Product Reviews Rated 4.31 out of 5 stars
48 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Found my Liquid Liner! Pros:
1. The construction made it really easy to use just like a pencil.
2. The felt flexible tip made it the easiest to apply from any "brush" liquid liner applicator.
3. Formula was smooth and bold.
4. Great value for its price that I looked up (I received it for free in exchange for my honest feedback). Been using it for 2 weeks daily and I barely made a dent.
Con:
1. You can use it in your lower lid but it does smudge a bit more. So really more for your top lid.
Overall:
I am a busy mom of 2 toddlers and I love how quick and easy the Honest Company Black Liquid Eyeliner goes on. Its so much easier to handle than normal liquid liner especially because off the flexible felt tip. Its almost like using a felt tip marker. I found less is more and that wiping off the excess before applying made it go on smooth and gave you tons of control on the thickness of your line. I love the "winged look" and this gives me the pop I look for, for a 5 minute face that looks like I took 30 min. I love the matte black finish because I can wear it at night and it is also appropriate for work.
Highly recommend!
Most Helpful Critical Review Really Messy Bought this eyeliner because of the clean beauty claims but honestly had to stop using it after 4 uses. It's normal every now and then to mess up your liner when you're putting it on, we've all been there, but there was no way I could put this on without it getting messed up every. single. time. I tried again and again thinking it was me, but when I put on my usual Glossier liner it was so much easier and neater with no smudging. This liner is super runny, gets all over your eyelashes, and you spend more time fixing it with a q-tip and reapplying your eyeshadow. So frustrating. To top it off, when you take off the liner it's also super messy and your whole eye gets covered in black. Not sure why this has any good reviews, I really don't.
Reviewed by 48 customers Good Stuff 5
K from Texas
It just does what you want it to. It stays (haven't tried swimming in it yet but it's not waterproof so don't expect that). And it comes off when you want it to so I'm all good with it! Of course I don't like liquid liners as much but this is helping change my mind.
Wanted to like this 2
S from Los Angeles
I really wanted to like this eyeliner because of the brands philosophy and the cleaner ingredients. While it is a nice deep black shade, the liner will melt and get messy at the slightest exposure to moisture.
Really Messy 1
Tiffany from Austin, TX
Bought this eyeliner because of the clean beauty claims but honestly had to stop using it after 4 uses. It's normal every now and then to mess up your liner when you're putting it on, we've all been there, but there was no way I could put this on without it getting messed up every. single. time. I tried again and again thinking it was me, but when I put on my usual Glossier liner it was so much easier and neater with no smudging. This liner is super runny, gets all over your eyelashes, and you spend more time fixing it with a q-tip and reapplying your eyeshadow. So frustrating. To top it off, when you take off the liner it's also super messy and your whole eye gets covered in black. Not sure why this has any good reviews, I really don't.
Great but not for humidity or oily lids 4
jesslrus from Virginia
This eyeliner would probably last longer on someone who lives in a dryer climate or doesn't have oily eyelids. It lasts well and doesn't smudge when I wear it in the winter but in the hot summer, it can rub off easily. The applicator is really defined, I believe its a felt tip not a brush tip. Also, this liner smudges with tears and watery eyes.
Terrible 2
Jenny from GA
I love the brand, but the eyeliner does not stay on. I went to sneeze, and when I looked in the mirror some of it moved off the waterline. That was the end of that eyeliner.
Pleasantly Surprised! ✨ 5
Sascha from Washington
I've been wearing the cat eye look since high school, but I've recently started looking for a less smudgy liquid eyeliner. After going through about 6 different expensive brands I have found my go to with Honest Beauty. Not only does this eyeliner have a slim applicator that is great for small detail work, but it's less smudgy, and not sticky like other eyeliners. I also love that it's rated very well on the EWG Skin Deep database, meaning it is a very safe makeup product to use :) Overall a great product that I highly recommend!
This eyeliner gives me so much grief!!! 1
Tiger from NM
I am so annoyed with his eyeliner that I felt drawn to write a review about it. This stuff does not stay on at all, it's nice that it's cruelty free, but that's about it. God for bid you mess up and try to fix a tiny part…. All of it will smear across your face. This is ridiculous I will never use this product again.
Hidden Gem 5
Must have from Nevada
This liner is a steal! I was a little skeptical at first, as I am with any liner but honestly I will buy again and again. Super matte and it is easy to apply.
Wow, this is my favorite liner I've ever tried 5
Kat from Ky
I did not think I was going to like this, I hoped I would, but I never have good luck with liners.
It doesn't transfer or smear like other liners I've had previously, it's matte, very pigmented, and I can get a very precise line without much effort. I just love it!
