Rated 3.44 out of 5 stars
I used Bare Minerals liquid eyeliner for years...until they discontinued the product. Grrrr..... I tried several eyeliners trying to find one that came close to Bare Minerals, and this is it! Fenty Longwear Liquid is the closest match I have found. The only issue I have had with this product is that the top can pop off after a few weeks and the pen will dry out. I was super angry the first time it happened, but now I know to keep an eye on it to make sure it closes all the way and stays closed.
Ive been using liquid liner for decades. Ive gone through many differnt brands. I strayed from my usual brand to try this since i loved how pigmented it was. After a couple hours it was transfering to my upper lid which was set with powder and eyeshadow. The corners of my eys wore off completely within probably 4-5 hours. I wear contacts and my eyes were so dry and bothersom the whole day while wearing this. Some of liners do bother my eyes but its far and few between.
Afton from Salt Lake City, UT
The pen goes on smooth - the felt tip is perfectly bendy so that you can draw on a sharp line. The concentration of the liquid is great so the line is solid. However, once it's on, it goes EVERYWHERE and then becomes super sticky.
KG from Indiana
I have both *mature* and hooded eyelids and this is my absolute favorite. It goes on smoothly, dries quickly, and stays in place. You will need a good oil based eye makeup remover solution to get off, but it comes off easily with solution.
Amanda from Monticello, GA
Leeny from New Jersey
I wanted to love this product - but the brush's tip is flimsy and lacks ink over time. A few months after using this, I noticed that I needed to strategically angle my application so that I'd be able to hit the spots on the brush that did have ink.
Jules from Long Beach
Trying to do a wing liner with this liner is almost impossible. The top of the liner is sooooo dry. I have to leave it upside down for so long to get it some what wet with liner. Not for oily eyelides or the water it comes right off.
Lex from Utah
Comes out looking very textured on my skin, which is not desired in a liner.
kenna from Hanover, PA
ive fallen asleep with this eyeliner, gone swimming, sweat a TON, and this eyeliner did not move.
from Los Angeles, CA
the lines i am able to make with this liner are so rich and intense, it's exactly what i was looking for
Nichole from Massachusetts
This eyeliner is my favorite, the black is pigmented and has a great formula. It wears all day and doesnt flake. Seems like each purchase doesnt last long, but i still feel its worth the price.
Katie from St. Louis, MO
I love this formula! It stays on hard-core but the plastic casing breaks 50% of the time (I've bought 4 total). When the plastic breaks, you can't get the lid to stay tight so that means it dries out fast. I wish they could fix this!
Eeeerrriiissss from NM
It worked well in the beginning, but now the tip is dry even though its relatively new and a lot of product appears to still be in there. Also, the tip is frayed and I cannot get a sharp line. I had better results with the Nars liquid eyeliner, although it has its drawbacks.
super sharp lines. stays on all day even on my oily eyelids
Gretchen from Salisbury NC
Love this eyeliner it's by far my favorite so far!
V from Dallas, Tx
The eyeliner starts out very nice and black but it dries out after one month of having it. Once it dries out the product erases whats already in there.
TayTay from Pflugerville, Tx
Dont get me wrong its an amazing product but cant withstand water. First hour at the pool i had not eyeliner left
K from USA
Pros: It's a true brown liner. Has a bit of a reddish tint to it. Literally does not budge once it's on.
Cons: Literally does not budge when it's on. If you mess up, you're gonna need to get out the makeup remover and try again. But the more significant con is that, after approximately 14 wears over 45 days, the cap no longer stays on the pen: it keeps "popping off". To keep the cap on the pen body, I have to tape it shut with packing tape so it doesn't dry out. (It pops off with a decent amount of force/air pressure, it's not like it's draped on.)
Denise from Daphne AL - US
One of the easiest eyeliners I've ever used (and the most expensive LOL)
Angela from Los Angeles CA
Love the product itself but the cap cracked and completely dried out my eyeliner, rendering it useless. Tried to revise it and wouldn't come back. Bought another one and it did the same thing. :(
Glamandglorylab from Spokane valley wa
Claudia from Dallas, TX
Beautiful liner. All day wear without any smudging.
April from San Antonio, Tx
Color was bold, did not skip, or run.
Beliz from Sherman Oaks
I really like this Eyeliner applicator, I have accidentally fallen asleep with makeup on, and the eyeliner is still standing :-), I will say my only con is the prize, and that it's difficult to remove.
Jessica from Macon MO
I would typically recommend the product itself many times over but this time unfortunately. The pen was completely dry and I couldn't even use it.