Product Reviews Rated 3.29 out of 5 stars
17 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing Mascara I've tried great mascaras but this one beats them all. It separates my lashes and lengthens them beautifully. I've always had long lashes so most mascaras work for me but this one is just great! Elf is stepping up their game.
Most Helpful Critical Review Good price for a natural look Applies easily without getting on skin, and looks great for natural look for those with blonde or smaller lashes. I've always been lucky in the lash department so it's a good day or night look for me. My only issue is, while it's nice & creamy - not flaky, is that it takes so long to dry compared to lower price brands. So an hour or two after applying if my hand, glasses or something lighty brushes against my lashes they are ruined stuck together & misshapen. So much so that I have to remove all my eye make up and start from scratch. Never had to do that with other mascaras after letting them dry.
Reviewed by 17 customers No 1
Cailean from TX
It didn't work with my lashes and it didn't really make my lashes bigger very sad customerš¢
read this review 3
me from long beach
my mom and sister say it's good but for me it chunks up and never dries! two hours after I put it on and it smudges like crazy. I know it's not a lot of money but DONT waist it!
My Favorite Mascara Right Now 5
Great Mascara from New Jersey
The color is very good . When applied , it is not clumpy at all . It glides on so well . After I apply it , it looks like I have falsies on . It's not heavy feeling , the only thing is I wish it was waterproof , but I can live without it being waterproof .
I would buy it again 4
None from Moreno Valley Ca
I like it, it works great
Too heavy 1
Ash from Orlando, Florida
This is the worst mascara I have ever used. I have natural long lashes and this mascara weighted them down and made them look short and clumpy. You're better off spending a bit more and getting one from NYX or Maybelline
AMAZING FOR LAYERING 5
Hannah from CA
Not much on its own, but when I later it over any other mascara, even if that mascara is dry, this makes it look amazing
Have mix fellings 3
Libby from United States
Very smooth and does dry out quick. Nice about of product. But doesn't dry on lashes, clumps on lashes, not a natural look.
Super flaky 2
Lemons13 from Philadelphia, PA
I used this for about 2 months and found it became super flaky after just a few uses. And the bottle started to lose color/come off in flakes on my hands, which was hard to get off. I recommend spending the extra money to get something better.
Like this mascara 5
Kerry from Massachusetts
Really good for the natural look I like. Not good if you like bigger bolder lashes.
Good-Ish 3
Mya from North Carolina
The mascara is good, but it's very easy to get on the eyelids if you aren't careful. It also takes a little while to dry.
Good 4
Ur mom from Texas
Great for the price, good for natural looking eyelashes.
Elf Mascara 4
lalamakeupe from US
If you want a small, natural look, this is for you. It's great for beginners and those 11 year olds that want to wear makeup. You get what you pay for!
Get What You Pay For 3
Dani from Pittsburgh
I got this mascara as a free gift with another ELF purchase. Overall, I like ELF but some of their products are better than others. This mascara is just okay in my opinion. It gives you a subtle, natural look. I prefer big, bold lashes, so this mascara didn't cut it for me.
Djdndb 4
Jessie from CNBC's
It's very creamy but it takes long to dry
Good price for a natural look 3
Zoe from Philly
Applies easily without getting on skin, and looks great for natural look for those with blonde or smaller lashes. I've always been lucky in the lash department so it's a good day or night look for me. My only issue is, while it's nice & creamy - not flaky, is that it takes so long to dry compared to lower price brands. So an hour or two after applying if my hand, glasses or something lighty brushes against my lashes they are ruined stuck together & misshapen. So much so that I have to remove all my eye make up and start from scratch. Never had to do that with other mascaras after letting them dry.
Worth what you pay for 1
Jade from Florida
This mascara is good if you want a very natural look at a great price. I like more dramatic mascara, so it's thin application and barely-there appearance didn't work for me.
Amazing Mascara 5
Madina from Springfield, VA
I've tried great mascaras but this one beats them all. It separates my lashes and lengthens them beautifully. I've always had long lashes so most mascaras work for me but this one is just great! Elf is stepping up their game.
