Product Reviews Rated 3.63 out of 5 stars
38 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review new fav for me Bought this without thinking because I needed a new mascara and I'm so glad I did! Mascara is really personal to everyone and I found that most mascara is very drying on me to the point where a number of them just straight up fall off every night when I remove it with the gentlest cleansing oils. I've been using this one for a month now and have noticed significantly less fall out as well as just better lash health over all. My eyelashes feel like they can stand a chance now with tugging and curling instead of just falling off and landing on my eyeball from a single blink (ouch!). When it comes to the formula, it is very creamy and can be a little too much if you don't blot before application. It does dry a bit faster than some covergirl máscaras I'm used to so careful when applying more than one coat since I'm sure that was what caused some complaints on here with the flaking. I only apply one coat since I prefer the minimalist look and have absolutely no flaking. There is a bit of a learning curl as all mascaras have and it al depends on what you prefer. I've noticed this brand overall celebrates a more natural look (think of a more leveled up glossier with a bit of coverage) so less is always more when it comes to application. If you're the type that likes to apply coat after coat, this may not be for you.
Most Helpful Critical Review Glory Review: Lacks volume, fragrance gives me a headache The Too Faced Waterproof BTS mascara has been the best mascara I have tried. However, I'm currently in search for a replacement that is not waterproof as to not continue damaging my lashes. My lashes have pretty good length and stay curled ....... until I apply mascara. I need volume and a mascara that doesn't weigh my lashes down.
First of all, this mascara is strongly fragranced, smells like amplified hotel bar soap. The smell lingers for about an hour and gives me a headache. It didn't give me volume and although it didn't weigh my lashes as much as other high end mascaras it wasn't great either. The brush is very similar to the BTS mascara. I tried it over the Milani lash primer, this helped with the volume but I won't keep it because of the fragrance.
Reviewed by 38 customers MY GO-TO MASCARA 5
Nat from South Carolina
I have struggled for YEARS trying to find a good mascara that would make my lashes longer & thicker & this is the ONE. I absolutely love it & it doesn't smear. 10/10 recommend!
Not for me 1
Mermaid from Georgia
Avoid this if you have allergies. Made my lash line itch and the smell is so bad. Also it was a nightmare trying to remove it… to much pulling and tugging at me eyes. I'm glad I got this as a sample and didn't pay for it.
Yes 5
Dee from Seminole FL
My favorite mascara ever
Great mascara 4
RS from CA
This is some of the best mascara I have ever used. It is volumizing and last all day. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is because literally every single time I try to buy it, they're out of stock. Clearly, this is something Ulta should have more of.
Um, wow! 5
JJ from AZ
My favorite mascara currently! This mascara is soft and doesn't clump, which is rare in a volume mascara! It honestly nourishes your lashes and washes off fairly easy. I'm not a huge thickening and volume mascara fan but I love this one! It doesn't smudge too bad, but if you wear a setting spray you won't have a problem! It's great for those days you want to go "natural".
Great mascara 5
Christy from Southern California
I got this in an IPSY bag and love it. It goes on easily, builds easily and quickly. Makes my lashes pop and I have thin and short lashes. I like that it's not a very thick formula. I would compare the wand to Better Than Sex but I like this formula better.
My new favorite overlooked mascara! 5
Christy from Louisiana
I bought the travel size item of this or maybe I got it in a makeup bag. I'm not sure but I'm here for the regular size tube! It last all day and it spreads my lashes because the best part NO BUILD UP! When I wash my face it comes off without running down my face. Love this one!
The BEST mascara out there!! 5
Hot Mess from Florida
This product is amazing! Really lengthens and volumizes lashes without clumping.
I've searched and searched for mascara that works but is reasonably priced.
Love! Love! Love!
FAN FREAKING TASTIC 5
Doc from Dayton,ohio
Who new a mascara that smells this good could also perform so well. Very lengthening and thickening. Tends to get dry after awhile
Amazing mascara, terrible scent! 4
Dannie from Maine
I absolutely ADORE this mascara and I have tried a lot of them!! I just wish they would make an unscented version. And then this would be a holy grail mascara for me!
Even my sparse lashes look amazing! 5
unseeliepixie from St Augustine,FL
I have sparse lashes, especially on one side, and this mascara is amazing! Even on the very sparse side, it makes my lashes noticeable and even on both sides.
Great length/volume- horrible scent!! 3
Sensitive nose? from Chicago, IL
I received this product in my Ipsy bag. When I first put it on, I was like "Yes! This mascara is amazing! I'm totally going to buy more!". But, as I left the bathroom after putting on my make-up, I was like, "What is that rose scented, old grandma perfume smell?" I couldn't figure it out. Then, the next day I put the mascara on again, and I realized that it's the scent of the mascara! I've never known a mascara to actually have a "scent". It literally smells like cheap, rose scented, old grandma perfume - the kind that give you a headache. I had to put body spray on my neck just to over power this horrible scent while I was at work. Change the scent and you will have an amazing product people!!!!
