Rated 4.34 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The best!
This is truly the best mascara I have ever used. I like SB Indecent Exposure Mascara and Full Exposure Waterproof Mascara but this new mascara beats them all. It literally does everything it's states but I do curl my lashes and use an eyelash primer (not SB brand). My lashes are curled and thin so when I do all these steps(curl, prime, color), they stretch out very long. I have been using this mascara up against all my other ones by various brands and this one has won so far, even up against my Ives Saint Laurent, Lancome and Urban Decay. With each one, I have thrown them out because this mascara is so much better. Now, I usually use waterproof versions because my skin is dry and I use heavy moisturizer around my eyes, which cause my mascara to smudge often, but this mascara has held up. The only other mascara I have that is on par with this one is Estée Lauder Sumptuous Extreme waterproof which I will keep and use. This mascara takes a couple of coats to add volume since it is not advertised as a volume mascara but a fan mascara. It stays soft so you can build intensity. Estée Lauder's is a one and done mascara but it is a dryer formula. I can't say enough about how good this mascara is and the price is fantastic also, very affordable. Give it a try, you will love it too.
Most Helpful Critical Review Just Ok
This concealer is a little to thin for me. I have dark circles under my eyes and I have to use too many layers of concealer to get them fully covered. Also I had to buy three different colors just to finally match my skin tone. SB 24 hour cc spot concealer worked better for me. Me and wand concealers just don't get along.
Reviewed by 1693 customers Love this product, It is perfect for me
Boni from North Carolina
Love this product, it does not cake
Me from Somewhere in the US
I received this and it was full of mildew so now I see why they were having a sale...thanks Ulta 👍🏼
Absolutely love this mascara
Necie from Meridian Ms
I don't wear false lashes but this mascara makes your lashes so full and pretty that I don't need too.
Yep, they get compliments
NikkiA from IL
First time trying this mascara and I'm a big fan. I have natural long eyelashes,. Finding a mascara that doesn't clump on my lashes is always the issue. I always turn back to loreal telescopic, but this mascara is the first I might consider spending the extra bucks on. Since wearing it, I have got several compliments on my lashes more so than I do, lol. So I think this is going to be my new go to mascara!
Hasn't failed me yet!
Mandee from Illinois
I have never been disappointed by a Smashbox mascara and this one hasn't failed me yet! I absolutely love how it performs and I haven't had any issues with flaking or clumping!
Love the brush; wish I could love the formula
Miss Kendra from California
I really wanted to love this product. The first few uses were exactly as expected. The brush helped me fan out my lashes and reach the hard-to-reach corners. The formula was thin and easy to apply. However, after two or three uses, the formula became thick and clumpy. I tried to heat the bottle in a glass of warm water in hopes of thinning it out, but the mascara became a paste that was really difficult to use.
Overall really nice
kate from ky
I really do like this product, the only reason why I gave it 4 stars is because you have to go in with powder quickly after applying it because it will crease (under eye area primarily). Otherwise, it has a really nice consistency and is pretty full coverage. I've gone through 2 bottles already because I love it so much.
Love this mascara!
Jill098 from Colorado
I got this mascara on sale to try out and love it! Great application and fans out lashes with full, even coverage. It is a great pigment and buildable if desired. The tube is a metallic substance (I warm my all of my mascaras under my arm or in my hands just before application for a smoother consistency) so this one is a bit chilly, but the results can't be beat!
. from :)
i love this mascara! i've been using it for 1 year now and it's my favorite mascara. i also love smash box in general!
Mindy from Horsham, PA
I've tried so many mascaras from high end to drugstore brands, and this is the best I've found so far. It makes your eyelashes look fantastic after just one coat. I would highly recommend.
Miranda from PA
I have very short lashes and this mascara gave them length without the clumpiness
LOVE this mascara!!!
Jan from Fernley, NV
I have severe allergies to almost all mascaras, this is the ONLY one that doesn't hurt my eyes and no redness either!!! I'm so EXCITED to have found a mascara I can use!!! Plus I love how smooth it goes on.
Love the lash separation.
annabanana from IL
I was excited to get Super Fan mascara. I really like the consistency, color, and separation it gives. It does lengthen but was hoping for more drama. I've been looking for drama similar to Essence princess lash because it can smudge (yes, princess lash does come in waterproof but it's remnants can last a couple days. uhg!) Used to swear by IT superhero but last tube I got was so globby. All in all I do like Super Fan and will wear it.
My favorite of all time!
Melissa mom of 2boys from Vegas
This mascara really lengthens and coats every lash, I have tried tons of mascaras throughout the years and this is now my new favorite. The brush holds a lot of the mascara, I've had so many other wands/brushes that barely added anything to my lashes but this one gives them a great coat!
Love this mascara!
DM from Melbourne, Fl
I have been looking for a mascara that goes on smooth and doesn't clump besides Lancôme Definicilsand I found it!
Lilbunny from Velva ND
Great coverage matches my hard to match skin tone
Love this mascara
Adge from Newtown, PA
I love this brand but the last couple of times I've bought it, it's been clumpy!
I would buy again and again
Elle from South Texas
I immediately regret not buying 2 on sale. This was my first time using this brand and I was blown away. I have short lashes and I don't really like to use an eyelash curler. But using this mascara really brings them out. I will purchase again.
Very good mascara!!
Amy from Los Angeles, CA
I have very small lashes and this mascara really makes my eyelashes look a lot longer, it's amazing.
The brush is not too thick which is also a plus!
THE BEST MASCARA I'VE EVER USED
SOUTHERN BELLE from EAST TEXAS
I ordered every brand that was on sale for Black Friday. There are a couple I haven't tried yet but only because after using this I am now a customer FOREVER! I rank it #1 & I've used many prestige brand mascaras.
Love this product
C. Fry from Lima,OH
I love using this as a base mascara to help fan out my lashes to prepare for a thicker mascara!
Hannah from Dallas, TX
This mascara comes out in clumps on the want. Impossible to get an even coat on your lashes. This just does nothing for you and I will not repurchase. It's almost like it's missing the scraper at the top of the tubers scrape the excess mascara off the wand. I'd give zero stars if I could.
Heavy and Clumpy
katferg from Indiana
I wanted to like this mascara. I bought it because of the brand and it was on sale. It is heavy, clumpy, and takes a long time to dry. It does not have a natural look. I do not recommend.
Clumps in Bottle After 1 Week
Elisabeth from Grand Rapids, MI
The first two times I used it I LOVED it- my lashes looked long, curled, and dark! But after just one week there are already big clumps in the tube, which make is so difficult to apply it well. I have been applying it to clean lashes, not layering on top of old makeup, so I don't know what the problem is. Very disappointing!
Better than average
Colorado HRD from COLORADO
I bought this because it was on sale and Mr regular brand want available. No flaking. Very good coverage with no clumps. My biggest struggle with mascara is keeping it from giving my raccoon eyes. This mascara was better than any drug store brand I've tried but I still had some dark color bleed under my eyes after long days. I will use this on my top lashes but probably not on the bottom lashes