Product Reviews Rated 3.9 out of 5 stars
1130 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing length! I have tried expensive lengthening mascaras and this is the best for my lashes. I am a redhead so my lashes are invisible. This solves the issue and my lashes are amazingly long. I just wish the tube lasted longer.
Most Helpful Critical Review You get what you pay for. I bought this mascara because I had a lot of friends and family members that recommended it. I have to say that I would not recommend this product.[...] I was in need of a new mascara but I didn't want to spend a lot of money and also the mascara I used before was out of stock. I would say you get what you pay for. For a cheap price it works pretty well. After a few hours it starts to flake so I need to always check and make sure it isn't all over my face. Also the brush is horrible, in my opinion. It doesn't add volume or lenght. It clumps my lashes and I need to use my old mascara wand to unclump them and add volume and lenght. If you're looking for a cheap mascara to wear for a little bit that doesn't show that much then I recommend it, but if you want to add lenght and volume to your lashes I would go with another mascara.
Reviewed by 1130 customers almost perfect 4
haley from omaha,Ne
i got this mascara because it was recommended to me. it's wayyy better than i expected. i have hooded small eyes and i love the way it makes my eyes and eyelashes look. it can be a tad bit clunky but u just have to brush through it and brush through your eyelashes before
I would recommend for price 4
JoJo from Michigan
I read decent reviews and typically don't buy maybelline mascaras have never really liked them. I decided to try this one and surprised I do like my lashes using this. Do I think it's the best ever no but for the price it does do what they say. The big negative is the cheapest wand I've ever had in any mascara, and since the wand is a big part of the lengthening due to the shape, they should invest a bit of money and make it better. I am however ordering it again.
soooo cute 5
liz from ca
i have long lashes alone but this is honestly my favorite brand of mascara. it makes my eyes look even more full and i've been told so many times that it looks like i'm wearing falsies and i tell them about this mascara and they never believe me. x
So pretty! 5
Lindsay M. from Fallston, MD
I bought this a couple months ago, tried it, and wasn't a fan. I tried it again this morning, and was pleasantly surprised! I have longer, fuller lashes, with no clumping. I will be using this as an everyday mascara, because while it does all that, it's not so dramatic that it looks overdone. I love it!
YESS LOVE IT 5
gig from fk
i love this mascara, would buy it again.
holy grail 5
jossy from riverside
i love it i have really long lashes and this mascara wand curls them and coats them perdectly , ive tried several brands but i always keep coming back to this one i love it
No Volume 2
asm1 from NJ
I have pretty long eye lashes, typically could use any type of mascara and it will look decent. This just doesn't do it. idk if I got a bad batch or what, but this barely adds anything to my lashes.
Length, length, length! 5
Joejoe from NJ, USA
This is a great mascara for those who want as near to doll eyes without actual falsies! The mascara has a wet formula that builds nicely, and does a decent job at separating lashes as well. Clumps are minimal, but still present. Smudges and fallout were minimal as well. The formula works best with curled lashes, otherwise it may weigh them down. However, if you want length and/or to avoid smears on your glasses, I'd recommend a lash curler anyway! Overall, I really like this mascara and would definitely recommend it for someone looking for drama.
Pros:
- Lengthening
- Wet formula, buildable
- Nice separation
- Dramatic
Cons:
- Some smudges
- Some clumps
- Lashes need to be curled/a but heavy
Don't waste your money 1
autumn from St. Louis
Don't get me wrong, I do like other Maybelline mascaras but not this one. The wand is so flimsy I feel like it's gonna break everytime I use it. It makes my eyelashes clump together so badly It's impossible to separate. So much product gets on the wand I have to scrape a lot for it to be useable. I really give products a chance before I leave a negative review and this mascara is just awful I wish I could get my money back
BEST!!! 5
Amy from New Jersey
All time favorite, never disappoints and perfect for volume and separation!
Inexpensive, no flaking 5
RN from Anderson, SC
Great inexpensive mascara that doesn't flake, smudge. Also makes lashes appear longer and fuller. Great purchase!
Don't waste your money 1
Cheaperbythedozen from WI
It not do what it says.