I might get this again 5
VCR from san diego,ca
I have stick straight, slightly pointing downward lashes. Typically only waterproof mascara holds a curl for me, but sometimes it doesn't and it's impossible to remove. This mascara is really nice; I got the mini. It gives me mad volume and holds a small curl. Nothing major, but the volume and length it gives is GREAT!. The scent I like, but I don't think mascara should have a scent, especially bc it could cause allergies and irritation in the long run. I might purchase this again. The mini bc full size I feel is a waste tbh.
Am going to buy more 5
Libs from Denver
I really like this mascara. My favorite.
I am looking for this at Ulta but out of stock 4
Cat from SoCal
I used for Smokey eye with eyeliner.
Loved the Look, Hated the End Result 2
Brooke from Pittsburgh, PA
I loved the way this mascara made my lashes look, and it held the volume, lift, and length throughout the day. The HUGE fail for me was that it smudged all the way down under my eyes at the outer corners at some point during the day. It's freezing cold here and I wasn't sweating or really even running around doing anything. BIG deal breaker.
Stinks like old lady perfume! 1
Nina from New Orleans
Don't add perfume to eye makeup! It's really bad when you can smell your eyelashes and like other people have mentioned, it's giving me a headache. There is NOTHING nourishing about this mascara. I'm throwing this out!
WHY ADD PERFUME??????? 2
Holly from Hollywood
Love the formula but the scent ruined it for me. I had an unpleasant allergic reaction to it. Why add perfume to cosmetics, especially eye makeup???????? Into the trash it goes.
Love -- Had to order full size! 5
Emmalee J from Statesboro, GA
Got the travel size of the mascara in my IPSY bag and had to come and order the full size! I'm hesitant about trying new mascaras, because once I find one I like, I tend to stick with it.
The first thing I noticed about the product was the smell! I've never had a mascara that smells good!! And unlike others, I only need one dip/application to achieve the drama that I like! I use the shimmy at the root & roll-up the lashes technique with this product and it works perfectly. 10/10!
Good mascara, awful fragrance 3
BPats from San Antonio
I really like the application of this mascara. Drama Bomb is an accurate name. I almost think I have falsies on. And, I think my natural lashes look fuller and longer since I've started using it. But... the fragrance. It's perfumed almost to a nauseating point. And boy does it linger. The fragrance kinda dissipates if you use it every day. But if you're a once-a-week wearer, it's always going to be rough. I probably won't repurchase, but I'll finish it.
Glory Review: Lacks volume, fragrance gives me a headache 1
Glory from California
The Too Faced Waterproof BTS mascara has been the best mascara I have tried. However, I'm currently in search for a replacement that is not waterproof as to not continue damaging my lashes. My lashes have pretty good length and stay curled ....... until I apply mascara. I need volume and a mascara that doesn't weigh my lashes down.
First of all, this mascara is strongly fragranced, smells like amplified hotel bar soap. The smell lingers for about an hour and gives me a headache. It didn't give me volume and although it didn't weigh my lashes as much as other high end mascaras it wasn't great either. The brush is very similar to the BTS mascara. I tried it over the Milani lash primer, this helped with the volume but I won't keep it because of the fragrance.
new fav for me 5
ricebean from USA
Bought this without thinking because I needed a new mascara and I'm so glad I did! Mascara is really personal to everyone and I found that most mascara is very drying on me to the point where a number of them just straight up fall off every night when I remove it with the gentlest cleansing oils. I've been using this one for a month now and have noticed significantly less fall out as well as just better lash health over all. My eyelashes feel like they can stand a chance now with tugging and curling instead of just falling off and landing on my eyeball from a single blink (ouch!). When it comes to the formula, it is very creamy and can be a little too much if you don't blot before application. It does dry a bit faster than some covergirl máscaras I'm used to so careful when applying more than one coat since I'm sure that was what caused some complaints on here with the flaking. I only apply one coat since I prefer the minimalist look and have absolutely no flaking. There is a bit of a learning curl as all mascaras have and it al depends on what you prefer. I've noticed this brand overall celebrates a more natural look (think of a more leveled up glossier with a bit of coverage) so less is always more when it comes to application. If you're the type that likes to apply coat after coat, this may not be for you.
Decent Mascara 3
Ant B from TX
It adds great volume, however, it doesn't hold a curl. It's worth purchasing on sale.
Another empty promise! 1
Micki from Jackson,MS
I am looking for a great mascara that doesn't clump, flake, smear ,looks natural but better. The 1st try of this mascara I thought it was great. The 2nd use I noticed large clumps. The 3rd try was worse, clumps, smears, tarantula lashes!!! I am frustrated, you can't fix lashes that are plastered together when you don't have time to redo your makeup!! I don't know what to believe .I've thrown out 20 mascaras in the last 2 years ,I really don't know what to buy. I need volume, length and absolutely no clumps, smears or smudging. HELP!
Would be a great mascara if it didn't transfer... 2
Jes from Chicago, IL
I loved this mascara the moment I applied it. It's very lengthening and volumizing, as indicated. Unfortunately, less than 2 hours after application, I have mascara transferred and flaked below my eyes. Granted, I have bad allergies and my eyes do tend to water, but I wonder if this formula never fully dries down. On the flip side, it does wash off very easily. I will stick with my other brands that I know won't transfer.
