Product Reviews Rated 3.42 out of 5 stars
19 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great product. Great for a smokey eye.
Most Helpful Critical Review Smudges I was so excited to try this product because of a good review from a popular youtuber. However this product smudged/transferred down to my lower lash line after a few hours of wear. Super sad because it applied so nicely and dried matte!! I even tried it again and set it with a black powder. Still gave me panda eyes. I'll be sticking with my physicians formula eye booster liner (brush tip) that's incredibly easy to apply and doesn't budge all day.
Reviewed by 19 customers not good 3
Ash B. from Florida
Waste of money
Dried real quick 1
Mizo from Knoxville
I thought this would be a great liner because it was super wet when I first used it but the next day it was so dried out! I even store them upside down to make sure product stays at the tip. I'm very disappointed!
Transfers 1
Elou from Wyoming
The color is dark and application is easy but it transfers so badly. I have tried everything. I set my eye shadow with powder, I set my eyes with setting spray, I have set the eyeliner with translucent powder... nothing works it smudges and transfers to the upper lid no matter what.
Would not buy again 1
mlb388 from Indianapolis, IN
I saw so many rave reviews for this liner and several youtubers recommended it, so I decided to try it out. The first line was great - very black, matte and smooth. However, after that first line, it was basically useless. Once it got some eyeshadow on the tip of the pen, it no longer worked very good. I couldn't even finish one eye with it. I let it set and tried to use it the next day and the same thing happened. I wish I would have just spent a little more money and got a better eyeliner.
not a fan 2
Trishie from Philadelphia
I really didn't like this liner. application didn't go on smooth and was messy throughout the day. I wouldn't purchase this again.
BEST. EYELINER. EVER. 5
Ambria from Pittsburgh, Pa
OMGGGG this liner is life changing. Literally the best eyeliner I have ever used - even compared to many popular higher-end felt tip pens (i.e. Kat Von D etc.). It is so inexpensive and yet its performance far surpasses any others I've used. Don't think, just buy. You'll thank me later.
Best eyeliner pen 5
Holly from Pa
The best eyeliner pen I've ever used! The felt tip never gets wonky after using it.
LOVE ❤️ 5
Heather from Tampa fl
This is great and affordable. Super black and goes on easily. Will be getting this from now on!
Great product 5
Jmg53088 from Las vegas, nv
I absolutely loved this product! So much pigment!
Will be returning 2
Sarah from Austin, TX
I bought this product based on the glowing review of a popular Youtuber who I really trust- unfortunately, though, this product just didn't work for me and I will be returning it. While the liner swatches a beautiful, dark black and the felt tip is perfectly nice, this product is simply way too watery and runs like no other. My eye watered a little while I was applying liner, and I immediately had jet-black tears running down my face. This doesn't happen with other felt tip liners I've tried. The liner also smudges and just doesn't have any staying power. I was willing to try to make it work, but the last straw was when I pulled off the cap and some sort of plastic insert remained on the liner pen- it obviously was supposed to remain in the cap to protect the felt tip, but I couldn't get it to stay in the cap after that, and removing it just resulted in watery black product getting everywhere! Sad to say I'm going to be returning this.
Great 4
Ash from Florida
It's nice to have a cheaper alternative since I always stuck to Kat Von D trooper. This eyeliner dries to a matte which I definitely appreciate. I do have some issues with applying it though. The tip is just a little too long and saturated. I end up getting a little bit on my lid and such. But other than that, it's great. I would definitely repurchase. :)
Soooo good! 5
Ally from AZ
Really versatile bold black color easy to apply however you like your liquid eyeliner!
I would buy this product again !!!! 5
Nana from Puerto Rico
Great product
Applied beautifully, then it went downhill 1
Clever Name from Las Vegas, NV
I bought this in the endless search for the perfect eyeliner. It applied beautifully and I even had a fantastic wing with almost no effort. I really though this might be a new favorite. And then I looked in the mirror about 4 hours later and found that I looked like a raccoon. It had transferred from my upper eyelid and migrated into awful clumped splotched on my undereye. I had not lined my lower lid, nor did I try any crazy tightlining with a new product. The amount of transfer was awful, and I was embarrassed when I looke in the mirror and saw how crazy I looked. Save your money and your shame. Do not buy this.
Great product. 4
LoLo from San Diego, CA
Great for a smokey eye.
Smudges 2
SweetPeachBeauty from Birmingham, AL
I was so excited to try this product because of a good review from a popular youtuber. However this product smudged/transferred down to my lower lash line after a few hours of wear. Super sad because it applied so nicely and dried matte!! I even tried it again and set it with a black powder. Still gave me panda eyes. I'll be sticking with my physicians formula eye booster liner (brush tip) that's incredibly easy to apply and doesn't budge all day.
black as night 5
brig from Indiana
this is such a great eyeliner. its so black, easy to use, and it doesn't skip.
Intense black color; but a little hard to apply 4
the_lady_in_red from NJ
The felt tip on this eyeliner is a little bit long and hard to control to get that perfect wing. However, the eyeliner flows out of the tip seamlessly and easily without skipping. That's a plus and hard to find in a felt tip eyeliner. Also, the black is INTENSELY bold and black. The width of the felt tip allows for a thin line that's buildable to a thicker line.
Best eyeliner I've ever tried 5
Brianna from Buffalo, NY
I'm an avid cat-eye wearer and I've used many, many brands of eyeliners and this is BY FAR the best to use. It's so bold and very easy to apply. The tip isn't thin but it isn't too thick either; it's perfect for a sharp wing and a nice even line over the lashes. Bonus points for being called Wing Woman!!!
