Rated 4.26 out of 5 stars
I received this product free from Influenster for review purposes. I don't often have much luck with eyeliners, especially eyeliner pencils. I work in the dental field and have to wear a mask which tends to fog up my glasses and makes my eyeliner a complete mess halfway through the day. I had given up on winged liner for a while because I knew it wouldn't last. I was so excited to receive the COVERGIRL Perfect Point Ink It Eyeliner, but I also skeptical- how was this going to perform any better than the other waterproof eyeliners that I've tried with no success? This eyeliner claims to "glide like a gel" and "stay on like ink"and uses a clean formula. It is also meant to last 24 hours. I'm happy to report that this eyeliner lives up to most of its claims! This liner holds up to a full day of watery eyes and foggy glasses. My "wings" were still present at the end of the day and I only experienced slight smudging in the corners of my eye below the wings. I don't find that the liner glides on - it's not dry, but it's also not smooth like a gel. It was a little difficult to get a smooth line in one pass and due to the application, my liner appeared a bit faded. I can't report on whether or not the liner lasts 24 hours because I don't like to leave makeup on overnight, but based on how well it held up during the day, I think it stands a good chance at living up to that claim. Overall, this is a great eyeliner and I'm so glad I had the chance to try it out. I would definitely recommend it, especially to those who have watery eyes and struggle to avoid the "raccoon eye" look during the day!
I was very excited to receive the Covergirl Perfect Point Ink It Eyeliner in the mail. I received the black liner. I have tried this eyeliner on my upper lashes as well as my lower lashes but not at the same time. Let me begin my review with the lower lashes.
The first time I used this liner I put it on my lower lash line. It was not too difficult to apply but it did not go on very smoothly. My eyes looked nicely defined.
The second time I used it was on my upper lash line. This application was much more difficult. It did not go on smoothly at all. The line was much thicker than I would have liked. The liner seemed too dry and did not glide on. On this application I used the blending tool at the opposite end of the eyeliner to try to blend the out the liner. It did blend but it seemed to make the liner appear paler in the parts I blended (by paler I mean almost non existent, so I had to reapply). Also, when I tried to open the lid of the blender, the whole blender tool and the lid came off. This is definitely a design and safety issue that needs to be addressed.
The eyeliner was fairly easy to take off when I used makeup remover wipes. It comes off and transfers to fingers when touched. Also, I noticed my eyes slightly itched when I used this product. I do have allergies and I have sensitive skin. I would not recommend it to people who have allergies or sensitive skin.
Overall, I don't think this eyeliner lived up to what I thought it was going to be. I would give this eyeliner a 3 out of 5 stars. It is not something I would buy again.
summerbaby92 from undisclosed
I love CoverGirl and all their products. This liner goes on so smooth and precisely when applying. I have been trying to perfect my wing eyeliner for years and this liner makes it so easy.
brookesb_ from undisclosed
This product is very well made. The formula allows it to glide perfectly on the eyelid and easy to apply. The tip is the perfect shape to make application almost error proof.
nikkinicholej from undisclosed
I love this eyeliner, a glass on flawlessly. I don't have to smudge it although it comes with a little smudge brush on the end it's perfect. This is one of the best eyeliner's that I have used. It gives me a dramatic look, but not overly dramatic like I said it right on so easy so smooth love this. ￼
sldeathe from undisclosed
This eyeliner was very easy to use and went on very smoothly. I was able to get a very thin line above my eye so it does not look bulky. Definitely a fan!
angelakdb7d from undisclosed
The eyeliner has a good color payoff and lasts most of the day. The point starts of thin but quickly goes away so if you want a thing line it has to be resharpened. I smudge my liner so it worked out for me.
b308camie from undisclosed
This eyeliner goes on silky smooth. If you like a bold eyeliner this perfect. I like how easy it is to apply. Stays vibrant all day long with no fading.
marjuniel from undisclosed
Im not a big eyeliner girl but this covergirl make it very easy to use. The fine tip make the line so crisp and perfect and the other one is for bigger line or coloring it in. I definitely recommend.
staceef from undisclosed
The perfect point ink it eyeliner is really easy to use. It goes on smooth and you almost get a perfect every time which is really nice. It lasts all day too. There's no smudging or smearing as the day goes. I really like this eyeliner a lot, and this is my go to eyeliner from now on.
bri_marie from undisclosed
I'm not big on eyeliner so need something easy to apply. I like that this product is that. Saw many comments on it being crumbly and breaking but I didn't not have that problem. It doesn't have a super long shelf life, though.
laurawebb3a700895622 from undisclosed
I really love the color of this eyeliner! I would typically choose a dark brown, but the hint of gold in it is really nice. My only complaint is that the formula isn't super smooth, so it does tug on my eyelids.
