Rated 4.05 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Love it!!
I have been using Stila eyeliner for years until this L'oreal eyeliner arrived. Its even better than Stila ( sorry Stila) . Very easy to aplly and remove and it lasts all day without looking like a panda. I can do thick and thin lines without a problem. I cant wait to put it on everyday. Definable recommended.
Most Helpful Critical Review Applies easily, but smudge worse than gel.
This liner applies really well and the fine tip allows you to get all the way into the inner corner and around the tear duct. The problem is this stuff smudges horrifically. I wear a flicked liner every day using either gel or liquid, and this liquid liner smudges worse than unset gel liner. It's unreal. The first day wore this liner I looked in the mirror around lunch time to find black marks smudged all around and below my eyes - I don't even know how that happened since the liner was flicked on the lids and I don't rub my eyes. In sum, great applicator, but horrible product.
Reviewed by 127 customers I HATE IT
Mo from California
I hate it so much. Save your money this is so ba
JA from Idaho
horrible eyeliner. An okay tip and good color but if you touch it at all it smudges. Any water touches it and its running.I wouldn't be able to wear this all day without it getting messed up
Yesss from San Antonio
This is my go to eyeliner. I love the way the pencil is made it helps a lot when doing my wing. The only complaints I have are that it's not dark enough and gets smudgy over the course of the day. Other than that I love it.
Problem with the tip
Kyrie from Montreal, CA
The first time I used it, it was amazing. Then the tip is always dry and I'm either too bad with makeup or I don't know how to get the product in the tip. I bought a second one, in case the first one could have had an issue, but same problem. It would be my favorite if it wasn't of that.
I'm a chronic cry-baby and my wings stay flawlessly put
Jenny from Miami, FL
every other product on my face can get messed up after one of my many cry seshes but this eyeliner does not budge!! 11/10
Best Felt Tip Liner on the Market
Sweet P from Los Angeles, CA
Ok so I've tried HUNDREDS of liners in gels, pencils, liquids, creams and markers. I used to only like the liquid liner then moved to the gels and then tried THIS. Yes! This liner is everything! I do my liner in like 3 quick swipes and it comes out perfect and clean. I also love this because it can do the inner corner lines so precise. This is no joke an amazing holy grail liner. My ONLY complaint is that after years of buying this product I've had several issues with top of the pen coming off when I pull it open. It's an easy fix but annoying sometimes because I get liner on my hands and fingers.
I love this Eyeliner!
Nana J from Tennessee
I have tried many eyeliners in my 59 years and this is the best. Beats out higher priced eyeliners.
Worst liquid liner
KAT from Maryland
UGH this liner tested my patience. After the first use, I thought it was pretty good and applied easily, but that was the only time. After a few (and I literally mean like 3 or 4) more uses it dried up to the point nothing was coming out unless I was aggressively pressing down on the tip... which at that point I had liner everywhere. I really tried to make it work, but in the end I had to part with it. I always store my liners with the point down to keep the tip saturated, but it didn't matter for this liner. Super disappointing. :/
best liquid liner i've used
nat from new york
I've had this eyeliner for awhile, & just recently realized it is my holy grail. i bought the double eyeliner from tarte & been using it for a couple of days but i just love this l'oréal one so much better. not only is it cheaper but making the point of the wing with it is so much easier and i will literally swear by it.
Jayka from FL
I bought this because I ran out of my Mac (marker) eyeliner, which is amazing. The point is pointy, firm and the eyeliner was easy to apply. This L'Oréal brand is of course cheaper but I thought maybe this would be a good buy since L'Oréal is a good drug store brand and I love their foundation. Nope! This eye liner frustrates me every morning. The point after one use gets weak, the color doesn't come out even. I have to go over three times for the color to apply. The point is horrible for wings. I'm not satisfied with this at all. I don't recommend this.
Dries out within days!!!
Keira from NJ
It's basically useless after 3 days
Meet my new partner in crime
TamiG from Florida
Glides on stays on. Makes the sharpest wing, careful it will cut you. ☺️. Definitely in my makeup kit at all times!
Love the result
Irene from PA
Love the way it glides on with no tugging and love the super pigment and matte finish
A.l. from Battle Creek Michigan
Great price won't break the bank. Goes on smooth. Last all day.
Very Good but Needs to be Replaced Quickly
Keira from NJ
It is a very good product and I would recommend it, but it runs out of formula quickly
Miss BeautyDoll from Los Angeles, CA
I love using pen eyeliners & from the ones I've tested this has been my go to. Glides on smoothly and it's perfectly pigmented. The only downside about this drugstore liner is you can't always find it.
Particular from Winterville
I love this eyeliner!! It goes on smooth and DOES NOT smudge or smear in the crease
I'm not gon lie
abby from breathitt county schools, ky
I apply it to my eyelid close
Liner for life
Meg from Bentonville
10/10 liner I used it for the first time 2 or 3 years ago and have had no interest in switching, even after trying other felt tips (Ipsy sends me them!) I love this one the most and have had no luck finding one that compares
Vere Stiff tip
Eve from New Jersey
I am just going to go straight to the point. This eyeliner has a very stiff tip like a sharp pencil. It was very hard to draw a line with it, I literally tried it the first time and couldn't even finish I had to reach for my other liquid eyeliner. The color wasn't coming out solid either, it almost felt like it was half dried out. Needless to say I never used it again. It went to the trash.
Rare when I buy it again!
VickiV from Atlanta, GA
I rarely buy the same product again but this is one of them. I have neuropathy in my hands which makes it hard to hold items sometimes. This is why I love the flat surfaces of this eyeliner. I really get a better grip when applying which is everything wether trying to achieve a cat eye. The tapered applicator makes it easy to either do a fine point or thicker line. Now this product will smudge so that's why you need an eye primer. Once over UD eye potion primer I'm good all day. This has really become my favorite eye liner. I've just purchased my third one! That says a lot from someone with a mountain of makeup of one time buys.
MommaT from Hartland, MI
Smudge and runs and difficult to remove
Jessie from New jersey
It runs easily and it's very difficult to remove
Mandy from Lincoln, NE
Dried out before I could even finish the wing on one eye. Ended up returning it.
Easy application but easy to smudge
Carol from State College, PA
I bought this product to replace what I normally use which is Tarte lights camera action eyeliner. It has since been discontinued and I had been looking for a cheaper replacement. I was very excited to first use it, as the applicator feels nice in your hand and I was easily able to create the same look as I did with my previous eyeliner. I was extremely bummed to find that it smudges very easily, which my previous one did not. If that is your look, go for it! I would not recommend because of this and am still on the search for a cheaper replacement!