Product Reviews Rated 3.01 out of 5 stars
71 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best Mascara Ever! I ordered this mascara earlier this month and received it in less than a week after it was processed! I have used extremely expensive mascaras and E.L.F works the best! I have very long stick straight eyelashes that are hard to work with even with the most expensive mascaras they only clump and don't even curl but with E.L.F they curl with just a swipe of this mascara and are actually separated. I cannot use curling wands because they just break my lashes I am so in love with this mascara. On top of everything it will not clump or flake off and dries off pretty quick and is easy to remove.
Most Helpful Critical Review Horrible mascara Usually volumizing mascaras work the best for me but this one is so bad. Hard to apply, doesnt dry fast, if it gets on your skin then it wont come off.. Its super sticky (eyelashes kept sticking together first hour of having it on), doesnt even volumize or do anything to eyelashes no matter how much you add... Very dissapointed. Dont waste your money.
Reviewed by 71 customers I Know It's Cheap, But Not Worth It 2
Tris D from Kansas City
Does not add volume at all, and I already had low expectations because the price was so cheap. It smears into the corners of my eyes by the end of the day and my lashes end up being irritated after only a couple hours. In this case, you get exactly what you paid for and it's not worth it.
NO volume, lots of length. 4
product review. from USA
The formula is pretty liquid like which does not add any volume so I'm very confused about the name. It is a great brush to coat every lash, very pigmented and adds lots of volume. I use it as a base and then put a different mascara on top for volume.
Great product 5
AngelLove from Florida
I've been using the Elf mascara along with the brow and eyeliner pen for over a year. I love all of the products and love even more that they do not test on animals and are a cruelty free company. I've never had any issues with the mascara clumping etc. I will continue to use and high recommend.
Terrible 1
chloe from Kentucky
Consistency is terrible and so is the wand. The mascara was so thick and it clumped up on the wand. It was so sticky and made my top and bottom lashes stick together. Clumps of mascara would land on the base and tips of my lashes and people had to constantly point out that my lashes had clumps. I would not purchase this whatsoever. It didnt even seperate my lashes. Buy the Maybelline Sky High Lash Sensational Mascara instead. You wont regret it
Long lasting 5
Atlantic from Atlantic
I really like this it gets the job done! I bought it like two months ago and I've been using it along with the eyelash primer and it's perfect!
Long lasting 5
Atlantic from undisclosed
I really like this it gets the job done! I bought it like two months ago and I've been using it along with the eyelash primer and it's perfect!
Well it stays on 3
Mea from Lake Charles, LA
If you want a mascara that stays on all day and possibly forever then this is it. It makes my lashes stick together so I can't get them to "fan out" but I only use it to coat them before putting false lashes on and to accentuate my bottom lashes. It's definitely for length, not volume. HOWEVER, I have used 3 different makeup removers and baby soap and it still doesn't come all the way off. I have black smudges under my eyes that are all but impossible to remove and have tried until my eyes are swollen to get it all the way off. So if you want it to stay all day this is it. If you want to be able to take it off eventually this is not a good option.
Good 4
Katena629 from Lancaster Ohio
I love this mascara because it doesn't clump. Gives a beautiful natural look of eyelashes with the great color you want.
Doesn't clump 5
Chrystal2020 from AL
Great inexpensive mascara. Easy to apply and doesn't clump. Definitely buying more .
No 1
Cailean from TX
It didn't work with my lashes and it didn't really make my lashes bigger very sad customer😢
read this review 3
me from long beach
my mom and sister say it's good but for me it chunks up and never dries! two hours after I put it on and it smudges like crazy. I know it's not a lot of money but DONT waist it!
My Favorite Mascara Right Now 5
Great Mascara from New Jersey
The color is very good . When applied , it is not clumpy at all . It glides on so well . After I apply it , it looks like I have falsies on . It's not heavy feeling , the only thing is I wish it was waterproof , but I can live without it being waterproof .
Marvelous Mascara 5
PinkPrincess717 from Fargo, ND
I love this mascara!
It lengthens and adds volume to my lashes!
I would buy it again 4
None from Moreno Valley Ca
I like it, it works great
Horrid 1
Disgusting from undisclosed
Flakey. The mascara had little fibers in it. Those fibers weighed down my lashes and ended up flaking all over my face within an hour.
So beyond dissatisfied with this product. Used once and I'll never use it again.
Marvelous Mascara 5
PinkPrincess717 from Fargo, ND
I love this Mascara!
It gives my lashes extra volume! They look longer and thicker!
It doesn't clump either!
I bough this about a... 5
Jazvaz13 from chicago
I bough this about a month ago and was a bit skeptical because I have very stubborn lashes that never stay curled. But the mascara is lightweight and keeps my lashes curled all day
Too heavy 1
Ash from Orlando, Florida
This is the worst mascara I have ever used. I have natural long lashes and this mascara weighted them down and made them look short and clumpy. You're better off spending a bit more and getting one from NYX or Maybelline
disappointed 1
CC04 from NJ
I have used the volumizing mascara for years but I am so disappointed in the new formula.
AMAZING FOR LAYERING 5
Hannah from CA
Not much on its own, but when I later it over any other mascara, even if that mascara is dry, this makes it look amazing
Have mix fellings 3
Libby from United States
Very smooth and does dry out quick. Nice about of product. But doesn't dry on lashes, clumps on lashes, not a natural look.
Super flaky 2
Lemons13 from Philadelphia, PA
I used this for about 2 months and found it became super flaky after just a few uses. And the bottle started to lose color/come off in flakes on my hands, which was hard to get off. I recommend spending the extra money to get something better.
Like this mascara 5
Kerry from Massachusetts
Really good for the natural look I like. Not good if you like bigger bolder lashes.
Good-Ish 3
Mya from North Carolina
The mascara is good, but it's very easy to get on the eyelids if you aren't careful. It also takes a little while to dry.
Sticky unuseable junk 1
Thirty3 from Ohio
Second elf mascara purchase. Second negative review written. Why elf are your mascaras so sticky??? Absolutely terrible. Takes forever to dry which it never completely does. Sticks top lashes to bottom ones. Not to mention it made my eyes itch so badly I had to take it off, which is a reaction I've never had before and I've tried too many mascaras to count. I'm so aggravated with the awful quality of your mascaras. Also you are the only company I've ever seen that does not even at least offer compensation for an inferior product. For these reasons I've decided to stop buying your products altogether and I was once very brand loyal. Done.
