Rated 2.63 out of 5 stars
Jenjenjen from Bourbonnais
I was excited to try these. I loved the old formula and wss sad to see it go but heard these would be better…and tbey see NOT.
The once subtle tingle youd feel to plum with the last formula is intensified in a bad way with this new formula.
Also this new formula is drying and turns to a more matte finish, creaping into any lip lines you have.
Huge disappointment and I will be returning the 2 i bought.
I will also say the swatch isnt as accurate as the shade you get when you apply it.
Deb from Turlock
I really like this lipstick. The color is great and it lasts for over 6 hours. It's great
Me! from Kansas
I can't compare it to the old formula, since I've just recently made the switch to Buxom. That said, I am in love with the Chocolate shade! I haven't experienced over drying. This is one of my favs now: stays on long without the dryness some longwear lipsticks have.
Ms. E from North Carolina
Advertised as Buxom Full On but not even close to Iconic Buxom lipsticks that are generous, moist and ease to apply. This was like trying to pencil in the lip color. Very very dry, and shape of the tiny lipstick makes it even more difficult to apply.
Rae from CT
I purchased one yesterday as I loved the past formula and the way it felt when I put it on and I wanted another color. Bought this new one and it just doesn't feel as nice. The last one felt very moisturizing.
Denise from Baltimore, MD
I got the shade Dolly Doll. I was worried after reading the negative reviews but I really love it! It's not drying at all and it's actually moisturizing. I agree with the other review about it having a medicinal smell but I don't mind it at all.
Deb from Tulsa ok
I had such high hopes for this lipstick after reading the description. It's very drying, so I have no idea how they can claim it's moisturizing. I got the red which is a very bright blue red. It was not long lasting at all. I tried dabbing it with tissue before applying a second layer, etc. and it would just disappear except around the lip line. It just had a cheap drugstore to it. I am a connoisseur of lipsticks, and this one performed very poorly. I would not recommend it at all. Very disappointing, I will be returning it.
KittenB from Michigan
The original Buxom lipsticks were my all time favorite. The smell, formula were perfect. These feel drier, dont have the same color payoff, and smell medicinal. I ordered two and refurned both. So disappointed.