Rated 3.83 out of 5 stars
Rosario from New York
I use to use this eyeliner religiously when i was a teenager and it use to be so good. They must have changed the formula or something because right now it gets clumpy the minute it hits the air and the makes it very hard to apply since it dries down quickly giving you thick wing.
luisa from riverside
never tried this brand. but I was looking for a good eyeliner that would last. I bought other brands. but this one is soon good. I have to buy ot again. it supper black. last a long time. supper impressed.
April from Norwalk, ca
Just like many people, i was a hardcore milani fan. And after tons of eyeliners, this is my top. It does dry out eventually, but milani had the same issue. Yes, buy it!
Dawn from Florida
Long lasting, rich and true to color eyeliner! Not for nubes! If you make a mistake, good luck!
Even after 24 hours of war and running a 10k, my eyes still looked beautifully done !
brooklyn from California
if you're looking for an everyday eyeliner, for bolder looks, don't buy this. after one use it was already clumping up terribly. i've used this everyday for about 2 months now and it is the worst eyeliner i've ever used. the bottle is CAKED with hard clumpy eyeliner. i store it correctly, i clean the top off every time. still does this. stick with the NYX epic wear.
Jess from New York, NY
They discontinued a waterproof drug store favorite of mine, the Milani Infinite liquid eyeliner. I used it for 10+ years most of which I was a competitive swimmer - it never budged during practice or swim meets. I needed an alternative and struggled, even with nicer brands (tried Stila, Urban Decay, MAC, etc.) I found this one off of a blog recommendation and I won't try any more. This is a great waterproof eyeliner, easy to apply, pretty quick to dry. Not proud of it but can sometimes go over 24 hours and it won't budge.