Great Eyeliner 5
Noreen from Rosemead
Love this eyeliner! Recently bought this eyeliner and was instantly pleased when I tried it on. Mind you this was with out a full face of make up. Its super matte, dries down fast, great applicator, cute packaging, totally on point 🙌🏻
MATTE 5
Ang from Salem, OR
This is the best liquid liner I've used. Now I'll say this, if you haven't had a lot of practice with liquids just be careful. I always do big wings and thick liner and this was perfect. I hate when my liners say matte and they still have that shine to it. This truly is matte like dry matte yes but it doesn't crack. It's comparable to the ABH liner if not better. It doesn't get a bunch of liner on the felt tip tho the way the abh one does.
Fast dry 3
Ava from South Milwaukee
So you may be thinking, "fast drying is a good thing!" With this, it's not. Once it dried, it started cracking on my face and wouldn't stay. Not only that but it is SO hard to work with. It's almost impossible to do a small wing or anything other than a huge,fat wing. I really don't recommend buying this product.
amazing brush tip 5
amarie563 from US
if liquid liner is hard for you to apply you'll love this product. the easiest liquid liner to apply that i've ever used. the brush tip is amazing
Love it! 5
Nette from Drexel hill
Great eyeliner! Didn't budge or smudge all day
Best liner! 5
Kassadizzle from USA
Want a matte liner? Get this! I now use nothing but this liner every day. It dries matte and I find it easy to apply! It's also super black (which I appreciate).
Worth it! 5
Sam from Downey
Amazing eyeliner!!! It works really well and it's worth it's price point.
Almost the perfect eyeliner!!! 4
Lizawaz from San Diego, CA
I pretty much mentioned the highlights of the product in the pros & cons. Can Honest beauty pleaaaasssse change the applicator to something easier to apply a fine line? I spend a little extra time to make sure I don't mark my face and always have to use a cotton swab to clean up. I know it could be the user error but man, this would be the all time best eyeliner out there. Also, great lack of toxic ingredients. I love this brand.
Love it 5
Vivi from California
This has become my new fav eyeliner. It's affordable as well. Will be buying again
Okay 3
Ashley from NY
Nice pigment and easy to put on but it didn't stay well for me. Seemed to run easily when my eyes watered.
Nice makeup 5
taediva from Nevada
It's fine nothing super stands out but works
Found my Liquid Liner! 5
Johanna L. from Pomona, CA
Pros:
1. The construction made it really easy to use just like a pencil.
2. The felt flexible tip made it the easiest to apply from any "brush" liquid liner applicator.
3. Formula was smooth and bold.
4. Great value for its price that I looked up (I received it for free in exchange for my honest feedback). Been using it for 2 weeks daily and I barely made a dent.
Con:
1. You can use it in your lower lid but it does smudge a bit more. So really more for your top lid.
Overall:
I am a busy mom of 2 toddlers and I love how quick and easy the Honest Company Black Liquid Eyeliner goes on. Its so much easier to handle than normal liquid liner especially because off the flexible felt tip. Its almost like using a felt tip marker. I found less is more and that wiping off the excess before applying made it go on smooth and gave you tons of control on the thickness of your line. I love the "winged look" and this gives me the pop I look for, for a 5 minute face that looks like I took 30 min. I love the matte black finish because I can wear it at night and it is also appropriate for work.
Highly recommend!
The Honest Company Black Liquid Eyeliner 2
BeatnikReviews from St. Charles, MI.
I really didn't like this eyeliner. The applicator was awesome but the product itself just doesn't hold up. If my eyes watered at all, even when the sun is too bright it would make the eyeliner run like a gazelle being chased by a lion. I need an eyeliner than can withstand some pressure, even with setting spray it still ran without much difficulty.
Pigmented Liner 3
Mev from Chicago
This is my first time trying anything from Honest Beauty. This eyeliner is dark black but unfortunately, if it gets wet, it does smear! So don't get caught in the rain! I've only used this on my top lid, and my eyelid is OILY! I was surprised it stayed put! (granted I did have eye make up on, so that might have helped it.) Tried again without eye makeup and it had transferred. The felt tip brush is thin and can make very thin lines, so I have to go over my line to make it thicker. Very easy to take off, can use just water. Can also easily use the brush to make a flick for a wing. Probably won't purchase again, since I like my eyeliners to not smear.
Yeah dude you should buy it 5
Random lady on the internet from Akron ohio
I am not one to leave reviews - but - this is the eyeliner I have literally been searching for FOR YEARS. I've wanted something matte - but liquid. Not a fan of gel liners. The applicator is P E R F E C T. I was using a $20 precision Mac brush - but this makes it so so so much easier and faster and is so precise and sharp. Really impressed. Really enjoying this brand. And the price is *chefs kiss*
Smooth liner 5
Sheri from Illinois
Its tip is easy to use and smudge proof lasts all day.
