Product Reviews Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars
20 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review These Are Amazing! I ordered this duo from the Eyeko site, not knowing it was available at Ulta. I received a different Eyeko liner in my Ipsy bag, which sparked my interest in the brand, and I have never been more impressed with a mascara or liquid liner! The tip of this liner is ultra-fine, perfect for making the sharpest, thinnest of lines. The pigmentation is amazing... It makes the blackest, most completely opaque line I've ever seen. The mascara isn't waterproof, yet it holds up throughout my entire day or night without giving me raccoon smudges beneath my eyes, which is something I struggle with even with most waterproof formulas. The brush really does lift, curl, stretch, and separate the lashes, and the formula has that same super-black pigmentation as the liner. The only complaints for me, which I see as fair trade-offs, are that the mascara is more difficult to remove than most, and the large brush makes lower lashes a bit harder to do neatly without first wiping some of the product off on a tissue. I just ordered the Lash Boost fibers that complement this set, and I can't wait to try them out as well!
Most Helpful Critical Review didn't really see much of a difference I used both of these completely and almost religiously the first month I really tried to make my eyelashes grow and then the second month I used them once every day together in the morning when I did my makeup and I'd take maybe 1 day off. I like to brush my lashes and I feel the brushing of my lashes helped my eyelashes more than the actual mascara. (I used it about 3 months). Don't recommend unless you want to just moisturize your eyelashes a little bit.
Reviewed by 20 customers My favorite eyeliner and mascara duo!! 5
Angel from Alabama
Ever since I received a sample from Ipsy about 2 years ago, I have not used any other brand since. One of the best eyeliners and mascara that I've ever used.
So disappointed 1
Ashley from Maryland
Both wands were dried out the minute I opened them. I was so excited to try these but dried out mascara and eyeliner should not be making it to the consumer. Couldn't exchange in store since I bought online so I just gave up and bought a cheap mascara. I was so excited to try this but now I'm wary of buying it due to the quality I received without trying in person.
didn't really see much of a difference 2
Storm from Texas
I used both of these completely and almost religiously the first month I really tried to make my eyelashes grow and then the second month I used them once every day together in the morning when I did my makeup and I'd take maybe 1 day off. I like to brush my lashes and I feel the brushing of my lashes helped my eyelashes more than the actual mascara. (I used it about 3 months). Don't recommend unless you want to just moisturize your eyelashes a little bit.
Great set 3
Biki from San Francisco, Ca
Liked the set. It was handy and a great deal to have both in one set. I liked the pigmentation of the liner but it wasn't the easiest to get a proper line for me
Best of the Best♡♡♡ 5
Sarah D holla at me!!! from Va
This Eyeliner mascara duo Is the best purchase I have made in a long time♡♡ I love them both super long lasting and super black♡♡ Love these two♡♡
Two great items in one package! 4
Elee from Waterbury CT
This mascara is a favorite for volume and zero flaking.
Awesome product! 5
Mom on the go from West Branch, MI
I absolutely love the mascara and liner. I've tried many but Eyeko is the best. The liner goes on easily and stays on. The mascara lasts all day and is not clumpy and does not flake. This is now my "go to" brand.
Awesome product 5
Bilianska from Levittown, NY
Love the quality of it! And the pigment is really great!
Ok 3
Meggo from MO
The eyeliner applies easily but I have hooded eyes and this product transfers easily creating a raccoon look on me.
Will buy this again 5
Ashley from Louisville, KY
As a die hard fan of Tattoo liner I was thrilled to find this liner at ulta which was comparable in performance.
Best mascara and eyeliner ever! 5
RRichard from Holly Springs, NC
I love the fact that the mascara has Keratin and Shea Butter. This mascara lifts, curls and volumises my lashes. I apply one coat for a daytime look and two coats for a dramatic look. Therefore it's a very versatile product.
The eyeliner is amazing! The Widelash technology really promotes lash growth! My lashes are way longer than before using it. Lastly, the precision brush makes the application very easy.
Holy Grail 5
Mel from NJ
Big cat eyed liner is my everyday staple. For years I have been a die hard Kat Von D Tattoo Liner fan but trying the Black Magic liner just once I can never go back! The pigmentation is amazing, it lasts FOREVER (I once forgot to wash my makeup off, rubbed my eyes and while all my other makeup disappeared the liner didn't budge) but at the same time isn't hard to remove. The product itself lasts forever as well. I have had this one liner pen for the amount of time I would have gone through 2 Tattoo Liners by now and it is still going strong. Not to mention actually doing your liner with the super precise tip is a BREEZE. The mascara is also amazing! This is a super long review but honestly I cannot say enough good things about this product! Try it!
I would definitely buy the eyeliner again 5
ARA from Long Beach, CA
Haven't tried the mascara yet. The eyeliner works great, I also like how this has way more product than the stila liquid eyeliner. But I really love the calligraphy style brush, it is my favorite like the lorac eyeliner!
I will continue to use this product again and again 5
Seel from Cleveland
I use the mascara daily. I will apply it one time for just a simple look and if I want a little more volume I'll apply 2 coats. It lasts all day, doesn't flake and is easily removed with a make up remover wipe.
As for the eyeliner, I only use it a couple times a week for a more dramatic cat eye look. It glides on easily and the tip is fine enough that you can choose the level of drama you want.
Love this eyeliner 5
Miss from Rialto, Ca
This mascara works wonders on your eyes. It adds curled volume to your lashes without needing a lash curler. The eyeliner really is magic. You can build a dramatic cat eye or a swipe a quick wing. Totally versatile. The thin brush makes your job easier. This magic liner lasts all night long. Love it.
Love it! 5
GT from Sacramento, CA
Long lasting and great color
Wonderful product. 5
Purplegirl72 from Pittsburgh, PA
I really enjoy this product. It does not make my lashes dry or crispy. They feel conditioned. Both products have a lot of pigment and are long-lasting.
Love this stuff 5
Jessica from Grand Rapids mi
Easy to apply and long lasting
Love LOVE love love 5
T from Portland, or
I love the eyeliner! All of them! Easy to apply and perfection every time!!
These Are Amazing! 5
AprilAcuna from Longview, TX
I ordered this duo from the Eyeko site, not knowing it was available at Ulta. I received a different Eyeko liner in my Ipsy bag, which sparked my interest in the brand, and I have never been more impressed with a mascara or liquid liner! The tip of this liner is ultra-fine, perfect for making the sharpest, thinnest of lines. The pigmentation is amazing... It makes the blackest, most completely opaque line I've ever seen. The mascara isn't waterproof, yet it holds up throughout my entire day or night without giving me raccoon smudges beneath my eyes, which is something I struggle with even with most waterproof formulas. The brush really does lift, curl, stretch, and separate the lashes, and the formula has that same super-black pigmentation as the liner. The only complaints for me, which I see as fair trade-offs, are that the mascara is more difficult to remove than most, and the large brush makes lower lashes a bit harder to do neatly without first wiping some of the product off on a tissue. I just ordered the Lash Boost fibers that complement this set, and I can't wait to try them out as well!
