Rated 3.94 out of 5 stars
I really liked the mascara, but I already have long and full lashes. The mascara gave them a lot of length and a good amount of volume, for a mascara not labeled as a volume one. It seperated and grabbed every single one. the brush really grips and pulls each lash upward for a very nice effect. the mascara never dries out!! I've had mine for over 2 months. All in all, a definte keeper.
I had high hopes for this mascara since it is supposed to be Maybelline's replacement for their XXL Pro Extensions mascara, but alas, I was very disappointed. the XXL mascara was perfect--not too runny or thick, didn't flake and produced ridiculously long, natural looking lashes to rival Diorshow Mascara. the Illegal lengths stuff is a far cry from that--flaky and weirdly thick, this stuff is anything but a great lengthening mascara. Maybelline, please bring back the XXL and NEVER discontinue the Full and Soft mascara!
Rebecca from Midland, MI
This is by far one of my favorite mascaras! I love how long it makes my lashes and the low price point doesn't hurt either. I bought a few extras for gifts this year!! < 3
Cass from Portland, OR
This is there best mascara I've used for over 10 years now. I have tried and tried to find better, in other formulations, but nothing compares. I have long lashes naturally but i can take them to great lengths and build volume effectively and easily with this mascara.
It is a dryer formula which tends to help keep the curl in my opinion. It grabs the lash and builds and builds however large and long you want it!
Please Maybelline... It's getting harder to find this mascara... Please NEVER discontinue or change formula! 🙏🏼
Julie from Topeka, KS
Genesis from Palm Springs
My sister used this when i was just getting into makeup. Its been my go to mascara for years now!! Ive tried other mascaras but they just dont make my lashes look as nice as this one!! Im a illegal lenght girly for life!! Hope they never change the formula or discontinue it here in the US!!
Krisxo from Canada
Love love loveeee this mascara but why can't we buy it in Canada anymore?? This used to be my favorite mascara, I would even call it the holy grail but i heard it was discontinued long ago which is extremely disappointing. It is the only mascara that actually made my stubby eyelashes super long! Ive taken a break from eyelash extensions and honestly cannot find any mascara that is as good as this one. Please bring it back to Canada!!!
Paying Attention from Chi
Longtime user and loved the mascara for over a decade. Bedt brush. Natursl looking.
BUT….Since Covid there are WAY LESS fibers….yes, we noticed Maybelline. Total Bummer!!! I have purchased from different outlets, wondering if I could find one of the old batch, to no avail. Sadly, on hunt to find a replacement.
Goldilocks from undisclosed
The best mascara ever anywhere. Don't discontinue this ever!
Tracy from KY
I've loved this mascara for many many years! I keep trying all the newer ones but this one is my go to! It does seem to make my lashes appear longer. Love it!
Jennifer from Buckingham, IL
This mascara is absolutely perfect! It goes on so easy. The brush keeps the lashes from sticking together and just one coat is enough. No flaking, smearing or irritation with contacts.
jerry from San jose ca
This mascara made my eyes very itchy and it felt like i had something in my eye for days. Do not recommend.
Anon from New York
My sister told me about this product years ago after seeing how amazing her friends lashes looked and I haven't used anything else since. The length it adds is great. I've never had a problem with flaking or smudging, it's just simply the best.
Lissa from Houston, TX
I saw this on Instagram and couldn't find it anywhere so I was happy to stumble upon it at Ulta. I love the length it gives my lashes with the fiber extensions. I'll be buying again.
BrittyG from Seattle
Pretty disappointed in this mascara. It does not lengthen or thicken or add any volume to my lashes. If anything it really just clumps your lashes. I'd rather stick with my go-to lash paradise. Don't waste your money.
anon15687 from undisclosed
I just bought this brand new today and it didn't have a stopper in the tube....
Maybellinemayberry from Kansas
I sweat around my eyes and have tried every waterproof mascara and this was the only one that wouldn't budge... please bring it back
Ab from .
I never leave reviews but this is my ride or die really good length repurchased so many times
Osnow119 from Atlanta
Mascara adds good length to lashes. The brush grabs the lashes pretty good. Lasts a good while.
Mg from Wilmington
Best fiber mascara ever
OKD10 from 99336
Love it!! It actually lengthens!! Wish it was available in waterproof. The 4 stars was because it's not waterproof.
Thaliarod from UT
Ive been using this máscara since highschool I try others but allways seem to come back to this one. I hate how I cant find it anywhere anymore
Cort.Yerian from Ohio
Nothing to rave about here. This mascara is alright, I will not be purchasing again.
Mg from Wilmington, nc
This has lash extension fibers in it. It is fantastic! I don't know why this is not more famous yet
Jess from Murfreesboro, TN
Really like the slimness of the applicator. Feel like it grabs every single lash and really makes them look so much longer.
Glo72 from Texas
Love this mascara in the waterproof formula. I can't find it anywhere. Please bring it back!
T from Oh
It's ok, but "illegal length" is stretching it - pun intended