Rated 4.42 out of 5 stars
What i like about this mascara:
• omgosh the packaging is so cute! I totally love the tube with matte finish and embossed logo, the bluish lilac color is very pretty, it's thick and easy to hold, the box packaging is also nice.
• applicator is sleek and sturdy making it easy to apply
What i think can be improved:
• the formula is on the drier side, i thought it was dried up when i apply it on my hand but apparently works well on my lashes
• not very lightweight on the lashes
• it's a buildable mascara, you can adjust how long you want it to be, i found 1-3x application will give you natural minimal result, while after 5x swipe it will give the boost for length and thickness, it's more on lengthening not as much on thickening the lashes, you'll get that long wispy lashes effects
• took a bit of time to dry down, not waterproof, it can be partially removed with water, won't smudge just with water though, only when it's wiped it will then smudge.
I will still recommend this if you like cute aesthetic stuffs and love long wispy lashes
There are a few key thinks I look for in a mascara. Does it clump, does it lengthen, does it transfer. I have a huge problem with getting the under eye transfer when I'm laughing a lot - to the point where I often don't use mascara on my lower lashes if I know there's a high probability of me laughing a lot!
But, to get the full picture of a new product, each time I wore this mascara, I did my lower lashes too.
At first, I was sold. I wore it for a full day with only a tiny bit of transfer/smudging below my eyes toward the end of the day. There was no clumping, my lashes looked great! But, I realized I hadn't laughed much that day. The next time I wore it was to go out for a trivia night. I knew I'd be laughing and having a good time. I even did no foundation or concealer right under my eyes to give it a fighting chance. Forty-five minutes in to the night, I used the restroom and saw it. The under eye transfer. The smudgy look I was hoping to avoid! I wiped it away and hoped that would be it for the night. The next time I checked it, maybe an hour or so later - more transfer. So even though it applied beautifully, this is not a mascara I would purchase again because I try to avoid smudgy eyes whenever possible.
Momof3girls from Ohio
This mascara was just ok for me. I found it to be too thick and clumpy.
Chelle from Nashville, TN
I use mascara everyday in my makeup routine, and the Greatest Lashes of All did NOT disappoint! I did have to apply atleast 2 coats to get the desired effect, but it was such a dramatic difference! I did receive this product to try at zero cost for a review, but I'll definitely be buying it in the future!! If you're on the fence, try it. You won't be disappointed!!
Heather from Texas
Definitely made my eyes look better and just fulll lashes
Gabrielle from Arlington, TX
No more crunchy eyelashes! It gave my lashes fullness without clumps, no heavy feeling, all glamour!! The wand does all of the heavy lifting. I think I've found a new favorite
Smudgy from IL
cvdoss from Chicago
This mascara did a great job at lengthening my lashes and giving decent volume. The packaging is amazing, and I appreciate that the mascara doesn't look too unnatural when I wear it, but only for one coat. It doesn't seem to be a buildable formula, which is why it only gets 4 stars from me. No one wants clumpy lashes!
FifiCastillo from Eagle lake tx
This mascara has the cutest packaging! Be the light shade of purple they chose for the tube and how it's slightly on the thicker side so it's easy to hold and use.
The formula is really good ! I'm able to coat my lashes and work the mascara from root to tip without getting spider lashes. The formula lasts all day and does not give you panda eyes . I love that it doesn't rub off or transfer. I wear glasses but have had several people ask if I was wearing fake eyelashes…. It's that good!
Swags from PA
If this was more lengthening i would rate it a perfect 5 star, but i dont find it as lengthening as others. The brush finds every single lash no matter how small. Volume like wow. The formula is a little dry so its not clumpy at all. It doesnt flake or smudge. It stays put yet its easy to remove at the end of the day.
Angel from Queens NY
I was excited to try a new, cruelty free brand at Ulta, and the brush on this wand looked exactly like my favorites. However the formula is like cement, it clumped my lashes together and weighed them down so much. They looked awful. Immediate return- and I don't return anything.
4Zmami from Jacksonville, NC
Let me start by saying that I am a mascara snob lol. I rarely wear fake lashes, so a good mascara is a must. I usually wear Benefit or Too Faced mascara. But after trying Polite mascara, I'm definitely switching. The product itself is light and works well with a primer (I used 3 different kinds with this product). My natural lashes aren't super long but have a good length. This product adds volume and length. I got several compliments about my "lash extensions " lol. Once my 2 teenage daughters noticed, they started using it and was in love as well. We're definitely adding this to the collection.
Amandaleaou from Blanchester, OH
I received this product for free in exchange for my honest review. Things I like about this mascara, it's easy to apply and non-irritating, very natural looking. Things I don't like - it's very natural looking. I like my stubby, blonde lashes to look much darker and longer than they really are and this doesn't do that. I would wear this for a day where I'm primarily going to be at home.
