Product Reviews Rated 3.98 out of 5 stars
572 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Product was good - color not I purchased rose gold. The color is pretty but way too light for my pale skin. This would look better on someone with a deeper complexion where there is more constraint. I had no issues with application and my cat eyes lasted all day. Bummed the color is too pale but I overall think it's a good product and i might exchange for the black. I don't mind the felt tip applicator and found my control to be good.
Most Helpful Critical Review NOT IMPRESSED I bought this literally two weeks ago and it completely dried out. I wiped the applicator trying to clear the dried clumps and it's just clear plastic. From the moment I purchased, the formula was thick and sticky and very hard to get a clean line with. The applicator came out of the tube bent. I don't know if this is just a bad batch or what. It would go on kind of patchy, dry very awkwardly and flake really badly. I didn't like that if I needed to thicken the line it would take what was already there off. I absolutely love most L'Oreal eyeliners and mascaras, but this product completely missed the mark. The number on the bottom of the tube says R700
Reviewed by 572 customers loved the color. not a fan of everything else 2
Rachel from North Carolina
Let me start with the good: I was never able to wear black eyeliner (it always looked too harsh on me). But this color was actually flattering! It has a "wet" look to it, but it actually looked nice. And I love the flexible felt tip!!! felt tip pens are goof-proof in my opinion. so that's pretty much all that was good about this eyeliner....the color and the applicator.
Now the bad: I had to apply 2-3 layers to get a rich color( it reminded me of water colors and I had to layer it). It dries quickly, but as i layered the eyeliner, it started to flake and peel off. It took some work to finally get a smooth, rich line on my eyes. About 2 hours after wearing it and having the perfect line and perfect color...it started to flake and peel off my eyes. I was disappointed because I really wanted to love this eyeliner! Removing this eyeliner was a nightmare for me. I use the clinique "take the day off" and I have NEVER had a problem removing even waterproof makeup. But I had to rub repeatedly to get this stuff off...and all it did was throw flakes all over my face and smudged HORRIBLY. it never really came off until I used my face scrub. i wanted to love this eyeliner, but it was not a good product for me.
Such a awesome change 5
janna from pleasanton
Such a fun brightening change for my fair complexion from my normal brown. Also gave some to my granddaughter and she loves it as well. Pink color is not too dramatic, just right don't change.
Disappointed:( 1
Jules from California
Applied it to one eyelid and that was all that it lasted. Immediately got dry and crumbly- I love the mascara from this collection but the eyeliner didn't perform unfortunately.
All the best L'Oreal items always get discontinued 4
Jill from New York
This product corrects my black liquid eyeliner cat eye, which I rarely get to even on the first try, while adding that inner corner pop of shine. It catches the light in every room, making you look like a luminous angelic being. There is no other product on the market like it. I use to use a black vinyl look liquid eyeliner and it was also similar in its ability to catch the light. I love how quick and convenient to apply if you have only a few minutes to get ready in the morning. I wish L'Oreal would stop discontinuing their best products. Rose gold liquid eyeliner & True Match Foundation Compact are work and school make up essentials. With these two products you could have a full beat in minutes if you're in a rush
Gross, dry and crumbly 1
A from Vermont
The first one I got was dry, so Ulta replaces it, but the second one is so crumbly and messy as soon as it dries! The worst yuck
Amazing eyeliner! 5
Kmoliva97 from Houston, TX
I've tried different eyeliners before and they usually dry out and the felt tip no longer absorbs the product, but this eyeliner does the opposite. This eyeliners tip is amazing, I love how easy it glides over the eye and it is very pigmented. Dries very fast in the eye and there is no smudging after a couple minutes or hours of wear. I constantly rub my eyes and this eyeliner stays put!
Ok 5
None from Land o lakes, Florida
None
A crumbling mess 1
N.J. Smith from Ogden, UT
This is a terrible product. When it drys it automatically crumbles and it's a mess. Save your money. Buy something better.
Cute alternative to black eyeliner- adds a subtle highlight 5
Jess from San Diego, CA
I don't know why this product gets such bad reviews. It works very well for me. I use it over black eyeliner or alone for a subtle highlight over my eye.
