than two. It shows up nicely without being needed to blot. If u want a lighter or more of a tint look then you can blot it, and still get nice color.
Sometimes i have to take a q-tip and fix below and above my lips before i go out.
I highly recommend. Expecally if you love this brand like me, or are looking for a amazing liquid lipstick
color is waaaay off from picture
jackie from texas
i orderd milk tea expecting a nude-ish mauve, however it is literally dark muted purple!! and it's really sheer. it's still wearable just unexpected
I love these!
Bonbori from San Antonio
From the packaging to the shades, they are really nice if you are trying to stay in the "warmer" and "natural" shades. It definitely is a true matte, and sometimes I forget I have it on. Not the most hydrating lipstick, but look is very cute!