Rated 3.81 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Flaky, but an excellent accent
I got this because... it's white liquid eyeliner. So many possibilities. After trying it, however, I've confirmed that I'm pretty much just using white out! That's not exactly a bad thing, but I'm really not joking. Get out a container of classic white out, and open it up. Look at the brush, then draw a line on the back of your hand. You have now swatched NYX's White Liquid Liner. It requires a very steady and patient hand to apply, and it is kind of flaky. I mostly use it under my eye pulled up along my cat eye, so it's not too noticeable, but you won't be able to do looks like they advertise (huge graphic lines) without noticing the cracking and flaking.
Most Helpful Critical Review It stains clothes!!
I've had the same experience with this product as most people here and I'm
moderately satisfied with it. however!!! it's like paint! like acrylic paint! It flakes and crumbles when you set it with powder, and looks chalky when you don't. It's very nicely pigmented, but you can't build it up if there's a clear spot bc it will just flake off. Overall, I like the product, but using for much more than freckles/dots is not recommended.
Reviewed by 1026 customers They stink...
Sam from Wisconsin
They work well, but they smell awful.
EL from CA
it cracks easily and doesn't last and doesn't apply smoothly by far not a good liner that I have purchased !
In a League of Its Own!
Mel from Tx
This is by FAR the best eyeliner I have ever used. I tend to rub my eyes when I get frustrated and this bad boy doesn't budge! It is superior to even their other eyeliners. It stays on all day, which is a major plus.
I like that I can make a really thin line and then build it up for a more dramatic look.
Hands down THE best!
Mel from Chicago
I live for my liquid eyeliners. I've painted on cat eyes for 20 years and this is by far my fav!! Total precision and lasts all day , bold and fierce. Thin beautiful application.
Stel from San Antonio, Texas
I have used this eyeliner for quite awhile and I really like it, it goes on very smoothly and last all day
QweenLT13 from New Mexico
Best eyeliner ever!!! Tried many and this is my favorite!! Have to keep a tube on hand.. can't risk running out...
my go to liner
lee from texas
i have been using this liner since 2019 i love love love this liner waterproof stays on all day,, black black color i love it sm will continue to buy it💜
JKH from United States
I usually like Nyx liners. However this one was terrible. It dries really crackily and will continue to chip off for as long as you choose to wear it. I will probably not buy this again. I will look for a different white liner.
Repsihw from WI
I love all of NYX liquid liners, so I thought I'd try this one. Even applying it super thinly, it cracks & then it looks soooo horrible. It looks amazing til it dries! Lol
Leeuugh from Miami
The handle sucks makes it very hard to get a clean line
difficult to use & cracks every time
requisha from LA, CA
i bought this eyeliner hoping it would work as well as their epic ink liner but it's nothing close. this liner cracks and the brush isn't even so there's so much room for mistakes. the ink runs out in the middle of using it and i would just not recommend overall.
Cracks a lot
Momo from Swagistan
I love NYX products so much, but honestly this liner was not it. It cracks heavily when it drys, and adding more makes it much worse. It looks dry and flaky, and honestly really gross, it almost dries like white out. I don't really recommend this product.
Not the best
It's alright from Portland
This eyeliner cracks an flakes off. If you put it in a place that has literally NO movement it'll be fine, but it'll crack anywhere that moves a lot. I will not be repurchasing, but I will continue to use until I am done with it.
stays on through crying
Red from Alabama
i cry all the time (i'm a happy crier, angry crier, i cry laughing, i get emotional easily) and last week i had a day where i was crying almost nonstop. my drugstore mascara was running down my face but this liner pulled through and did not budge. i find it easy to do a cat eye with, it's stayed on through lots of sweaty workouts, and it can survive my cry sessions. strongly recommend.
Not a fan
Sami from Salem
I love NYX's other liners, but the white tends to bleed and crack. It's not the most pigmented either. You can kinda build it if you apply layers but it's gonna crack....
LC from NY
I've been using this eyeliner for years! I've tried almost every liquid eyeliner from Elf to KVD and I just keep going back to this one
Vanessa from Monrovia
I love the matte liquid liner by nyx but they happened to be sold out so I gave this one a shot and absolutely not sis. Drys super fast, cracks, and flakes. It also smeared a lot when applying it. Kinda hard to take off
I got the black eyeliner and i swear by it
Freya from PNW
Goes on nicely stays on all day and not easy to rub off. Nice sleek finish. Only downfall is if it gets on your lashes it makes the crispy a bit, i usually get my fingers wet with water and pull on my lashes lightly to get it off, otherwise i love it
Katrina from Antelope
This liner is only good when you use it in your crease line. I wouldn't use it for an eyeliner cause it cracks. Still like it tho.
Evie from USA
Bright but after 30 minutes it starts cracking and flakes
Hsbugg from Ohio
NYX has always had my favorite eyeliners and they keep impressing me! Easy to use, dries fast, great!
I would probably buy it again due to non allergic reaction
Allergic to everything from Cushing OK
I use it daily and it is hard to put on.
Super chic liner!
Cassidy D from Benton il
This liner was super cute! I just had to make sure that it dried enough otherwise it could transfer or crack, stayed on through taking a shower and forgetting to take it off!
Cc02 from CT
Super matte black. Very easy to work with. Doesn't get flakey no matter how many times you go over it.
Lilly Ann from Lafayette, Louisiana
The idea behind this was nice, but this liner dried up so fast and gave me a messy bottom liner (waterline) look. It wouldn't be bad if it didn't dry out and skip as you apply.