I've been using this mascara a while now I love it! 5
Faby from Pasadena
Helps my eyelashes add volume!!! Love it!
Really works!! 5
Lusyd from Massachusetts
Two strokes of the mascara and I looked like I had false lashes on.
Game Changer 5
Shoegal from Las Vegas
I really can't figure out the negative reviews! I always buy high end mascara, until now! This mascara is now my holy grail. I can't see spending twice the price or more for high end mascara any more.
Now I know why they call it Falsies 1
Cdubbya from Olathe
I decided to try this. When I first started putting it on, I was loving it. Gave me lots of length immediately. I was impressed. On my way to work I looked in my mirror, it was all over under my eyes. When I got to work I cleaned all under my eyes the best I could. I also noticed the length it instantly gave me ,collapsed. I don't what happened, but I was upset I was stuck with this all day. Trying to clean it off was the HARDEST. I tried everything. Even my most expensive eye make up remover wasn't working. It took almost two days before it completely came off. I lost a few lashes for sure. If I wore this every day, I wouldn't have any lashes left. I would need FALSIES.
My view has changed on this. 3
Brooke from Undisclosed
I started using this mascara when I had short barely noticeable lashes. Now that my lashes are fuller and longer, I don't like it near as well. When I first tried this I was amazed at how noticeable my barely there lashes became. Now I have beautiful lashes that I am very proud of. I love the formula of this mascara, it's a wetter formula which I prefer. But the brush is my biggest issue. When my lashes were short it curled them and thickened. With longer thicker lashes, it does a decent job but I wouldn't say it's a game changer. I don't want to say I hate it because I don't but if I had to choose between this and another maybelline mascara, I would not choose this one. They made a falsies mascara with an hourglass shape and I like that one much better.
flimsy and doesnt separate 3
JJ from WA
Worst mascara ever super flimsy wand have no control whatsoever the waterproof is worst
AMAZING! I love it!!! 5
Fashion in Ashland from Ashland, OR
Doesn't clump. Thick lashes.
Really good! 4
Anastasia from Tempe AZ
I have a very love hate relationship with this mascara. It is a very sticky and nearly glue like consistency but does not clump lashes and definitely doesn't flake off! I really love the lift and volume my lashes have when I use it, the only down side is it is VERY difficult to take off. It usually takes me 10 min to try to get it off my eyelashes because it is so sticky. But I put up with it because of how nice the quality is. Maybe better than some of the high end mascaras I've tried.
holy grail 5
nicole from indiana
i've been using this mascara for over 6 years now. i've strayed away at times to try others but i always come back to this. i've tried other mascaras from cruelty free brands but nothing holds a candle to this! maybelline, please follow in cover girls foot steps and go cruelty free! i would love to purchase this without feeling guilty. but anyways, my lashes look incredibly intense, long, dark, and thick with this mascara. if you apply too many coats it can get clumpy if you go overboard and apply too much. it usually stays on well throughout the day and i have oily skin. rarely transfer unless i'm sweating buckets, but i don't find it flakes off until it's at the end of its shelf life. when it starts doing that i know it's starting to dry out and it's coming to the end of its life and i need to replace it, which is about every 3 months. that's the recommended time to toss a mascara anyways. i love this! for under $10 you can't beat it.
Love love love 5
Bekah from WV
Been using the same mascara for 5 years
Not as good throughout the day 2
Victoria from Philadelphia, PA
This mascara clumps my eyelashes together and makes them hard to separate. Also, throughout the day, the mascara falls off my eyes and makes the skin under my eyes turn black.
Only one I use 5
Mk from Wooster, Ohio
This is the one and only mascara that I use and probably will ever use. It stays on me perfectly and does not flake or smudge. I have had the same one for about a year now and it has not dried out and still puts on great. LOVE, LOVE, LOVE!!!!!!!!!!!
PSA: You NEED this mascara in your life 5
Allison from Columbus, Ohio
I have searched high and low for a product that would last through my long days, sweat, blood, tears and all. I have tested so many products ranging from $50-$5 and let me tell you this WORKS. Don't spend the extra money vying for the perfect product. Stop here, this is it. Don't walk, run.
