Rated 3.77 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Does not budge!
Primer on it's own gives a soft, medium-full fringe. But with the step 2 mascara, you get super long, curved, stretched-out lashes that lasted all day, then made it through through a two-hour, sweaty workout! Usually use waterproof Voluminous, but this lasted longer without transfer. However-you will need a heavy-duty cream eye-makeup remover to get this stuff off! It does not budge!
Most Helpful Critical Review Good volume
I like the fact that the primer is actually black instead of the usual white. So, it is easier to cover it with the mascara and not have any white fibers showing. It is a nice deep black but it isn't the easiest to apply. I would say I get more volume from this rather than length. It seems to dry out quickly as well. Just an okay mascara for me.
Reviewed by 44 customers VOLUME BUT WITH SERIOUS CONS
Lorilei from New Jersey
L'ORÉAL makes mascaras far better than this.
Great Long Lashes
Southern Belle from Tennessee
Best mascara for long beautiful lashes. It works great with contacts.
snesbear from Minnesota
I wanted a mascara that'd give me volume. This does not. If you want length then this might be for you. But I just want my lashes fanned out with some volume. This did none of that. I tried so hard to separate my lashes. But the first step clumps them together so I have maybe 5-7 lashes. I still haven't found a volumizing mascara.
I would buy again
Isabella from Connecticut
Works very well and lasts a decent amount of time.
Great waterproof mascara
None from None
I like this mascara because it is buildable and the black lash primer is a great idea because the lashes don't appear gray as they would with a white lash primer. Great length and volume. Would recommend.
BusyTwinMom from Upstate, SC
I accidentally picked up the waterproof tube and I will never buy it again! I got home and realize I picked up the wrong thing, but thought I'd give it a try anyway.....WRONG. It wouldn't come off! I tried eye makeup remover, micellar water, and even face wash directly on my eyes and it still wouldn't come off. All I can imagine is if I use this every day imagine the buildup. I would try the regular mascara before I could give a true review but as far as waterproof, it's a no for me.
Love this product
Pumbaaface from Bend, OR
Definitely extends my lashes And makes them look much thicker than they are
Great product for thick, long lashes
Cmpbrown from Durham NC
I have thin lashes and this product thickens and lengthens better than prestige versions.
Kissa from Belmont nc
It's not really that great. I like the double extend wayyyyy better. Had to scrub my lashes with coconut oil to get it off. Made my eyelashes fall out. Fiber mascara remover didn't help at all.
Krystal from Weedsport, ny
I usually use the regular silver packaged voluminous with the white primer so I thought I'd like this since it had black primer. My lashes curl on their own and have good length with any mascara.... so howin the world did this mascara make such a disaster? it was sticky, unworkable, clumpy, no notable length or volume or anything except stuck together, dried out and horrible. Never again. Threw mine out after two attempts
Unfortunately, I would not purchase this product again
Miss Pink from Georgia
This product was priced just right, and I was truly excited about the duo. However, my lashes did not look bold nor voluminous at all. The color of the mascara was quite dull. I will return to using Lancome mascara.
A definite must buy!
ChaChi from Florida
Keeps the curl to my lashes even through hot and humid weather. I've got stick straight Asian hair and this mascara is awesome! I like that the primer is black too which adds more depth to my lashes! Love it!!
Smudges under eyes and won't wash off
Emilath from Az
I tried to remove this with soap, and makeup remover. Nothing would remove it. However, it still did smudge under my eyes after all day wear. Will try the non waterproof next.
Eyes from Wichita, KS
After reading about this, I thought it was going to make my lashes pretty amazing. Not so much...
ali from la
I have very straight lashes that have a hard time holding a curl. I was pleasantly surprised that I liked this mascara, it leaves my lashes looking long and holds a curl.
Cheap poor quality
Jessiey from Spokane wa
The fiber end is a clumpy worthless mess. Dries too fast to apply mascara. The 2 formulas dont seem to play well together. I tried the fiber with an urban decay mascara and mac worked slightly better but the fiber just doesn't do much but make a mess and clump lashes together terribly.
Mascara Go To
Val from Mississippi
This product is my go to for mascara. I love the way the fibers are real lash looking not like mascaras I've tried in the past. I usually just use the fibers first and then apply on any mascara you use on top and use the other end for lower lashes.
I like it, but it flakes.
Catherine from Florida
I like the black primer. I like how my lashes look after I have applied the mascara. But it flakes after a couple of hours.
Mel the Aerialist from Houston, TX
Love this mascara! I have been using this for over a year, and I am always reaching for it. I gently rub almond oil or olive oil to remove the mascara, and the oil hydrates my eyelashes. I don't like eye makeup removers, because they tend to irritate my eyes.
Nettie from Redlands, CA
I have purchased this like 10 times. It's my go to! Love how it gives me length and separates. I sometimes combine it with a more voluminous mascara for that extra sexiness!
Love this product!!!
Trishg from Maryland
I have whimpy eyelashes which I have to curl. Usually primers flatten out the curl but not this product. Lashes stay curled, no dry time for primer.
Sharia from Florida
This has got to be the best mascara I've ever used!! Everyone thinks I'm wearing fake lashes but in actuality it's the mascara. I love it!
Irritates my eyes
Angela from Hayward CA
I don't have sensitive eyes and I've tried tons of mascaras, both drug store and high end. This mascara makes me feel like there is constantly something in my eyes. My eyes also feel very dry. The application looks OK but definitely not worth being uncomfortable all day. I've only used it once and it's going straight in the trash.
if you give neg review you arent using it right
rach from VA
you must prep your eyes. take some coconut oil put then on your lashes let them dry......THEN step 1 and 2. you should be doing that reguardless. start from the root...wiggle and swipe up. I was having the same problem until I did the above. now it's the best one I have ever had!!
Tay from Arkansas
It's not a bad mascara for the price! I LOVE mascara. If I had to have only one makeup item, it's mascara.
The length you get from the primer side is great just in itself, when you add the mascara it's a good amount of volume as well. The downside is...I found myself having to put multiple multiple coats on to get it the way I liked. Dries out somewhat too quickly for my liking.
But It holds the curl great! And it's SUPER waterproof. I've showered and it didn't move! You need a designated waterproof eye makeup remover for this puppy.
I'd probably not buy again, but I've definitely used it until it died!