Rated 4.46 out of 5 stars
I did change lotion/eye cream as. result, but suddenly the skin around my eyes became so dry it cracked and bled. I have used Bare Minerals for years and slept in it, even slept with prestige mascara and eye shadow on! For years! But when you go into menopause EVERYTHING about your skin changes. I went from oily all over to combination skin and could not apply any eyeshadow or the skin around my eyes would crack, flake, and my eyes would water. I researched everything "clean" and this set is the best quality, reasonably priced matte set. The skin around my eyes stays soft and it lasts several hours (though I no longer sleep with eye makeup on). I just wish they sold individual colors because the buttercream is perfect all over and the pink is a great under-eye cover, so of course the darker colors are used much less. I hate having to throw out half-used colors when I need to replenish buttercream and pink. But until my eyes settle down this is my everyday shadow set.
The Storm Chaser eyeshadow palette (PR sample) is the most cool-toned multi-shade palette offered. Unfortunately, all hues were too warm and muted against my pink-porcelain skin tone. I realize that shimmer has been all the rage for nearly 2 decades now, and I like an opalescent wash on my eyelids, but I don't care for so much of it. This was especially true for the lightest shade, Lightening, which I could not apply as a base due to its hyper-glittery finish. I'd love to see these palettes redesigned with an equal distribution of matte/satin and shimmer (matte especially for the lightest and darkest shades). It would also be great if one shade could be removed in order to double the size of the base shade. jane iredale makes the best mineral foundation on the planet, I've been buying it for 22 years. But I continually strike out with too-warm eyeshadows now that the excellent Pink Smoke, Taupe, French Toast, Iris, Platinum, Magic, Nude, White, and Wink have been discontinued. Storm Chaser is a high-quality palette and an excellent value. It just didn't work for me.
Dawn from Oklahoma
Received this for being a diamond member and a purchase. I'm 64 and have started using prestige products in the last 14 years and as I've reached 60 I started wearing matte eyeshadow so when I saw this I was disappointed because it looked like shimmer. I opened the way to cool magnetic case and gave it a shot. First, the shadows felt like silk. Second, they didn't show up until about 3 layers. Third, they lasted all day. Fourth, I was amazed since they looked very natural and really pretty. Fifth, I wouldn't want to pay full price but I might. This is my review and hope it helps anyone looking for a natural look.
Daniela from Seattle
Received this palette as a Diamond Gift. I was very excited to try out a Jane Iredale palette, but I was rather disappointed in the quality. Even though the colors look really pretty, I found them hard to apply. I needed to swipe at least three times for each color to really make them visible on my eyelids. It worked much better to apply them with a wet brush or by hand. The color payoff was much better this way, and they stayed on throughout the day. Solid three star rating, but I´m glad I received this for free.
Teresa T. from Undisclosed
I love both products!
Patricia K. from Undisclosed
Just right colors for subtle shading
Vicky C. from Undisclosed
Perfect color combination!!
Irina G. from Undisclosed
Beautiful and versatile palette. Ans Jane Iredale customer is the best!
Sharon B. from Undisclosed
I love the pure pressed eye shadows. The colors are gorgeous, buildable, blend easily, and wear beautifully. The finish is perfection. Most impressive is the color selection and combinations. I wore many of the shades over time, but I recently discovered the pallets when I got Solar Flare as a gift with purchase. Thank you, Jane Iredale! I followed with Storm Chaser and Naturally Glam! Pure Basics is in my cart. I love them! I have very sensitive eyes and skin, and they do not irritate!
Lorinda K. from Undisclosed
Love it. Beautiful color palette...very flattering!
Deloris W. from Undisclosed
I like the Eye shadow very much. That's the one that I wear only thing I didn't like. I did not have a brush for my Eye shadow.
Jennifer S. from Undisclosed
I cannot believe how EASILY this eyeshadow blends! It is such full pigment!
Jillian M. from Undisclosed
Jennifer E. from Undisclosed
Beautiful mix of mates and shiny ones stays on my eyes and looks great
Carrie B. from Undisclosed
I've used the product before but the updated product did not improve. I preferred the former formulas and feel I've wasted my money.
Hope M. from Undisclosed
I loved most of the colors!!! The last one in the storm chaser eye shadow pallet is to dark for me. The quality was very good of the eye shadow was very good!
Laura D. from Undisclosed
Love your products because they are toxic free and allergy resistant!
kym s. from Undisclosed
I have used Jane iredale products since 1991 and have always been pleased. I love the loose powder as a concealer or as an all over the face brightener. I bought these products for a friend who uses drugstore makeup.. I showed her how to apply it and give it to her this week and she is thrilled beyond belief. Sees a huge difference between what she's been using and the Jane iredale products as I knew she would
Marilyn C. from Undisclosed
This is my first purchase of Jane iredale eye shadow, and I have really been enjoying it. I bought the storm chaser palette! The colors are beautiful, easy to apply, and last all day! I highly recommend jane's products!
Patricia S. from Undisclosed
I like the variety of colors but this time you changed what I usually buy.
Dulcina M. from Undisclosed
Love the colors and it feels lite!
Vicki H. from Undisclosed
The colors are very unappealing on my eyes. Rather than giving the purchase a negative review, perhaps I should mention that I should not have ordered the compact. I was so very disappointed. I have found Jane Irdale to be an excellent brand without exception. Each product I've purchased over the years has been delightful. I am sad to find these colors to be so unappealing on my eyelids. EXCELLENT BRAND!
Alice A. from Undisclosed
Live the matte eye color combination.
Diane I. from Undisclosed
Nice matte finish to eyeshadow. I'm not loving the colors. Too much of a red tone for my fair skin. Would prefer taupes.
Molly M. from Undisclosed
beautiful shades, smooth and rich on lids, and cool magnetic container!
beth p. from Undisclosed
Love the colors but wish the lightest was a matte versus shimmer.
Mim from Undisclosed
I love my old Jane Iredale eye shadow palette "Naturally Matte" as I can use it for both eyeshadow and eyebrow. As another reviewer say, Hurricane in Storm Chaser is too dark for brunette eyebrow. I still love all Jane Iredale collections, but I wish there are more options for matte colors. I hope someday Jane Iredale will make a refillable option so that I can pick my own colors for my eco-palette!