Product Reviews Rated 1.81 out of 5 stars
32 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great Mascara I need waterproof mascara as I am a woman who laughs a lot with tears streaming down my face! This mascara goes on beautifully, but also is easy to remove. Some waterproof mascara is impossible to remove. Also, it gives me length and definition without looking heavy or clumping!
Most Helpful Critical Review Bad applicator design The mascara itself seems to be good. It lasts all day, doesn't flake off, and gives me super long lashes. The applicator design is HORRIBLE though. There is no rubber 'flange' at the opening, to clean off some of the product, so the wand comes out with globs everywhere. It's very hard to apply evenly, and without it looking like a spider is crawling out of your eyeball. I have to use an eyelash comb between every layer, to clean up the globs. I tried to replace the wand, with one from another Ulta mascara, but the tubes are different sizes. I like the mascara, so I'll continue to fight through the application. It just takes much longer, to get a clean look.
Reviewed by 32 customers What a waste 1
Plowdriver from Ohio
What was wrong with the old amped up mascara! This replacement is awful. Absolutely hate this. Bring the waterproof amped up back. It was a great mascara. The brush is so wrong.
Worst mascara i've ever used PLEASE BRING BACK AMPED LASHES 1
Carly from US
I would give this zero stars if i could. It's so thick and uncurls my eyelashes and is so clumpy and isn't separating on my lashes whatsoever. PLEASE BRING BACK YOUR AMPED WATERPROOF MASCARA!! I got so many compliments on that amped lashes mascara it was my favorite for months i'm so sad to see it gone:( now i need to find a replacement which isn't going well so please please bring back amped lashes!!!!!
Clumps and doesn't curl 2
Laurie from Lexington KY
Purchased because of Ulta promotion. Was not happy with how it clumps and doesn't hold curl on lashes
Not waterproof 1
Rudiments from Texas
Tried using the mascara several times but it was not waterproof.
Love this product! 5
Kdgum from Bloomsburg, PA
I really do love this product. It makes my lashes look amazing. It can make a mess on the tube when closing. Otherwise I really like this product!
No 1
None from Eldersberg
I did not like it at all and will be returning it. Way too gloppy and hard to apply
Awful replacement for Amped waterproof 1
Momw2ms from Connecticut
Wanted to buy Amped waterproof, seems to have been replaced by this. Applicator brush is weird shape with too much product in it. I have tiny lashes, and can barely get this on. Never had any problem with the old product. Will not buy again, will have to shop around for a new favorite waterproof.
A goopy globby disappointment 1
Sara from Arizona
I really liked the Amped mascara that was waterproof and I am sorely disappointed in this new version of Ulta's waterproof mascara. It goes on in globs, and is goopy and the mascara seems to just sit at the roots of my eyelashes. It stays wet after application so it is messy if you blink within 3 minutes of applying and the wand is a hot mess.
Disappointing 1
Katie from Providence, Rhode Island
I wish I had read the reviews before I bought this :( The previous version of this waterproof mascara (amped) was the best mascara I'd ever used, but this update is the worst. The wand is so chunky that the product clumps up your lashes, and it's unavoidable that you get it on your skin too, because of the huge globs. Washing it off is a whole other mess, because it flakes and smears the product everywhere.
If it's not broken, don't try to fix it!!! 1
M from Chicago, IL
This is a HORRIBLE replacement for the waterproof amped lashes mascara. That was my favorite mascara--never clumped, went on evenly, waterproof, perfect amount went on lashes with each application. This? It's awful. The applicator is the worst--the mascara comes out clumpy and it's hard to use. Too much mascara is on the brush so my lashes look way too black and clumpy. Bring back the old version!
Horrible replacement for previous product! 1
Linda in Galveston from Galveston, TX
This used to be my favorite mascara. I switched from Lancome and was saving $$$. Now I'm going back to Lancome and this product is going in the trash. I would have given it no stars if that had been an option.
