r.e.m. beauty Midnight Shadows Lustrous Liquid Eyeshadow

Most Helpful Critical Review

Incredibly bad product

I rarely write reviews but I had to for this because no one should waste their money. I got 3 different colors and the formula is a miss either way: either watery or too dry. It doesn't play well with other liquid or powder shadow and lifts anything you try to put underneath. The base colors disappe...ar and it's basically just the glitter you get left with, which I didn't expect based on the swatch photos. The applicator is incredibly incompatible with the formula and barely picks up any product. Literally had to redip and swirl the brush in the container 3-4 times per eye to get product out! And if you try to put it directly on the eye with the applicator, it takes away whatever glitter you already have on your eye resulting in uneven and patchy applications. The applicator is also super scratchy which is unpleasant to use on the eye lid. And to top it all off, the containers don't want to stay upright because they're slightly too rounded. I got these 50% during a steal sale and even then I'm tempted to return them.