Rated 4.14 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great Mascara
I have super straight lashes that normally do not hold a curl. The waterproof formula does an excellent job of holding the curl I get after using an eyelash curler. I used the regular formula before and I really liked the brush because it does a great job of separating your lashes, but it didn't hold the curl. So I tried the waterproof formula for the summer and I love it. The only problem is that it's hard to remove, but this is something that happens with most waterproof mascaras.
Most Helpful Critical Review Doesn't live up to the hype
I really wanted to love this mascara. I actually wore this mascara for two weeks and compared it with another brand before writing this review. Let's start with the claims, lengthens and gives a butterfly effect. Okay, it does lengthen, to the point where you cannot wear this mascara on your bottom lashes without looking like a freak show. Long lashes are great, but there is zero butterfly effect. I wasn't buying into that claim anyway because I have used 3 other mascara brands that utilize the identical wand and don't have that claim whatsoever. I purposely choose waterproof because I have very straight, hard to curl lashes. Waterproof mascara sets your lashes where washable does not. I applied my mascara at 7AM and by noon, they were almost straight again. This was a fail for me. This was a daily occurrence when I wore this mascara and I am not the type of person to walk around with an eyelash curler. I felt this formula was slightly too wet, and I couldn't seem to get enough product on the wand. One coat was similar to Great Lash mascara. Very natural, barely there. Just a subtle darkening. Two coats provided much more length and some volume, but not much. Three coats gave good length, not great, and a little more volume, but still not as much as other brands. My lashes didn't clump, nor did they get spidery with 2 or 3 coats. Just as a test, I did trying wearing this mascara with just 1 coat to see if the curl would last. It didn't. Same with two coats and I think the reason is because this mascara is very soft. Even with three coats on, your lashes aren't the slightest bit stiff. That being said, this is a great mascara for me to use when I'm wearing false eyelashes. I always apply my mascara first and eyeliner first, then my lashes. A stiff mascara gets in the way of my lash application, where this one does not. Major bonus there. The point of me looking at this mascara was for me to get away from wearing the false lashes daily. I still have to wear them with this mascara, not so with other brands. This mascara also has a shiny gloss to it, which annoys me. If you love shiny mascara and have lashes that hold curl well, then this is a great product. For me, it's not. I will use it will falsies until it's gone, but I probably won't purchase again. Seems a waste to only use it on weekends, and then still have to use another mascara for my bottom lashes. I'm on the fence with this one. I really want to like it, but it didn't live up to the hype.
Reviewed by 204 customers I like it
TT from Rochelle Illinois
Danielle from Detroit, Mi
Only mascara I will use. I have eyelashes that fall flat and this is the only mascara that after crimping and applying doesn't fall flat. Super black color, adds length and volume. Only brush I've ever used that I can apply over and over to build up and it doesn't create clumps!
Tried this for the first time. Very nice product.
MaryKwrites from San Diego
Wanting a mascara that doesn't flake or smudge, so am hoping I've found it at last.
MY FAVORITE MASCARA
Webkinz Diva 1 from Houston, TX
I have used this product since the first day they offered it and I LOVE IT. I get so many compliments on my eyes and I know it's because of the Mascara I wear.
Katherine from I
I love this mascara! With this mascara my lashes can reach my eyebrows! Not in a bad way, in a beautiful lengthy way. I always wipe off the extra product inside the tube because you do get a lot that comes out and having less on the wand helps it separate and length. It will clump your lashes together if you have too much product, but just wipe some off and your all good. I layer the Lash Paradise on top of this mascara and It's so pretty.
Love this mascara
Abbie from Pennsylvania
This mascara is amazing I love it for my upper and lower lashes and I love that it's waterproof stays on all day but I will say it's a little tough taking it off but nothing you can't handle would recommend!
Andie from Texas
I have used this mascara for over a year. I use the waterproof since I have straight eyelashes that will NOT hold a curl with regular mascara. I love this product because it separates and lengthens my eyelashes and adds a little volume. I apply two coats and it lasts all day!
Stays Put All Day
Picky about Mascara from Belvidere, IL
Lasts all day without running, but removes easily with makeup wipe. Doesn't clump. Wand reaches all the small eyelashes.
Doodles from Stuart fl
I put a base coat on then use this product, it separates the lashes
I like it okay.
None from Robertsdale, Alabama
I like this okay but it doesn't separate my lashes like I had hoped. It slightly clumps as well.
Beautiful lashes! No need for the expensive stuff!
Linda B. from Fountain Valley, Ca.
My esthetician told me about this. I was using another brand that I liked, but tried it and liked it much better! No need to buy expensive mascara brands. This is great!
Rhi from Tx
The brush is designed to flare in the right places and it does a great job for evenly distributing product to all of my lashes.
My favorite mascara!!!!
Danishaa from San diego
Best mascara ever!!
stranded from Midwest
Clumps like crazy. Dries quickly on the brush which makes it difficult to apply. Bottom lashes look great but top tend to just stick straight out.
Best mascara out there!
Shawna from Hillsboro/Beaverton, Oregon
I learned about this mascara while watching one of Kim kardashians makeup artist online state this was her fav so I decided to try it. I've now tried and only buy this mascara because it lengthens my lashes and the brushes unique shape makes it easy to apply without having to use a lot of product.
It was ok
Annette from Denver colorado
It was ok
I love this product!!
Sky from Saginaw, MI
This is my first time buying this mascara, and it is so amazing! I have to apply a lot because I have short, thin, blonde eyelashes and this product doesn't clump at all! My eyelashes look so long and beautiful! Will buy again when I run out!
Steph19 from Fl
I don't understand why people don't talk about this more. I LOVE this mascara!!! I have oily skin and this stuff DOES NOT BUDGE. The brush definitely has a learning curve but once you get the hang of it, its amazing. I use the normal front side to apply, the skinny back comb to comb product through and lengthen and then the side of the brush to thicken and add volume. I always get compliments on my lashes! The only downside is the tube doesn't last long. I use a ton of mascara and can go through a tube in a couple weeks. But for the price, you can't beat it. I tell everyone about this product. You have to try it!
Valerie from Virginia Beach
I LOVE this mascara! I have sensitive eyes and have struggled to find a product that really does something for my lashes without irritating my eyes. The brush takes a little bit of practice to get used to, but the results are fantastic! I curl my lashes beforehand, then apply a light coat to the tops/back of the lashes with the tiny side of the bursh, then use the longer side of the brush and do upward strokes on the front of my lashes. I hold the brush in place for a few seconds to help the curl set and give a lifted effect. This mascara easily removes with waterproof makeup remover and does not require excess rubbing. My lashes look fuller and defined with this mascara. For a more dramatic look, I apply the Butterfly mascara first and let it dry for a minute, then use L'Oreal Voluminous Carbon Black on the tips.
Mamacakes from Colorado Springs
I love this! Holds goid all day!
Been wanting a mascara that's for my upper & lower lashes
Drea from Modesto ca
Cindy from Chesapeake
Loved it 😍
This is the only mascara that I use
Desiree from Louisiana
Four stars because it does dry out quickly but for the price it is great
By far the worst
Watery Eyed Girl from Indiana
I have very watery eyes, so I only use waterproof mascaras. I was on the search to try out a new mascara and found this one. By far the worst "waterproof" mascara I've ever tried. Smudged under my eyes within 1 hour.
a real butterfly
velia g from McAllen
Its my favorite mascara ever. I tried others and always come back.