Product Reviews Rated 4.12 out of 5 stars
473 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Shine bright with theses eye shadows Lord knows I was looking for a bright firey shadow that would do my under eye justice. The way the Shadow pop and matte up once dry is out of this world. Only shadows with deep bright pigment looks good on all skin tones . I love the quality of the makeup the pencils last long and shine bright. The shadows are long lasting and come in a array of colors. For everyday and every mood
Most Helpful Critical Review Sadly, no I have used the powder Urban Decay Roach shadow as my go to I'm sure for a decade. My favorite shade of all time and without doubt most asked about and most complimented. My Ulta did not carry it when I looked and offered this now instead. Not even close in color pallet! Regardless of how much one uses, it fades out to a nondescript beige shade that is nothing special at all. Sheen even goes away. This was a huge disappointment, especially if the powder version is truly discontinued. Other than being an acceptable texture, this in Roach color is a no fly.
Reviewed by 473 customers I wanted to like these! 2
CP from MA
I ordered 3 of these and I will say they are good for the lash line if you want a pop of color… but as for the lids this does not apply well… even with a primer it tugs on the lid and feels very sticky and Dries really quick.
Love the color...but 2
Suzanne from Midlothian, TX
Love the color and how it applies. I hate that it's incredibly sticky. Even with Urban Decay primer, my eyelids stick at the fold even when I blink. It's beyond irritating to be aware of your eyelids sticking together all day long. I suppose I could try to cover with some powder, but I don't want to change the color or cover up the shimmer. I was really wanting this to be an everyday type item, Unfortunately, it seems to just be a waste of money.
Disappointed 1
SanKO from undisclosed
The color isn't true to what's on the website, not happy!
Easy 2 Use 5
Brie026 from FL
I really like these eyeshadow sticks. They are so easy to blend and they don't move once set. I don't even use a brush. So easy to blend just use your fingers. I have 5 of them so far. I'm waiting for the others to come back in stock. As they are even out on the UD website as well.
I have bought this over and over!!! ❤ 5
Gm0067 from Rhode Island
Great buildable color, sheer to full.... mixes and blends well with other sticks as well as powder! Nooo cons about this product!!
These DONT budge! 4
Julia from Minnesota
Just like the name, these stay on 24/7! They are super creamy and blend well while still having a lot of pigment and lasting power. I swatched this on my hand in store and tried to rub it off to see if it would budge, nothing! Then went home and even washed my hands with soap and water, nope still didn't budge! I was impressed! The only thing is that they are pretty spendy, a good dupe would be the colourpop eyeshadow sticks for a cheaper alternative but if you want something a little more high end, definitely go with these!!
Great eye shadow stick 5
Lety from undisclosed
Urban decay doesn't disappoint me it's a great eye shadow stick that goes on smoothly and l love the color . I also like how it last all day .
Gorgeous 5
Karina Holt from undisclosed
Gorgeous colors and formulas. I love all these make up looks.
It is expensive but worth it 5
Lisa Y from Auburn Georgia
Already gave pros and cons above.
Shine bright with theses eye shadows 5
Im_mocha_ from Harlem NYC
Lord knows I was looking for a bright firey shadow that would do my under eye justice. The way the Shadow pop and matte up once dry is out of this world. Only shadows with deep bright pigment looks good on all skin tones . I love the quality of the makeup the pencils last long and shine bright. The shadows are long lasting and come in a array of colors. For everyday and every mood
Works Well 4
Antoinette70 from Columbia, MD
I really like this product: it does the job very well.
Great color! 5
Natbeauty from Wausau, WI
This has beautiful color and it has great staying power. I have used them as liner and shadow, works great either way. I have also been able to blend with just a tad bit of effort with a brush.
Love it 5
Karen D from Michigan
I love how smoothly it goes on and it wears nicely.
Fun! Cute! Love it! 5
Jennifer Israel from undisclosed
Love this perfect set! Makes an extra exciting look that lasts all day & night! Great price too!!!
Long lasting 5
Ash from Louisiana
These are beautiful and actually smudge proof. I swatched them on my hand and they didn't budge when I tried rubbing it off. Performs great on the eyes as well.
Not thrilled 3
Ekekela08 from Missouri
It's ok. doesn't spread really easily/smoothly.
It stays on! 4
heart light from Olympia, WA
This eyeshadow lives up to its promise. It lasts all day, and more.
The only reason it did not work for me was the color. In the store, the package looked more lavender color.
When I tried it on it looked like a very bold, loud blue; not my style.
I wish they had a lavender/periwinkle color!
They work well 4
Baylor from Austin, TX
I got the colors Deserted and Pop Off. They work well and last long but they're not life changing. I got on sale for half off which made it worth it but there are plenty of cheaper shadow sticks.
Very Sticky 1
Kit from Denver
Well, I certainly wanted to love this sticks! The colors are gorgeous! Unfortunately they cause my eyelid to stick together and I was reminded of the eyeshadow with every blink. I was so in love with the colors I bought several and I will have to return them all. Bummer!
Favorite go to and VEGAN❤️ 5
Brenda M from undisclosed
I love these! Colors are amazing! Love that they are waterproof. Easy and quick to put on when you're in a hurry.
The low rating is for color 3
Goldie0303 from SWFL
I'm not a smoky, dark eye type of gal simply b/c it's never a necessity for my lifestyle.
I can't use this as a cream eyeshadow but it makes a great upper eyelid liner.
Eyeshadow sticks- my go to 5
Goldie0303 from SWFL
I've recently decided to start using cream eyeshadow sticks b/c they're much quicker for me in the morning. Urban decay shadow stick lasts all day, blends with other brands and colors, and it looks perfect for the day time. At night before I wash my face, I use a Clinique make up remover to my eyes first to wipe the cream shadows off, then proceed to wash my face.
Left my eyelids dry and uncomfortable… 2
LaceyBean from Orlando, FL
Very drying- I was hoping for an easy all over color, but I found that my lids became dry and I felt the shadow with every blink. Primed my lids as usual with the UD primer potion. I'll still to powder or even cream eyeshadows from now.
Perfect for oily eyelids! 5
Crazy4cosmetucs from South Shore, MA
These shadow sticks are my favorite of all the brands I have ever tried! They go in easily, blend well, and once they set, they are set for the whole day. They stay on the waterline, they stay for tight lining, and they stay on my upper and lower lids. I use a lot of eye cream under my eyes so for these to stay there in place all day is nothing short of a miracle. So far I only have them in three colors, but I going back for more. Awesome!!
Ehhh 3
S&H from Stroudsburg PA
I'm not sure how I feel about this. I enjoy the concept, but the shadow does glide on like I expected it to. It almost feels like a crayon on your eyelid.