Rated 4.53 out of 5 stars
I have literally never been able to put eyeliner on, I've tried dozens of products and I always end up looking like I fought with a raccoon UNTIL this! I did it on the first try, no problem. Definitely a great start for beginners.
The color (bronze) and how it blends are very nice and smooth, but mine was broken and a bit melted when I received it. I hope it was just a faulty one because I'm very interested in the other colors. I might repurchase it again
Sarah from sc
Easy to apply an stays put. 9/10, very shiny, but a top layer of eyeshadow mattes it easy.
Jen from USA
This is SO easy to use. My wings come out perfectly EVERY time and the time it takes to do my liner is way shorter. The only problem is this will not withstand any heat or sweat and will smudge after a few hours. Great for an evening but won't last a workday.
Diappointed from Alabama
I love Eyeko mascara and assumed the eyeliner would be just as good. Wrong! It disappeared from the inner corner of my eye within hours and smudged all over my under eye. Definitely returning this. Very disappointed with this product!
skiminsf from San Francisco
It is a good eyeliner but it's hard to remove the cap without the ink splattering. It's splattered on my bathroom door, floor, my hands, sink. Every time I use this product. While I like it, it makes a huge mess and for that reason I won't repurchase.
Laney from Texas
Love this! I bought the thin one and this thick one, the thin one was so dried out I couldn't even put it on.. this one on the other hand was so nice and dark black and goes on nice and smooth! Will def buy again!
V Val from Florida
don't have 20 minutes to get that perfect cat eye? Use this eye liner and get it done in five. I would definitely recommend this as an everyday liner.
KK from OH
Great for a thick line. But had to go over a couple of times as the color was not dark enough. It's my first time using a thick eyeliner so I do need more practice!
AliS from Boise, Idaho
I use it every time I use eyeliner. With it pen form I can get my cat eye right on the first try.
.. from ..
I bought this eyeliner because I love 💕 bold eyeliner but it's dry 😭
.... from NJ
Im very picky with eyeliner but I love this one. Applies smoothly. Dark black pigmentation. Water proof. I will continue to use.
Dolly Dagger from Idaho
I got this along with two nyx liquid liners to try and out of all three I like the Nyx Epic Ink liner best. When I wear this it ends up smearing under the wing and if your eyes water at all it will be all under your eyes. This is not waterproof so not an entirely good comparison but I don't reach for this one ever this because I'm afraid of unknowingly becoming a raccoon sometime during the wear time. The redeeming qualities are it's super black and it does wash off easily.
Lo14 from Nj
I really love this eyeliner! I was kind of skeptical at first because it had a large tip but as soon as I got the hang of it and moved the tip in certain angles for a thin or thick line it was great! It is much easier to do a wing with this eyeliner and last all day... I will continue to buy it
kim from Oshkosh
I want to love it but no matter how much I try, what techniques I use and do - it smudges on my upper lids and smears to my lower lids
Melissa from Washington, DC
I'm not going to lie....I've had this eyeliner for 3+ years (originally received from Birchbox) and through much searching finally found it again. By FAR the best eyeliner I have ever owned! Doesn't smear and lasts for forever. I definitely recommend buying!
Kate from Juneau Wi
Best eyeliner by far. The applicator intimidated me at first but it's actually easier to make a wing with this than any other liner I've ever tried. Only liner I used.
Christi from Northern Virginia
Used thin liner and liked it. This one tends to smear.
CarFar from Atlanta, GA
I have tried many different liquid eyeliners (probably between 10-15) and this Eyeko liquid liner is the best I've found yet. It is easy to apply, dries relatively quickly, and lasts all night. I typically use it for a more dramatic nighttime look or with a smokey eye. I prefer the fatter tip to thin liners because it is easier for me to apply it on my first try. I highly recommend this product!
Aria from Chicago, IL
I wanted a new liner to try. If you want a thicker line this is perfect, however it is hard to work with when putting on. During the day I noticed the liner was running and had black in the inner corner of my eye. Also the The felt tip dried out after a few times using it.
Bee Ray from Denville NJ
I got this as a sample a year ago and absolutely fell in love! I had to buy it again. I tried to find other eyeliners that could match it and nothing really did.
Bb from Potland
Cool! Made my tiny, almond shaped eyes pop! Is this the eyeliner ive been lookin for? So far, so good! i just applied. (My eyes are sensitive & water alot as well but they are not!) Like it!!!
Vv from Houston
Goo so far!
TwinsMom from Benicia, CA
I thought this would be easy to apply based on the reviews I read, but I found it more difficult to create a wing than other liquid eyeliners. This feels like a marker when you apply it. It has a nice deep black color and lasts well, but because it is so stiff and thick, I couldn't navigate it over my wrinkles without making a mess.
Sparkles from Whiting
Bought this during the beauty sale... So glad I did. Personally I always liked a thin line but u can control if u want a thin or thicker line. Goes on smoothly over the eyeshadow, which some is a problem and is true to its color, black.
Stacie from Elkhart Indiana
Kelley from Columbus, OH
This is my favorite eyeliner pen! If you're looking for that classic, thick cat eye, nothing is going to be easier than this. It's also a true black & darker than some other eyeliner pens on the market.