Rated 4.02 out of 5 stars
I feel like this is my DREAM mascara! I cant believe how well it works! I saw other reviews, with terrible things to say, but for me I feel like its the complete opposite.
Personally, I like very long lashes, separated, sweeping to touch my eyebrows. Naturally my eyelashes are straight, fine, and average length. But a simple curl with a lash curler, and 2 coats of this mascara, I have superstar lashes.
I didn't have any issues with clumping, or drying. My only tiny issue, and this is with every mascara I use, is smudging, I have very oily eyelids & Houston humidity, so when my eyelashes touch my upper lid you see some smudges. HOWEVER, some urban decay shadow primer = no smudges. I urge people to try this mascara for themselves!
The mascara brush is my favorite design, its slender, tapered, and rubber wand and tips are the best design. It combs through from root to tip leaving your entire lash covered and separated.
This mascara is either a love it or hate it. I definitely LOVEEEE it!
Please see the pictures I uploaded just so you have an idea of what the mascara looks like on by itself.
Bought this a couple weeks ago when they were advertising it at the front of the store. Seemed pretty good when I first applied it, definitely lengthened and defined my very thin lashes. But it did smudge a lot by lunch and when I went to remove it that night, nightmare! Would not come off! Flakes everywhere including in my eyes. Gave it a couple more tries, wish I hadn't. Third day I wore it and removed it I ended up at the opthomologist with a scratched eye from the flakes! Never use again! Be warned!
Joanne from Lake St Louis MO
This mascara gives volume and depth to my lashes. Love the brush.
Michelle from Wisconsin
This mascara is amazing.
Kate from Lancaster PA
Silicone brush & great formula that makes for great lashes. No chunks like tubing mascaras at removal. I've tried others I always come back to this one.
Louise from Garden City New York
I have used this mascara for a few years now and I love it. It's consistently good. Strong black color and makes lashes look thick and dark and well separated. Will continue to use bad gal bang lasts a long time too!
Extends lashes well
Marie from Virginia Beach, VA
Love how smoothly this goes on. My lashes never clump.
Lisa from Shelby Twp, MI
i always go back to this mascara, most others fade or dont accentuate your skimpy lashes like this mascara does
I love this mascara because it makes your eyelashes really pop. It is water resistant but so easy to get off in the shower- you don't have to harshly scrub to get it off.
Lori from New Jersey
Someone bought me this mascara as a gift and I absolutely love it. It makes my lashes look awesome. I don't know what some of these other reviews are talking about. It doesn't smudge at all and its not hard to come off. My lashes look so defined.
I should have known. I am not a fan of this product line as I think they are overrated, but my sister's lashes looked great when she first applied this that I decided to try it. Where to begin? First off, the product is WET. Like, wet, wet, and there is no way to get less product on the brush because there is nothing to scrape off that excess as it comes out of the tube. So, I wipe and wipe and wipe the excess on a tissue….and then I let it sit on my counter for a minimum of 3 min. I apply and STILL this product is wet. It gets all over every part of my eye and I am only applying to upper lashes. I have to use a spooliie to separate and declump the lashes. Okay. So… finally now they look good. As the day wears on my lashes get straight and the product wears off and smudges. What the? Really? It is 2024 and I have a mascara that smudges and wears off? Come on already. I will never buy another product from this line and I do not recommend this product to anyone.
Vicky from Twin cities mn
Francheska from TX
This stuff is like concrete superglued on the lashes and very hard to remove no matter what method you try. I tried it 5 different days and each time it broke off lashes no matter how gently I tried to remove it. I have used mascaras 40 years so I know how to remove them and this is the worst I have ever seen , even over waterproof ones. It doesn't even go on the great either. Went in the trash.
Daniela from Orlando, FL
I've tried lots of mascara and this one is my favorite. I've repurchased so many times at this point. Great for volume and length!
Michelle from Mn
Buildable, thick lashes. I always grab one for my mom too whenever I'm in an Ulta. We both love it!
Sherry from Brazoria, texas
The price was more than I would pay again but the product itself was ok
Nessa from Minnesota
This mascara goes on nice and makes my lashes look amazing but it does not stay put! It transfers all day and smudges realy easily... I expect better for the cost..
Carly from Spokane wa
This mascara is like the ex boyfriend you keep going back to. U love the first few weeks, and then remember why you never made the commitment. It rubs off onto lower lashlines and onto brow bone. Smudges and hard to get off. After a few hours of non stop running errands i saw smears and gross. I love the wand, and the creamy formula. Wish it didnt transfer as bad. Separates and lengthens nicely.
Barb from London on
Best mascara I have ever used
tori99 from IL
Between Roller lash & They're real, and Bad gal Bang. I'd opt for Bag gal bang lash. The formulation is wet side and takes a while to dry down. I like the applicator. While bad gal band still smudges, it isn't near as bad as They're real and Roller lash. I give it a 3, however I don't think the price is justifiable for an "ok" product.
Dani from Virginia
I tried this a few years ago and ive never tried another mascara since
Applies easily, adds beautiful length, doesnt cake or crust, no clumping, etc.
Koalas617 from San Antonio
If i dont apply a primer, the mascara is very wet and by the end of the day it is flaking off and smearing onto eyelids and below my eyes. If i use a primer first, it works perfectly
preetika from Westport, CT
Literally the best mascara ever, I don't know how Benifit does it but they just do. this mascara lengthens and volumizes all at once. I use it every day over all of my mascaras and it never misses. I have been using this mascara for years and definitely will continue to!! people always compliment how long my lashes are and I have put so many of my friends on this mascara and it looks so good on all of them! the best combo with this mascara is to actually have a dried-out one and a brand new one and put the brand new one on first and then put the semi-dried mascara on top and it looks the best!!! it doesn't look flaky at all and it seprates your lashes perfectly. benefit you did it again, this mascara is literally perfection!! Go buy it right now!!
janelle from Ann Arbor MI
A friend recommended me this, but it smudged quickly when it doesn't for her. I'm not sure if it's because we have different lashes/eye shape, but disappointing to see this highly recommended when it cant work for everybody.
Terri from Florida
Best mascara ever!
Sabrina from Huntsville, Alabama
My lashes have gotten thinner over the years, and I can barely see them. This is the only mascara that is gentle and yet picks up my lashes and makes them perk up! I have tried so many others when Ulta has been out of this brand, but I always come back to this! It is my go-to mascara!