body{margin-left:12%}Product ReviewsRated 3.55 out of 5 stars207 ReviewsMost Helpful Positive ReviewBest mascara I've ever used!!!!!I tried this product simply because I was on vacation and forgot to pack my makeup and this was cheap. I was completely shocked when I put it on my lashes! I had fake lashes for years and loved them, but they left my natural lashes looking horrible! I have been using products to repair my lashes and just accepting that they will always look like short stubby things, but then I put this on and OMG I was ecstatic! It looked almost as good as when I was getting them done! It not only lengthens and adds so much volume, but it also gives them a nice curl! The only negative I have agaist this product is that it is a bit difficult to remove.Most Helpful Critical ReviewLoved it at first but…I gotta admit, I purchased this mascara because of the name. Too cute! The first time I tried What the Fake I was hugely impressed. Volume, length, no clumps, and very inexpensive- absolutely the holy grail of mascara. I even took pics of my lovely lashes and sent them to some friends. But i never got those results at any other time. Either it would clump or not lengthen. It felt dried out after my first couple of times using it, even though I closed it tightly. I thought maybe I had gotten an old tube so I bought another tube to try. Nope. Never ever got the results that I did on that first try. Lots of clumping, no great length or volume. So unfortunate, this is a "no" from me.Reviewed by 207 customersBest mascara ever !5Stephanie from New OrleansI love this mascara because of the thick applicator and because it gives my eyelashes volume and density. You can see the difference after one coat ! Best find I ever made !Loved it at first but…3mandms4evr from TexasI gotta admit, I purchased this mascara because of the name. Too cute! The first time I tried What the Fake I was hugely impressed. Volume, length, no clumps, and very inexpensive- absolutely the holy grail of mascara. I even took pics of my lovely lashes and sent them to some friends. But i never got those results at any other time. Either it would clump or not lengthen. It felt dried out after my first couple of times using it, even though I closed it tightly. I thought maybe I had gotten an old tube so I bought another tube to try. Nope. Never ever got the results that I did on that first try. Lots of clumping, no great length or volume. So unfortunate, this is a "no" from me.I like the brand but......3Brenda from FloridaI like the brand of masacara. I have used others in the line but I am not overly thrilled with this one. I think I will just use the others that I have purchased before.I would definitely repurchase!5Heather from Indianapolis indianaAbsolutely amazing!Average mascara3CherylM from VirginiaI'm a huge fan of Essence mascaras. This one, however, fell short of the mark. It adds some volume but very little length. Would work well for those who like a more natural look. Would not recommend or repurchase.Third time buying5Amber from IndianaMy daughter loves this mascara. It stays in place and makes her lashes pop.Not sure it actually has fibers2Amy from Tucker, GAI tried it once, but did not see any lengthening or volume that is supposed to occur with a mascara with fibers. I have tried fiber mascara before and it worked. I will give it another shot, but was not impressed on the first application. Might have to return.Yes5Valerie from BuckheadThe only ones I buyWhat the…something1Sheila from Lexington, KYI went in to pick up a different option from this company but it was out of stock. I thought, how different could they be? This product was terrible. I had it on for less than an hour at church and already had raccoon eyes. I'll still try the other, but was bummed this one didn't work out.It's ok….2Shari from Dayton, OhThe original formula is best. This did nothing glamorous or extra.I would definitely buy this product again!5Denise from San MarcosI'm happy with this product!Great quality mascara5Amanda from Savannah GABetter product and comparable to better than sec mascara. You can't beat the price either!Yassss to the lash maker!5Jen from Houston, TxTwo snaps and around the corner for this product. Your lashes go from pitiful to plentiful!Disliked product1Jigi from ColoradoJust like the mascara clumps pretty bad for quality.Not great2Jennifer from Kansas CityThis mascara is not great. It leaves dark circles under your eyes.Feathery/Natural Looking Lashes5Marnie from undisclosedI love, love, LOVE this mascara since it makes my lashes look thick, wispy and natural. Better than any expensive mascara hands down.Drys out3Kendall from Fort Wayne, InI got this about 3 weeks ago and it's already dried out but it's great when u first get it.waste of money!1Kathy from Manahawkin NJWorse mascara I have ever used. Do not waste your money.good product5VICKIE from NORTH CAROLINAOnly used once so far, but great at not clumpingI want to like this3Aly from OklahomaThis mascara flakes so bad! If it didn't flake it would be perfectIncredible result!5Blv29 from TorontoMy eyelashes are naturally short and with this mascara the length and volume were incredible! I love it!! My eyelashes stayed voluminous and no smudging or transferring. I highly recommend this!Best Mascara!!5María R. from USI'm absolutely obsessed with this mascara. It makes s my lashes look thick without clumping or looking spikey even after a couple of coats. I won't be using anything else.Love this!!5Janie R. from USGreat mascara. Stays on all day, does not flake and allows you to build and build your lashes.I think your mascara is3Jennifer G. from USI think your mascara is great everyone I know raves about it but I was expecting moreNot for me2Linda S. from USI heard great things from a influencer I follow on Youtube , but this mascara didn't work for me . Was too clumpy .