Rated 3.8 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Flaky, but an excellent accent
I got this because... it's white liquid eyeliner. So many possibilities. After trying it, however, I've confirmed that I'm pretty much just using white out! That's not exactly a bad thing, but I'm really not joking. Get out a container of classic white out, and open it up. Look at the brush, then draw a line on the back of your hand. You have now swatched NYX's White Liquid Liner. It requires a very steady and patient hand to apply, and it is kind of flaky. I mostly use it under my eye pulled up along my cat eye, so it's not too noticeable, but you won't be able to do looks like they advertise (huge graphic lines) without noticing the cracking and flaking.
Most Helpful Critical Review It stains clothes!!
I've had the same experience with this product as most people here and I'm
moderately satisfied with it. however!!! it's like paint! like acrylic paint! It flakes and crumbles when you set it with powder, and looks chalky when you don't. It's very nicely pigmented, but you can't build it up if there's a clear spot bc it will just flake off. Overall, I like the product, but using for much more than freckles/dots is not recommended.
Reviewed by 1056 customers My go-to eyeliner
Dr Lady B from Cleveland Ohio
Stacking colors with this as the base color.
Favorite liquid eyeliner
Heather from Florida
This is easily my favorite liquid eyeliner. I have tried multiple EXPENSIVE, well-known brands and none of them work like this. The tube lasts forever and doesn't get all dried out like other brands I've used. It lasts long and I've never had issues with flaking like other reviews have stated. I actually can sleep in this eyeliner and touch it up in the morning and it looks as good as new. I 100% recommend this to all of my friends and get compliments on it almost every time I wear it. I have sensitive, "normal" skin. I am not too oily or too dry. It can definitely be messy if you are not used to applying liquid eyeliner and can be a real pain if you get it in your eye.
Jenny from Az
Cracks so bad dosent go on smoothly hate it worse eyeliner I've used
Good product but feels weird on the eye
Abby from St. Louis, MO
I like the small tip of the brush so I can apply the product precisely, but once it dries it makes my eyelidss feel like they have been painted on, like they are heavy and something is preventing them from opening and closing normally. It's like the eyeliner dries really stiff; most products you cannot even tell you're wearing anything, but with this, I constantly feel it on my eyes.
Not for people who wear contacts
Kelley from CA
It's pretty but it crumbles off your eyes throughout the day and gets in your eye. Ripped 2 pairs of contacts
I love eyeliners
babygirl from Pascagoula Mississippi
this is what I needed for my eye liner collection to make awesome eye looks on special occasions and birthdays
Maddie29 from Illinois
I think that this product is good if you like a wetter formula. The liner is definitely very wet and when I put it on my lash line and then open my eye, it will get all over my lid. I also don't love the applicator. It is more of a brush tip with bristles than a marker tip. It does glide on very smoothly, which is good. It also looks nice once you clean it up. I think this is a decent product, but I don't think I'll be buying it again.
Dry, flaky, no
L from Utah
It goes on so patchy and runny, and once it dries down it starts flaking off. I had to scrub my eye with a q-tip to get it to flake off because my regular makeup cleanser couldn't remove it. Totally ruins any makeup look you try it with.
bryce from atlanta
it's LITERALLY white out, do NOT get this. i've had a better experience with NYX's other colors of liquid (tried the blue and purple liquid liners). it's still thick and goopy and kinda flaky when it dries but it looks nice from afar.
I wouldn't buy this product again.
no from no
I did not like it. I mean, it's okay, but it gets really flakey and like crumbles and cracks on your skin. It kinda reminds me of white out, but like okay for your eyes. I would recommend finding another eyeliner. If you really want one for this price, then it won't kill you, but finding a more expensive one/better one in general will be worth your time.
Cracked Right Away
MUA Flo from Hoffman Estates
The product was smaller than I expected but that's beside the point. I certainly wasn't impressed with the quality of the liner. It cracked right away after drying. Unfortunately, I won't be buying it again. My search for a white liquid liner continues.
yellowvicki from Simi Valley, CA
it was kinda hard to open up, it was good while it lasted! Wish there was more product in it & wish it didn't dry out so quickly :(
Kate from Seattle, WA
I'm pretty sure the only reason this has okay reviews is because there's so few white eyeliners to pick from, but that's no excuse. It's thick, gloopy, patchy, feels terrible to wear, and starts flaking off as soon as you put it on. The "pros" are that it looks semi-okay from far away for like an hour or if you use it for some other purpose I guess, but it definitely doesn't work as a normal liquid liner. Clown makeup would literally work better than this.
Good color but she thicc
Craftygirl_nic from Michigan
So I love the idea of white eyeliner. And wanted to love this so much.... I had to do multiple layers as the first mixed with the shadow pigment. The brush is too long in my opinion so the control lacks there (user error?) eventually it looked great! But I felt it tighten on my eyelid and then noticed small cracks... removing it was ok until the swelling started. I used micellar water(my go to) let it sit for a moment and gently removed it not my eyes are still swollen :(
Kristina from TN
I have used the entire bottle of this eyeliner and it works beautifully. NOT smelly, NOT sticky, NOT thick. It doesn't crack AT ALL!! Even with my oily eyelids it stays put for hours!! And it does come off easily with makeup remover wipes. (Duh it's what they're made for??) I don't know why people are saying these things because mine was absolutely amazing!!
Rose from Wisconsin
It comes off easily with baby wipes so idk how someone couldn't get it off, I also didn't notice a bad smell, it does crack but it's not noticeable by other people. It's not that thick either. It works pretty well, just fix the cracking and it's 5 stars.
worst eyeliner ever
nikki from Georgia
i have tried this eyeliner too many times and it's pretty much never pulled through. it cracks too easy and when I have colorful eyeshadow, it picks up from that color.
maya from ma
amazing for the price and very pigmented
My ride or die.
glorymakeup1 from California
I love it.
my go too...
Dee from el paso texas
my favorite liquid eye liner
Alyssa < 3 from Turlock, Ca
This liner is absolutely gorgeous but it does crack so beware. I was doing my eyeshadow and I added a white line to my cut crease and it cracked so bad
BEST LINER EVER!!!
Alyssa :) from California
I've been a fan of this liner for over 3 years now and wow I just love it!!! It goes on very smooth but beware if you're a beginner at liner because it goes on like a paintbrush, I would recommend using tape as an outline.
Sammm from San Antonio
10/10 I've actually only tried like two or three other eyeliners because this one is definitely the best! (BETTER THAN THE MATTE ONE) The brush is super thin and the liner stays put all day! In the past I've had my eyeliner smudge and get messed up throughout the day, but this ones perfect! It stays put and comes right off with water. LOVE IT
well it definitely stays put..
Bex from Atlanta
Picked this up and did a quick little test wing in the car, it came out pretty sloppy cause the formula is pretty thick and hard to work with. I also had a VERY hard time removing it. After using my normal makeup wipes, cleansing oil, Clarisonic + foaming deep cleanser, AND makeup eraser I still couldn't get off the rest of the liner and ended up going to bed with white liner still on my eyes. If you're looking for something LONG lasting this is absolutely it.
kevan from texas
very pigmented can't wait to try on a full face look. and didn't notice a bad smell like another reviewer said.