Rated 3.72 out of 5 stars
What a unique eyeliner. I normally line with an eyeliner marker, but I've never used one like this before! The shape is so special and really helps you make super precise and thin lines. You can also create a super thick, dramatic wing by using the wider edge, and I appreciate that versatility. I was worried about the durability of the tip, but it's actually more sturdy than I expected! As far as the formula, I wish it was a more intense black. On first swipe, it's not as opaque as I would hope, but it does layer over itself easily to create the inky black look I'm after. I also don't think it's waterproof. It actually comes off pretty easily with *just* water, so I'm not sure this would be a great eyeliner if you're hitting up the beach or pool. However, it did still wear well for me, even with my oily lids. The design of the tip is definitely the best thing about this, otherwise it's just fine.
I recently tried the Magic Flik Liquid Eyeliner in the shade Flikking Fierce by Half Magic Beauty.
I found the thin, curved edge of the tip to be great for precision lining and wing shape, while the thicker, flat side was perfect for filling in and creating graphic designs.
I noticed the felt tip was too rough for the delicate skin around the eye area, resulting in uneven application and skipped spots. While the concept of this eyeliner is great, the execution needs improvement. For that reason, I would not recommend this product.
JenJen from Iowa
I was sent a replacement as I thought I had a faulty eyeliner. I received the 2nd one today and just as I expected, dried out after trying to apply. I wanted to love this so much but I don't. I'll stick with my Tarte double take eyeliner.
Jen G from Houston, tx
I just bought this 2 hours ago. I came home and deicded to try it out. Well I drew 2 lines then it immediately dried out, just like others have stated. Thats very weird. Also, the tip actually hurts. Im unsure if this was due to it being dry but im not a fan. Im let down because ive been wanted to try this and finally pulled the trigger on it just for it to be an immediate dud. Dang. Ill be returning and will not be repurchasing.
Liz from Dallas, Texas
I loved this eyeliner for the first month that I had it and then it started to go downhill. Even though I stored it upside down like suggested, after a month of having it, it's begun to dry out. Disappointed. I hope they fix the formula.
Jay from Canton, GA
I was really looking forward to using this product since i love alternative makeup. ive been keeping downward like the product suggests you to do, but about a day later after purchasing its almost dry, and harder to use. when i purchased it, it was a really nice black and extremely precise, but over time it just gets more disapointing to use. Fabulous applicator but the formula is a no for me.
Linds from Phoenix
I bought this a week ago and absolutely loved it. It wasnt as black as i wanted but could be filled in but now a week later and its drier than if i bought it a year ago and left it uncapped. Its design made my flicks at the end super easy but when going along my lash line it looked like a sysmograph reading. Wont purchase again and will return.
Nicole from Chicago, IL
I want to love this eyeliner but I can't. Every time I try to put it on it either dries out halfway through or it just moves the product around on my lid without giving me anymore.
Maritsa from Bakersfield, CA
I was able to do a perfect eyeliner on one eye, however when I switched to the other eye, the product was dry. I tried shaking it and leaving it upside down, however it was still dry.
Vonnie from London, England
Not recommended if you are used to a brush liner. Very black!
Anna from WI
Little to no pigmentation and had to push super hard and it like flaked off immediately
Luvnmkup from Atlanta
For me, this product is great! I always have a hard time applying eyeling on my upper lid and this has litterly made it so simple and so easy!
Mia seitz from New York
I am obsessed with this eyeliner. It is so easy to apply, lasts all night and is a rich black color unlike other eyeliners I have used. The formula glides on so easy but stays!! If you are an eyeliner person, this is the one!
Andibaby from arkansas
I got this after trying it at the store. I've been eyeing it online for a while. At the store the tester worked well. When I got home with it and tried it on my eye, it was pulling at my eye and hard to make a line at all. Like it was dry. Hopefully the rest of their stuff is good, but this ain't it.
Kris10 from Visalia, CA
At first I was so confused on how this eye liner was going to work because the application tip was different than normal eyeliners I've used before but once you get the hang of it, it's super easy to use! It creates a perfect wing. I didn't experience any smudging throughout the day. I do have sensitive eyes so I did notice I got to close to my eye and it started watering but I've been keeping it away and it's fine.
Ty from Knoxville, TN
It was kinda disappointed bevause I have high hopes for this brand but the application of this product could use some work to be honest. Its not terrible and it might work gor some people! Just not for me 🥲
Mrwpnw from Portland
I'm no pro makeup artist, normally this would scare me but with tutorial videos has made me feeling more confident gliding this on my eyes! Smooth, easy to use and with the felt tip it's been easy to get that perfect soft cat eye!!! Amazing stuff…
Ness98 from Phoenix, Arizona
This eyeliner has a unique tip unlike any other I've used before! It took me a few tries to really get the hang of it but once i did I was able to create a really clean and sharp looking winged eyeliner look!
Cheeeseley from Los Angeles
I wear liquid eyeliner everyday. This is now my new favorite! So easy to use, and give the perfect wing. Long lasting and doesn't smudge. Will be buying for the rest of my life!
Mikaerene from CALIFORNIA
I've never been a pen liner girl, they always bleed and were hard for me to control vs a brush, this changes everything! The tip is firm, of course it takes some getting use to, but the firmness helps you be more precise. I have never found a liner that didn't bleed quickly, this really stays. I initially tried it on the back of my hand, let it dry, and then rubbed it aggressively, nothing budged, then I ran it under water, no bleeding. JUST WOW!! Worth it!!
Sososoosos from undisclosed
Cute design! But rubs off a bit easily. I'm used to waterproof formulations and I wasn't prepared for the pigment to come off that easily (I have oily skin though so that's light be a factor). The design is cool and I appreciate it!
Taytay from Houston, TX
This is the perfect eyeliner for all of you who are not the best at applying eyeliner! It is very forgiving and has a thin applicator that allows you to make the line super thin or build it up to your liking. The product lasts all day and does not run or smear with water at all!
fdjkd23 from undisclosed
I'm in love with this liquid eyeliner! It glides on effortlessly, creating sharp, precise lines that last all day without smudging. The intense black pigment adds drama to my eyes, and the fine tip allows for versatile looks.
Mia from State college PA
Bought it because I was really intrigued by the style of the tip. It's a cool idea and it would be nice if there were more eyeliners styled like such but the product is TERRIBLE. You won't be able to leave the house without it coming off. Huge waste of money.
Grace from San Diego
I like the shape of the applicator, definitely needs a bit of practice but can make a really good wing. But this eyeliner dried out really fast, it was great for the first few applications, but goes on dry and patchy now. I still use it to get a general shape of my wings, but will go in and fill in the rest with another eyeliner pen. All over, I'm disappointed, I was hopeful for this product but it's just not worth it
Pri22 from Miami
The idea of this pen is genius! I love the design of the tip as you don't see this in other brands. Very pigmented and creates sharp lines due to shape of tip. It even stays on for extended period of time. But if you sweat, doesn't really stand a chance for too long lol
v311 from undisclosed
I've used this liner a few times and I think the tip shape is unique and can be helpful in creating different looks. I do think it takes some getting used to and I still prefer a regular felt tip. I also noticed the formula was a tiny bit flaky, so I'm not sure how it will perform on a sweaty day (I know it's not waterproof). The packaging is super cute!