Rated 4.1 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I LOVE THIS NEW MASCARA!!!
This is a great formula which really makes my lashes pop! They are so full with two coats. Like the instructions says, let it dry for 30 seconds before applying another coat. I am anxious to try the other new mascara, too!
Most Helpful Critical Review Absolutely terrible
Due to skin/eye sensitivities I had to find an all natural alternative. For a 'volumizing' mascara it really doesn't do that. Also it stays sticky so (I have long eye lashes naturally) every time I close my eyes or blink i can feel them forcing apart and the outside ones are staying together for good.
It also clumped a bunch of eyelashes together so it looks like I have 4-5 big eyelash spikes on my eyes instead of nicely separated and coated lashes.
This is terrible. I hope there is a natural makeup company that actually puts out a quality product because this is not good at all.
I don't know how it has any good reviews.
Reviewed by 132 customers Not what i hoped
Amy1999 from California, LA
When i ordered this i was very exited, when i got it i was disappointed. It makes my eyelashes feel like there is a brick on them, and it smudges to easily.
Smudges and flakes easily
Comet20 from Indiana
I had high expectations for this as I love Burt's Bees products! The mascara goes on easily and doesn't have that chemical odor that other mascaras have. However it flakes easily and I had two smudges under my eyes at end of day after carefully applying it.
smudges very easily
melh from new york
Its okay. I don't experience any eye irritation with it and its not drying on my lashes but its claim that it doesn't smudge is bogus. It smudges very easily.
Ann2 from Plano
I purchased this mascara after I decided to go with a more all natural make up brand. I love Burt's Bees lip products and decided to try the eye makeup. I am disappointed overall. The mascara is very dry. I wouldn't purchase it again. It's just ok.
Wanted to love this, but no.
Denis from South Dakota
I love Burt's Bees products and have finally found some that really work well, but this mascara is too dry and clumps. No matter how much product I try to clean off, just still seems to glob. It's too bad as I love the eyeliner. Unfortunately a waste of money for me.
This was the worst mascara I've tried
loeyarlie from Regina Sk
Two problems. #1, the wand delivers waaay too much product no matter how much you scrape it off. You don't see long lashes, you see clumps and globs. #2, the amount of black stingy oily guck in your lower eyelids the next morning. I use a good eye make up remover and am meticulous but this stuff stings and you just can't remove it all no matter what. Never again.
This stuff is amazing for a natural mascara
CCSS from San Diego
I really love this mascara! Its so hard to find a natural based mascara that doesn't clump or smear, all while making your lashes look longer, thicker and more beautiful. I also love the ingredients as well as the smell- reminds me of honey.
Not my fave
Ed567 from Oregon
The other mascara was almost perfect. This has been clumpy and hard to apply with the brush. Don't want to be too harsh just honest. Love everything else Burt's Bees though!
Monibotica from Chandler, Arizona
After 4× using it, it goes on clumpy. Spider legs.
adavis from Alabama
This mascara goes on really well & looks great. But it didn't maintain the curling of my eyelashes. Also it didn't stay put as long as I expected. In my opinion this product could use a little tweaking.
Formula good, wand not so much
Nat from ND
I purchased both of the Burt's Bees new mascaras thinking I would prefer this one because of the brush, but no. The formula is good but the bristles are too short and too far apart, so there's no separation.
HayliehJade from Boston,Mass
I usually get extremely irritated with mascaras but not with burt's and bees my eyes didnt get itchy all day and it lasted all day while at work I am so happy even my mom ditched her old mascara for burt's and bees mascara since we both are sensitive
Burt's Bee's All Aflutter Volumizing Mascara
amandasue1993 from Durand, MI
This Burt's Bee's All Aflutter Volumizing Mascara was pretty good. I am a sucker for nice lashes, and honestly have struggled to find a good mascara that provides the volume I'm looking for but isn't super harmful to my lashes. I have been using this Burt's Bee's mascara for about a month straight and have noticed that I'm not losing as many lashes which is definitely a plus.
I do have other mascara brands that last longer and provide better shape based off of the application brush. I guess it depends what benefits your looking for but I honestly would give up stay-time and a little shape for the benefit of keeping more of my real lashes. In conclusion I will continue to use this product based off of the benefits it seems to have for the health of my lashes, it could be better if it had better shape and was longer lasting but I think the benefit of keeping more of my real lashes definately outweighs that.
Excellent for full, natural lashes
iananna from Dallas, Texas
I have full, dark natural lashes; and, love to try different mascara formulas. Burt's Bees did not let me down. The brush is larger to offer enough product to almost all your lashes in one sweep. It is a little large for use toward the inner eye area. But, that's true of all brands. The formula lasted my whole work day without flaking. No irritation to my eyes. I received the Brown/Black colour; but, would change that option to Black in the future.
My new go-to daily mascara
sofia_maria from Michigan, USA
I was looking for a cruelty free natural Blue mascara when Burts Bees launched this one. When it was brand new, it was a little clumpy just from the volume of product on the wand, but after a week or two it was great! I use it in the morning every day before work and then say goodbye to my dog (a lab/rottweiler mix) he always has a sniff of my eyelashes, so I think he likes the natural ingredients too :)
Veeyon 88 from Eden Prairie, MN
I love the mascara, it gives my eyelashes volume. I love the texture as well. It doesn't cake and leave residue on my eyelashes. Also easy to wipe off. I highly recommend this product and I'm definitely going to get more
Would buy again
Lasemb816 from CT
I'm not a big make up gal but this mascara was great. Went on easy and I didn't have clumps. Lasted most of my day. Didn't feel super fake. I don't have much to compare this too but I world but it again.
ummhamma from Chicago illinois
Works really good. Didn't need many applications at all, loved it the color is great really black which I love. Made my lashes look really full. Really easy to wash off doesnt leave you with raccoon eyes. One bottles lasts a good amount of time.
Such a good mascara!
Aly428 from Illinois
I am SUPER picky with my mascara... it's so easy for it to be a bad one. This one is one of the good ones for sure and I will definitely be repurchasing. The wand is great, and is perfect for doing the lower lashes as well. It doesn't clump like crazy and it builds nicely. A beautiful product!
Best Mascara EVER
Rikki from greenville, mi
Best Mascara ever. I have tried so many different brands of Mascara and this is by far the best one. The wand is not flimsy which helps coat all the eyelashes. It does not clump and dries quick. The only wish I have is that it was waterproof. Which I'm sure there is something but I just love this.
Sticky and clumpy
BeeKeeper5 from undisclosed
I only wore this mascara a few times, but I found it a bit too thick and and made my eyelashes sort of clump together as though I had put on a few coats (yet only had put on one). Too heavy for me and a bit greasy to remove.
Murphy78 from Grafton,WV
I absoltuley love these mascaras. I wear contacts and have a lot of trouble finding mascara that doesn't bother my eyes or causes them to dry out. This is perfect. It also stays on all day but is still easy to wash off.
Did not like
Sla15 from Syracuse, ny
I did not like this product and I hate to say anymore but I can find some of the way it is so cute and I hate to say it was a good day for you to be a part of the way it is so I can find some way to celebrate it was a good day for the holidays and the beast cup of coffee and I hate
Wowwoman from Evansville IN
Literally love the volumizing mascara! Me and my daughters go to as of now . Will be a regular in this home always! Love burt's Bees . Cant wait to try other products and the natural ingredients are a must
Erikahagarty from Orlando, FL
This mascara works pretty well and isn't too heavy or clumpy. It adds a slight curl to your lashes as well. I tried the Navy and it gives a nice little hint of color to my lashes. The container is really nice looking too.