Great Mascara 5
Maria from West coast, FL
I need waterproof mascara as I am a woman who laughs a lot with tears streaming down my face! This mascara goes on beautifully, but also is easy to remove. Some waterproof mascara is impossible to remove. Also, it gives me length and definition without looking heavy or clumping!
NO!! 1
Me from NJ
Way too much product comes out on the brush. Which leads to massive product on your skin not on your lashes. I had to use a tissue to remove the product from the brush in order to put product on my eye. Waste of money and waste of time.
NOT Waterproof 1
Renee from AR
This is messy, doesn't separate lashes, and is definitely NOT waterproof.
Too goopy... 1
Bee from Prescott AZ
I have never used a mascara that was so thick and goopy. It globs so much product on the lashes and makes a disasterous mess. I have to use a fine comb or Qtip to remove the excess.
Unfortunately, I grabbed two of them for the buy 2 get one free sale. I will probably take it back.
However, once it is on its fine. No flaking or sprinkling on the cheeks. And it's waterproof. So if you can get through the application, it's fine.
Not my favorite 2
Mizzy from Washington
Not my favorite mascara at all. The brush is bulky and the mascara clumps.
Terrible replacement for Grey Waterproof Amped Lashes 1
Mary Ellen from Hemet CA
I bought this mascara as a replacement to to the Waterproof Amped Lashes. It is horrible. The applicator is not one size like the the previous. The mascara is lumpy, and not smooth like the prior. Can you please bring back the Amped Lashes, this is a horrible replacement!
Please bring back the old version! 1
Alix from Nashville, TN
This used to be my absolute favorite mascara. When I went to Ulta a few weeks back to purchase more, I noticed that the tube was different, but it was fine because it had the same description, and it wasn't the first time I've seen them change the packaging. However, this is the first time they have altered the actual product itself. This is the absolute worst mascara I have ever purchased; and I purchased TWO. It's a tube full of gloopy gunk on a horribly lame and inadequate applicator wand. You will wind up with spider lashes with just one coat. Not to mention, removing it at the end of the day will also turn it back into that gloopy, caked-on mess, but all over your face. Then, it just continues to smudge and move all around your face when you're trying to wipe it off your skin. Seriously. I'm talkin' major raccoon eyes. ULTA—please bring back the old version!!! ðŸ˜ðŸ˜ðŸ˜
Messy Application 2
Teary Eyed from Michigan
My eyes tend to water a lot but I was trying to get away from waterproof mascara. Couldn't stand the raccoon eyes so back to waterproof this was recommended to me. The formula seems OK from a waterproof standpoint, but the brush makes application difficult unless you wipe most of the product off with a tissue. Scraping on the tube doesn't cut it so that means lots of wasted mascara.
I wanted to like it but it's horrible. 1
Jenn from Bristol, Indiana
The brush was amazing but the formula for the mascara was not! Not waterproof. Not even at a good quality non waterproof. Put dry eye drops in which I do everyday and mascara was EVERYWHERE! Mad I got sucked into purchasing.
The absolute worst! 1
Pampamw1967 from Weatherford, TX
I have never been so disappointed in an ULTA brand product until now... This mascara replacement, upgrade, or whatever they were going for is the worst mascara in the store. I have to use waterproof mascara to keep the curl on my lashes. I went through pretty much every waterproof mascara in the store to find the best mascara I have ever used which was the grey tube before you replaced it with this. I am taking this back, and will never purchase again!! Bring back the one that worked!!!
Applicator 1
g. from Idaho
The applicator is awful, it clumps on the brush. I loved the amped lashes brush this one not at all.
Worst brush ever, the other amped waterproof mascara great! 1
Georgia from Idaho
I opened this and the brush is awful, it clumps the mascara on. I loved the amped lashes brush!
Bring back the grey tube 1
LH from IL
I think this product replaced Ulta's grey tube of waterproof mascara. This product is a huge downgrade from the previous mascara. It's hard to apply, the application brush is chunky, the mascara runs (not waterproof) and it doesn't hold your eyelashes "up"
Love 5
Krista from 93117
Such a great mascara and waterproof. Makes my lashes look amazing