Dee from NY
I was excited to see this new brand because I do like Too Faced, but this mascara was a miss. The packaging and wand are perfect, but the formula is weird and almost like mousse. It's heavy and feels like tar on my lashes. Even with just one coat and it fully dried down, my top and bottom lashes stick together when I blink. I've never had that happen before. My daughter had the same experience, and she normally can use any mascara without issue. And don't even think about applying 2 coats. It's like trying to spread mud. I really wanted this to work. If the formula changes, I would try it again.
Sel from El Paso, TX
Have been using this mascara non stop it makes my eyelashes look fuller & longer, perfect for an everyday use. It does leave clumps if applying several layers of mascara but it will only take about 2 for them to look full
Jess from Miami, FL
I have loved this mascara. It goes on smoothly and it makes my lashes look amazing! It does a great job of lengthening. I was worried that it would look very spider like once I saw the advertising pictures of the mascara online but I was pleasantly surprised. It not once looked like the advertisement and for me that's the best part. The only downside is that it does flake off a little throughout the day but not as bad as some other mascaras.
kitcatmom from Orlando, FL
Toy Box Brands kindly sent me a Polite Society Mascara for free so that I could review it via BzzAgent's sampling program. The Polite Society Greatest Lashes of All Time Mascara gave my blonde lashes the volume, length, lift, and curl they deserve, for everyone to see. It does not clump and is super easy to apply with the slightly tapered, fine tooth mascara wand. I absolutely love the PS Love and PS NO lists on the mascara's packaging. If you're looking for a paraben-, cruelty-, and negativity free mascara to give you a boost of confidence (and nourish your lashes), look no further, GLOAT (Greatest Lashes of All Time) is here!
Shoegirl411 from Eugene, OR
Polite Society greatest lashes of all time mascara goes on smooth and lasts all day. It's a great everyday mascara, however, if you're looking to add volume to your lashes, it does not do that. I dont usually put multiple coats of mascara on my lashes, but I did with this one just to test how buildable it is. I did 3 coats and it didn't look clumpy, but it didnt add much for volume either. The pics with eyeliner are when I did multiple coats, without eyeliner is 1 coat.
Overall it would be a good everyday mascara.
Judy from New York
I was curious to try this product to see if it lives up to its name of "greatest lashes of all times". I liked that the formula was buildable without significant clumping. I found that I usually like to apply 2-3 layers before it starts to look spidery. It definitely increased length and volume of my lashes but it didn't do much to curl or lift it. My only complaint would be that there was a bit of product transferred to below my eyes as the day went on. All in all, a decent mascara but I would've liked it more if it were waterproof or more resistant to smudging.
MarianneM from Massachusetts
I truly loved this mascara. It's become my favorite one so far. My lashes, and hair in general, is thin AND fine. This is the 1st mascara that actually curls my lashes when I put it on. My lashes are always in their natural straight/bent down shape. Depending on how I use this mascara it actually slightly curls them up. I don't know how this is possible if that's not their natural shape. Maybe the application method. I haven't used the eyelash curler ever since I got it.
Kaity from Virginia
I am very particular about the mascara I use. I like mascara that volumizes and lengthens, but I hate when it makes my eyelashes stick together. I don't want my eyelashes looking like Sally from the nightmare before Christmas. I also need mascara that is easy to remove, as my eyelashes tend to fall out when I have to work to get my makeup off. This mascara works well to lengthen and volumize, but it did make my eyelashes stick together. I tried a few different methods of applying the mascara, but regardless of what I tried, it continued to make my eyelashes stick together. It was easily removable, but I still prefer my tried and true mascara over this product. I wouldn't say it gave me the greatest lashes of all time.
Colby from New York
I've only used this product once, but so far I really like it. The tube is really nice and heavy and it feels luxury - I love that it's a totally clean product! The product photos in their advertising are interesting because it shows a very thick (almost clumpy) lash - and while I'm sure that can be achieved with several coats, doing just one or two coats has a great amount of coverage and lengthening that looks much more natural.
KansasKitty from Kansas City
This is a great mascara! I love the brush and the formula is the perfect viscosity. Not too wet and not too dry! I also appreciate the marketing images they used for the mascara. It showed real results instead of photoshopped images that other brands use.
Jadyn from Raleigh
Ive always had issues finding a mascara i loved until now! All other mascarad were always clumpy and fake looking like spiders legs, at first i was sketpical about this product but i tried it and im going to use this for the rest of my life! It was so fluffy and not a single clump it added volume and length and my lashes are so soft!! It makes it look like i have naturally really long lashes! I wanna try their other products i was so inpressed!!! My mon and sister often steal it from me to use!
Alex from NYC
I love how this mascara makes my eyelashes look so long! It doesn't clump or smudge
Tmarie from Chicago,Il
As a person with short straight lashes, all I can say about this product is YES. It gives you natural looking lashes with length, plus volume when you twist the wand down and add multiple coats. It never looks spidery or thick, UNLESS you use a lash primer beforehand.
Christine A from IL
This mascara doesn't compare to any other! First then packaging is a beautiful lavenderish color and its smooth as well, then the brush itself it spiky to grab ahold of all your lashes. The mascara drys fast and stays on all day.