dellarx from undisclosed
I used the product on one eye, it was amazing. When I did the liner on the other eye, the product tip broke. I wasn't applying any more pressure. I just think it was affected by the severe heat weather we had during transit. I still will try the product a second time.
brittneyla470 from undisclosed
I definitely am behind the saying "you get what you pay for" I didn't pay for this, but knowing the difference between this and prestigious brands…there's a difference. Mine was not gliding well . I figured it can be useful, you just need patience. If I was in a bind or traveling, forgot my items- I'd pick it up.
meganm37 from undisclosed
I'm not huge on eyeliner. It either smudges, does go in smooth and easy, or it doesn't stay on. This liner doesn't smudge, goes on smooth and easy, and lasts all day. And the brown color looks amazing with my blue eyes!
kaitlynne from undisclosed
The tip isn't as thin as I would like, it's a normal pencil eyeliner size. It applies pretty smoothly and it fairly easy to blend. It's not long wear if you are oily.
bekahboo023 from undisclosed
Was t the best. Definitely had potential but didn't glide like i thought it would. Maybe i got a bad one. Would love the opportunity to test other items
Rach61 from Atlanta, GA
There is a major reason why I am giving this a two. I was the biggest fan of the Cocoa Ink color in the Ink it Line. Prior to that I used perfect point plus, but never looked back once I found Cocoa Ink. It stays and provides great color. So why the low rating. Not having a matte color brown I now literally cannot find a replacement. I do NOT want shimmering color, I do not understand for the life of me why a highly sought after product color was discontinued or not brought into the revamped line. It really doesn't make strategic sense from a product planning perspective. I am so lost without my favorite product. I tried the shimmer brown color and nope not good at all. I expect the color to be on ebay soon and costing a lot of money. People are buying all the remaining products online.
tiff228 from undisclosed
I didn't love this eyeliner. The point was wider than I prefer ehich made it difficult to be precise. More importantly, the product smudged and ran easily. Total racoon eyes.
jettgirl14 from undisclosed
The things I like about this liner is the design and how thin it is. It is also easy to smudge…almost too easy. I wish this eyeliner was darker because I like my black eyeliner BLACK. If they could make this darker, it would be perfect
ingridkarinac from undisclosed
Covergirl, what can I say about this Covergirl product but that this one and all the one's that I have used haved been great to me. I love make-up, I think that most of us here do and I love to try different brands and products from them to see what I will enjoy the most. With that said, I really have to say that I am a big fan of this Perfect Point Ink It Eyeliner from Covergirl. It really has this great tip, this great point, that makes it so easy to put on the eyeliner. It makes it smoother to glide on and I really liked that. I also liked that my point did not break easily. I have tried other liners that do. Also, the fact that it is a gel liner makes it work great to work with and really last a long time like it says. 24-hr liner, oh yeah. Looking for a great liner that would really last a long time and is waterproof then I would recommend this wonderfull eyeliner for me from Covergirl. On top of that, they have these great colors to pick from. I got the privilege to try out the Bronze color. That for me it can be used in a more lighter tone or use it more intense. Either way, the color is beautiful and matches with most makeup and outfits as it is another tone of brown. If you enjoy using eyeliners then try out these Perfect Point Ink It Eyeliner from Covergirl. I am sure you will enjoy them as much as I did.
heatherschucker31679 from undisclosed
I've been using this on my eyebrows, since it's 1000% humidity outside. Stays put well, but also smudges nicely for a natural looking application!
ayocali from undisclosed
This eyeliner creates the most perfect cst eye! I typically use a jar eyeliner to obtain my super black cat eye. This one is just as good if not better then my current cream liner. I would recommend 1000 times
mandioak from undisclosed
Covergirl has a reputation for producing high-quality products, and this eyeliner did not disappoint! Great coverage that lasts all day. The pen applicator also gives you great control over your lines.
hmm1508 from undisclosed
I didn't think I would like this product but I ended up loving it!! It goes on so smooth and easy to get off at night as well. I will totally be buying this again.
stuntedgiraffe from undisclosed
I received this eyeliner free for review through Influenster. I really like this eyeliner, and the timing was perfect because I just ran out of my primary liner. I also have hooded eyes so my liner use for this product was rather limited.
It didn't wander or creep to my lower lids throughout the day and application was very smooth. I had to tightline since my hooded eyes are getting out of control as o age. I found d the sharpener after a few days too! The o oh useless bit for me was the smudger. Partly because of how I used the liner, partly because the eraser is kind of tough on my skin.
mistyt17 from undisclosed
This eyeliner glides on so easily it's almost effortless to do! I also liked the results it held throughout the day too! Great for everyday or special occasions.