Rated 3.48 out of 5 stars
This is by far the best mascara on the market and I've tried them all. I honestly can understand how anyone has had a problem with this product because I've rn blown away. I have naturally long and full lashes so Iv been searching for a mascara that will be volumizing but not clumpy or too thick. This mascara was able to wrap every lash in a perfect coat of mascara giving me the full dark lashes i've been searching for. I had no issue with the wand wing too big, the wand never even hit my eyelid or anything. On top of that I went to the beach later on in the day it was 93 degrees out and it didn't budge from sweat even a little. When I went in the ocean I was knocked down and completely submerged by waves multiple times and somehow the mascara stayed 100% in place, no smudging or racoon eyes or anything, just perfect lashes. By the end of that day the mascara was still in place and my lashes looked exactly how they did when Iapplied this. I never write reviews but this product deserves recognition. If your looking for dramatic eyes and want a mascara that is SERIOUSLY water proof this one is easily the best choice. My new absolute favorite product!
Super disappointed. I was really excited for the release of this but it let me down in so many ways.
First, as many have pointed out, the brush is HUGE. I have medium-sized eyes with hooded lids. I was able to apply it without getting it everywhere, but it was not easy.
Second, the packaging itself is larger than it needs to be, and as a result I was unable to fit it in my usual makeup bag (which has always been able to hold my mascara). It also wasn't particular comfortable in the hand.
Third, while the product itself performed decently (the first couple of uses), I saw no improvement over other, less-expensive mascaras. Honestly, there really doesn't seem to be a point to having such a huge brush... it didn't do anything.
But this is where it really started to go downhill.
After just a few uses, the "hourglass" design of the brush showed its poor engineering. The product began to collect in the middle of the brush (in the "skinny" part of the "hourglass") where the tube couldn't pull it off. The brush quickly began to degrade from there; the bristles are soft, so they began clumping together and being sort of flattened, until it got to the point where you pretty much just got a huge dollop of mascara when you pulled the brush out of the bottle.
So after about a week, it became all but useless. I gave it a few more tries before throwing it out. I'm very glad I used points to get this, and didn't pay actual money, or I would've been pretty upset because this is one of the more expensive mascaras out there.
Would not buy again, and would not recommend.
from Tampa FL
Great product. Putting on mascara became easy when I discovered this product. Only problem is you can't use the Ulta coupons for this product because it is considered a specialty product.
Mary Jane from Columbus, Ohio
I love Too Faced Better than Sex mascara, so I had to have this when it first came out. I absolutely LOVED how it made my lashes look, with just one application. Then I got sad...I was about 2 hours into my day and I ended up having 2 black eyes, it had come off.
Kelly from CA corona
I bought this to give it a try I've been shopping around for new one and I'm hooked on this one. Makes long fluffy lashes makes you look like your wearing false lashes...you must give it a try
Shae from White House, TN
Messy, clumpy and not worth the money spent
Glamapanda from Hattiesburg, MS
I originally tried this mascara when I received a sample in 2020. I've tried various others since then and keep coming back to this one. My lashes look incredible and somehow it makes my eyes look more green. It is thick and I would venture to say not for a novice mascara user. But I've never had an issue with it clumping, flaking or drying out.
Tricia from Mechanicsburg, PA
I thought based on the price this mascara would be wonderful. Unfortunately, it flakes and gets clumped up to the point where the flakes land on your cheeks. So disappointing.
Keegan from New Jersey
This mascara coats lashes, but doesn't lengthen as well as other mascaras I've seen. The shape of the brush isn't effective, it goes on clumpy and starts flaking after 1 hour of wear.
Riss14 from Maryland
I have mixed feelings about this mascara. In some aspects it's great like how it gives you nice thicker, longer looking lashes.. but it does seem to clump a bit.
Jess from New York
Not a fan of the formula and the brush.
Alterego from NY
Makes your lashes look longer with no smudges
Heather from Hillsboro, OR
I absolutely love what this did for my lashes (They seriously looked fake)! But it flakes... and not just a little bit :( I'm so sad that this flakes!
Liz from Meridian ID
The mascara comes out in a big glob on the wand and no amount of scrapping it off helped. When I applied it to my lashes it clumped them together and felt like they were caked in mud.
Charlotte NC from Charlotte NC
I've used it before thought it was great. Went on sale. I figured I'd buy it again. Not sure if it was a bad batch, but it left mascara on my eyelids. Every single time I've worn it and that's without going out or doing anything physical simply going to work and sitting at a desk … Not sure how you feel but I it is extremely embarrassing to not have a mirror in front of you 24/7 with this mascara as I had a 20 minute discussion with a client, then minutes after they leave - see a mirror & realize mascara has lash marks alllllll over your eyelids - leaving you looking - completely ridiculous.
I like this brand but this mascara has gone down hill :( it never used to do this! :(
Jess from Ohio
The first use was great, but it seems like as soon as the formula is exposed to air it becomes thick and unusable. I used it twice, and now the brush comes out of the bottle with the bristles slicked down completely due to the thickness of the mascara itself. Unusable.
kayla from california
wand way too big, messy application, I've used better mascara with length/volume
Jess from california
I opened the mascara for the very first time, straight out of the box and the brush was smashed with tons of dried clumpy product covering it. Completely unusable. I've never seen any other mascara ever have this issue to this extreme.
This mascara is so amazing and separates every lash! Lasts all day with no flakes. Will be buying again!
Lydia from Michigan
Way too thick and too many clumps
Kait from Humble
It actually works really good. I was really scared to try it out but it's honestly worth it. You can really see the difference between your natural lash to when you put the mascara on. 10/10.
Em from Michigan
For almost $30 this is not it. I struggle just to do a simple makeup look with the amount of clumps this mascara produces
Amber from IL
Wanted to love this but the wand is way too big and made my eyelashes feel so heavy! I have never had a mascara do this before. The color is good-everything else was not.
Steph from Wilmington, Delaware
I love big brushes and I love this 8 figured shape. It doesn't clump at all. Keeps all the lashes separated which I love. You can definitely build it up if you want them thicker. The tip of the brush is alittle bit big for the inner corner of my eye personally but i still use it and work with it. But all in all, it's a great mascara and the packaging is too cute. I don't really care about the case. I just want the product to be good. It happened to be on sale at the time so I grabbed it and glad I did.
Hala from Salt Lake City, UT
I love this mascara. I love the way it looks and how big and full my lashes are with it. I wish it was waterproof. It feels like it either dries out or I run out quickly. Also, if my eyes water at all, and they get any touch of the mascara, they burn terribly. I have never run into anything like this with any mascaras. I do have some allergies and can't use some mascaras (ie the Better Than Sex one), but this one supposedly doesn't contain the ingredient I am allergic to.
Holly from Valparaiso, IN
I was so excited after I was gifted this mascara but that quickly turned to frustration. This mascara is ridiculously clumpy, goopy, and just made my eyelashes look WORSE. The wand is so big it's impossible to focus on where you're putting the wand.