Rated 3.16 out of 5 stars
All my eyeliners have rubbed off by morning (if I didn't take them off the night before) BUT THIS IS NO NORMAL EYELINER!! I've been wearing yesterday's eyeliner all day, over 24 hour wear! (Please excuse the oily skin, I wanted to see how long the eyeliner would last so I only fixed my brows up this morning!)
I got this product in hopes of having a cute white liquid eyeliner, but as soon as i opened the item, the product was extremely thick and messy looking. When i tried it out, it was incredibly difficult to apply evenly and precisely. It had a very paint like consistancy and feeling. When i then tried to get it off, nothing i tried worked and it barley budged. I scrubbed my eyelids raw with soap, makeup remover, lotion, vasoline and warm water. I tried everything i could think of and it barley worked. HOURS after initially putting it on, it has rubbed off some, but none the less, is just a terribly made product. I DO NOT RECOMMEND GETTING THIS. I thought i had just got one that was in a bad batch, but after reading many other reviews of people having the same problem as myself, ive just chalked it up to the product in general.
Marissa from Michigan City, IN
I was shocked to see the lower average rating. This has been my go-to for about a year now. I have hooded eyes and oily lids, and work outside often. This eyeliner stays in place and it's the only one I've had consistent luck with. It isn't easy to remove BUT I'll take it if it means lasting all day. It's also worth mentioning that the brush is GREAT at first, easy to be precise. However I definitely notice a slight decline in brush sharpness after awhile, and the formula does get a bit goopy towards the last bit of product left. Overall, the long wear and solid pigment and price outweigh the cons for me.
Brend from California
For my hooded eyelid people. For anyone who suffers with transfering eyeliner, get this eyeliner! This eyeliner allows one to create skinny crisp defined lines! And great pigment! I agree its hard to remove, but its easy to remove with an cleansing balm or oil based makeup remover. I use the inkey oat cleansing balm, and it comes off with ease without irritating my eyes.
Ms from Massachusetts
Good product but very hard to remove, even with make up remover didn't come off took a couple of days to totally be gone
Jenni From the Block! from chicago
This bad boy stays on all day even the next morning. Throughout my tough shifts - it keeps in place. No smudges. No racoon faces. I use baby oil to remove it. Highly recommend and especially for the price. Can't beat it!
gothabilly from WA
I own almost all the colors of this eyeliner and have been buying it for years at this point. It works perfectly with my hooded eyes, it lasts all day (and even into the next), hasn't come off in saltwater for me, and looks really smooth on your skin with intense color.
You're obviously not going to like it if you're not used to using eyeliner pots or brushes instead of pens, but once you get the hang of it there's almost no going back.
The only con that I personally don't like is that it can be difficult to remove. Most of it comes off with my cleansing balm but occasionally it will leave little bits behind that you might have to remove with micellar water.
Mia from Michigan
Bright colors and a precise line. Did not come off throughout the day, though it does require using a quality makeup remover at the end of the day.
lyss from Palm Bay fl
its way too hard to get off. I literally had to scrape it off my skin which caused a lot of redness and swelling by my eyes. dont get it.
Anonymous from Tennessee
Stayed in place all night!
Chelsee from Texas
I wanted a nice pigmented white and saw some recommendations for this one. It is HORRIBLE. The applicator gunks up with product after a few uses and the formula goes on thick- as if it is very old liner. Impossible to get a nice crisp line
It was so thick when I applied it that it looked like I had several layers of eyeliner on. It's impossible to remove it as well. I am throwing it away. 😞
allie from peoria arizona
to get it off use miceluar water, but if just applied then can be wiped off easily! i own many colors and there my davorite eyeliners, there so east to apply as well and super affordable! i love the tip cause u can make sharp point so easily!!! highly recommend!
Nizza from Irvine, CA
This used to be my favorite go to because of the applicator but they reformulated and my skin hates it. I wont be repurchasing. Immediately returned.
Fatima from Mentor Ohio
Will i always miss the old formula nothing compares
Alyssa from Georgia
I wear eyeliner every day. Every single day. For the past 8 years, and this is the only liner I will ever purchase. It does not smudge or run AT ALL. I use it everyday and only have to purchase once a year. BUY THIS LINER !!!! I swear by it.
Nallely from Illinois
stays on even when sweating and when in water it won't budge
Gabriella from Turlock California
Not sure why this product has a low rating ! Maybe it because y'all don't give it a chance ! So the think with this eyeliner is that once it drys it's does not budge you can go swimming and this liner won't come off it's one of my favorite summer liner ! But if you you don't let it dry properly you will create a mess and also to remove it it's hard !! So trick is to line your eye and have a fan on standby to dry products faster I have a mini fan I bought from the flea market and it works great to dry it faster !!! This is definitely a summer liner and one that absolutely won't budge ! I encourage to practice with it !! Also use an oil based makeup remover because this does not budge !!!
Kenya from Chicago
I tried the blue for the first time and love it. Wish there was a pink😊
Zora from La
Its so bad. Bring bsck the old vinyl formula!! Even the old matte formula was bettsr than this. It dried out TWO DAYS after i opened it and it just flakes off after applied. Shame.
JENNII from IL
THIS EYELINER IS AMAZING! DOES NOT BUDGE OR SMUDGE
from St. Pete, FL
Terrible product and I ended up returning it. The liquid is thick and goopy. It gets caught in my eyelashes and gets everywhere. Not sure if I got a bad batch, but I returned it because it was unusable.
S from California
This is a nice eyeliner that glides on easily, but I honestly wouldn't purchase it again. It's supposed to be ling lasting, but it comes off easily. I shake the liner well before applying, but after a couple strokes I have to shake whole thing again to get product; I cant just dip it in, which is inconvenient. This eyeliner would be best for beginners.
Angie from Lewisville, TX
This is my second time purchasing and I am hooked. I know there are some negative reviews, but I have only had positive experiences with this eyeliner. I will purchase it again and again, unless I find a better product for less. The eyeliner is easy to use and looks good, no matter what style I'm going with for the day.
Lauren from Detroit, MI
I wear a cat-eye look every single day and this liner is not only precise, it's easy to use if you're used to using liquid liners. It's extremely waterproof so you really need makeup remover to take it off, but that's just what I need! I love this liner!!!!