Rated 4.26 out of 5 stars
439 Reviews
I kinda dragged my heels on the fly pencils cause I wanted to give myself time to read/watch the reviews from the other divas. These pencils are beyond AWESOME!!!! High pigmentation is on fleek. Now, for the "bad news" these pencils are described as retractable and they are not. So do not just roll the product up thinking you will be able to roll it back into the tube. I consider that a packaging issue and not a product issue. The product is perfect in every way. Also I've read that we could have been given more product in the pencil. But they are easy to apply, long lasting, vibrant colors, I can't say enough. I just am going to ask that Fenty start really putting more effort to the packaging. If you tell us that a product is retractable then that is what we expect. And I know everyone is tired of me screaming about the Glass Slipper gloss bomb tube leaking. Tighten up RiRi on the packaging so a good thing is not ruined.
I bought this eyeliner in the shade "Sea About It," which is a gorgeous matte royal blue color. I am very partial to that color, especially in eyeliners, and I wanted to try this. I swatched a tester in-store and it was pigmented and smooth, and didn't budge after it had some time to set. It was very promising. I purchased it, put it in my waterline after I walked out of the store, and wore it for about 3-4 hours. When I went to remove my makeup, the blue eyeliner had disappeared completely from my waterline, and had crumbled all over my lower eyelid. It was awful. I'm returning this. I wanted to like it.
3
CJnez from Arizona
Oily skin, oily lids person here. This liner is VERY pigmented and glides on; however, it smudges everywhere. And if it does by some chance stay on, it'll smudge on your lower lids. It also flakes. I couldn't continue using it, so now I have a barely used liner hanging out in my makeup bag.
1
Missy from Hopkinsville KY
Product was very FLAKY. I wear contacts and pieces fell into my eyes.
Selena from new york
it gave me blurry vision. it was very scary
2
Christina from Portland, OR
Jennifer from Denver Colorado
I like how long this eyeliner wears, especially for the water line. But it barely lasted me six weeks not even using it every day.
anisa from madison al
Horrible packaging and hard to apply but the liquid eyeliner insyead
5
Karly from Saint Paul MN
Perfect for tight-lining
from Youngstown
This eyeliner was very dry. It's a roll up eyeliner which is supposed to be creamy and smooth to apply. Very bad product.
Lizzie from new Jersey
I have gotten 4 of the colors so far. 1) cuz I'm back- does not spread nicely, hurts my eye line, very dry and doesn't stay on. 2) navy or die- the exact same way the cuz I'm black goes on 3) sea all about it- this one goes on but it balls up and I get these little balls under my eyes and just doesn't stay on. 4) lady lagoon- I've gotten this one multiple times. it goes on nice and smooth, but it's not made for all day wear. it does smudge in the corner of my eyes and I have make sure I check myself quite frequently in the mirror. but I love this color. Tarte had the best color liners but they stopped selling them. these are good if you're in between like myself while you're trying to find a better one.
Good for some from Redding, CA
I won't say this is a bad product because the color range is gorgeous and the product stays on all day. However, it stays on for multiple days… and it is hard to blend out, plus it does not glide as well as I would like it to for a product that is pictured to be worn winged out. Overall, for my needs I had to return these, but if you want a pigmented liner that stays in place, I would suggest this line!
Stephanie from Buffalo, New York
Long lasting. Non smearing. Glides on. My go to for eyeliner
Theresa from Fairless Hills, PA
I bought this product the color was nice and went on easily, but three days later it fell apart. I thought fluke so I bought it again. I almost ripped the bottom of my eyelid trying to put it on... forget it spend a little extra and get a real brand. no quality control.
4
K from Las vegas Nevada
Absolutely looking forward to the color variants. The formula is very nice and creamy, easy to apply. Unfortunately it dries out quickly and becomes tough, do not roll out more than you need as it does not retract.
Ri from Chicago
Gel liners usually melt right off my eyes but not this one. This one is highly pigmented and long lasting. It's not mushy like other liners that get all weird or crumble. Sometimes you get what you pay for.
E from Naperville, IL
Overall I really like this - I've been searching for a good purple that doesn't wear off and this delivers! Only too well! I have a hard time getting it off, even after 2-3 days! I'd definitely recommend with that caveat!!
Sam from Nashville, TN
This is one of the worst eyeliner formulas I've tried; it's impossible to get any color payoff unless you press so hard the tip literally breaks. Really disappointed in this product, I didn't get one use from it.
Brandie from Oregon
very drying and doesn't smudge out.
Sharon from Syracuse, NY
I was looking for a white eyeliner for my waterline that would actually come out white and give some shine. This product was it. I wore it all night and it was still good when I took off my makeup. Definitely one of the better products I have used.
Barb from St. Charles MO
I truly love the Fenty brand. This eyeliner does not make my eyes itch or water and more importantly stays where it's supposed to but yet comes off very easily. The color choices are great.
Francesca from Nashville, TN
The color is beautiful, but I found the formula to be a bit dryer than some of the other. It applies a little chalky and if you have looser skin you may have dragging issues. If they made this in their liquid eyeliner I would buy it in an instant.
Pat from Ohio
The eyeliner stays on when most do not. My eyelids seem to be more oily or moist than most and I love the way the liner be stays on plus it is easy to apply. A nice assortment of colors as well! I would love to see a teal color offered.
q from FORT COLLINS COLORADO
I LOVE the color it is highly pigmented and lasts ALL DAY but sadly on my forth time using this product I had and allergic reaction. I have NEVER had an allergic reaction EVER. I do not have sensitive skin. I RECOMMENED TRYING ON A SMALL AREA OF SKIN MULTIPLE TIMES.
Mona from Walnut cove nc
This product smears after one hour of wear…I looked like a raccoon…well close to it…it doesn't stay put.
Samantha from Ohio
I love these, and don't regret buying them in just about every color. Some go on smoother than others but the more you play with them the more you love them!
Janice from Valdosta, Georgia
Glides with ease, good coverage