Worst ever! 1
Loz from Virginia beach
This eyeliner didn't show up on me AT ALL. I even tried to use it as an eyeshadow vase, but it was too dry for that, I don't know
That there was ever any product in it
Dry 1
Rachel from USA
The pink color is fine but the black was dried out as soon as I opened it. I couldn't make a solid line because it skipped and dried out even after dipping and shaking it many times. Bought for a vacation and glad I tried it out before as I'll be returning it.
Save your money 1
Daisy 🐒 from San Marcos
The very first time I used it it was good, color was good and stayed on all night. But the times after that there's a no more color and instead left little flakes of glitter but it's supposed to be rose gold? Bottom line, not good. Save your coin for liquid eyeshadows and use them as liners.
I would definitely will keep using it 5
N/a from Pasadena Texas
I love it
Big waste. 1
Ohyahthatsme from undisclosed
I was excited to try this product. The applicator seemed nice, not to ruff and flexible. The draw backs to the applicator, it seems to be a flocked piece of silacon. I have had this product and have been using it for 3months on and off. Today when I had to dip in for the 5th time just for one eye, I was mad. I opened the package I g to see what was up. First I found out that there was a lot of product useable, that would not attach itsself to the applicator. Biggest waste of product and my time.
Never again! 1
Flossy Dime from USA
I used this one time! One time and that was it and the pigment honestly wasn't all that. But after using it one time, I go to give it another try about a month later and the container is empty! It was either empty or the liner had dried up. Either way, I only got one use out of it.
i would give 0 if i could 1
karl from Phoenix AZ
horrible hate it might as well throw away you're money.
3 stars 3
megs from Illinois
I always shake this before I use it. the liner doesn't show up much on my without an eyeshadow. the color is beautiful, I just wish that the spongey brush didn't dry out so quickly. I have to dip the brush like 3 times if I want to use it for the whole line. I now usually use this for an accent over a black liner and it looks great. all in all I'm glad I bought it
Very dry did not do the job well 1
Lisaisa from Santa rosa
Got this for a cheer competition for my child it was brand new and dry did not go on over the glitter eyes and hardley on my hand. Returned it and got my money back.
Would not buy again 3
Ms. Rae from Carmel, ny
Disappointed with this product .. not worth the money .
wish it was waterproof, but it's not and it is flaky 2
Dm from Houston, Tx
I bought this in black and thought I should try out another product from the lash paradise line since I liked the waterproof lash paradise mascara. The tip isn't fine and it was bendable. It was tough doing my cat eye since the tip wasn't pointy. although it was bendy, I laid the tip flat so I can line my lashes. I tried it out on my arm and it dries pretty quick. It doesn't smudge when it is dry. But don't wear it if you plan to be sweaty or if it is raining. The liner will flake off and smudge. It runs off pretty easily with out makeup remover when it is wet.
This is so easy for me to use 5
Sarah from Houston, TX
I love this eyeliner. I'm surprised it doesn't have better reviews. I've never really been a fan of liquid eyeliner, and I cannot STAND when it's thick. But I tried this one and I love it. If you just want a black LINE on your lash line to accentuate your lashes, this is a great option. If you want to look like a drag queen by day or a "cat", maybe try something else. This isn't drag queen/cat makeup for those ridiculous "winged" looks. I I really can't wait for this stupid "wing" moment passes.
If you want to look like a normal person with eyeliner that doesn't scare people when they see you, try this.
Not what I expected 2
Naay from LI, NY
I am an avid Loreal shopper but this was not what I expected. The item was dry and flaky, I will not purchase again.
I hate this eyeliner 3
scillalopez from rosamond ca
worst eyeliner ever made! I was excited to try it but the applicator killed it for me so quickly! I will not buy it again... beyond disappointed
crumbles 2
smm from ramsey, nj
I bought this product because I love the L' Oreal Carbon Black Intense Linear and have not been able to find it. This product had a fine tip but it would result in a dry crusty look towards the end. It would crumble off and just look very crusty.
NOT IMPRESSED 1
Beanerschnitzel from Houston, TX
I bought this literally two weeks ago and it completely dried out. I wiped the applicator trying to clear the dried clumps and it's just clear plastic. From the moment I purchased, the formula was thick and sticky and very hard to get a clean line with. The applicator came out of the tube bent. I don't know if this is just a bad batch or what. It would go on kind of patchy, dry very awkwardly and flake really badly. I didn't like that if I needed to thicken the line it would take what was already there off. I absolutely love most L'Oreal eyeliners and mascaras, but this product completely missed the mark. The number on the bottom of the tube says R700
