Product Reviews Rated 4.14 out of 5 stars
957 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Bang for your buck If you want volume and length, pick this one. Funny story, I was standing in line at the movies and this woman's eyelashes were the bomb, so I ~had to compliment + this is what she said she was wearing!! Thanks for the recommendation girl! I have never used such a quality drugstore mascara in my life!(yes, I've tried great lash, and lash paradise). For any~ mascara I've tried, the first time of use is always weird so I fixed that by pumping the applicator in and out for a few seconds just to let a little air into the formula. I like the way this product gets better with time. Application tips: curl your eyelashes first, and when applying, wiggle your applicator gently in between your lashes because you need to get each and every one! Clean up any excess with a damp Q tip!
Most Helpful Critical Review What a mess! I received this mascara from a relative brand new in the package and was excited to try it out for the first time. I applied it like any other mascara before going to work. I did love how it applied and looked, but that was short lived within the next 15 minutes. I got dressed, ate breakfast and went to check myself out in the mirror before heading out. I looked at my eyes and the mascara had fallen onto my cheeks and smudged in the outer corners of my eyes. I was not happy once that occurred, but I still was looking forward to how it would last throughout the day. Well through the day I was experiencing more flaking under my eyes and had to remove it with tissue. It's annoying when you have to continuously check your face for mascara fall out. I still was hoping to see how well it would look when I got home from a long day. It looked pretty good when I did check my face. So I decided to wash my face from all my makeup from the day. I washed my face but my eyes started to become irritated. I looked into the mirror and noticed countless specks of mascara had fallen into my eyes. I quickly grabbed a few q-tips to remove everything, but it was under my eye lids as well and areas too high to get out. I rubbed my eyes to remove the rest of the mascara derby so the irritation would stop. It took 2 minutes or so for me to carefully remove all possible mascara from both eyes. I truly am very disappointed with this mascara. A mascara shouldn't leave you with the feeling of irritation and constant worry about how it looks throughout the day. However, the deal breaker was when the specks of mascara had fallen into my eyes and began to really irritate them. :( No one should deal with this type of headache over a mascara. It is not worth the process of applying it. Sorry to say, but I will not be recommending this product to anyone.
Reviewed by 957 customers Classic 4
Jen from Michigan
For drug store brand it does an amazing job plumping and Elongating the eye lashes. Will have to use a eyelash brush to break up the clumps. But overall makes your eyelashes look fake
Bretman sent me here! 4
Eleni from Lake Elsinore
When I saw bretman rock do a review on this mascara, I was immediately intrigued! He has reviewed this mascara and it brought great length to his lashes. Personally I have very small eyelashes and this product doubles the size haha. I do not recommend going in the pool or any water with this on as it will smudge and make black streaks on your face.
Great mascara 5
Fancyface from Houston
My stable must have mascara. Increases volume on fine lashes well
Go to everyday 5
jk from Oregon
go to mascara. Brush works well, color is good. Does flake after a few months because it drys out quick
I love this mascara 5
Amandalynn from Missouri
This is my favorite mascara, I would choose this over any one out there! I wipe off excess product on the countainer and apply to my lashes. It works so well! And it's buildable to.
This is my go to ONLY MASCARA 5
mam from Webster, TX
I love this mascara!!!!! It is reasonably priced and gives you both volume and length! Try it you will love it.
HOLY GRAIL 5
miss tiktoker from Memphis, TN
THIS MASCARA IS MY HOLY GRAIL!!! I have trieddd sooo many mascaras and a few weeks ago I came across this at target. I picked it up, and man am I so glad I did. It lengthens, darkens, and curls my eyelashes perfectly. And unlike other mascaras it comes off easily without pulling out ur lashes. LOVE AND TOTALLY RECOMMEND
Its ok 4
Ang from Indiana
I think it's nice but it doesnt stay up for long but the product does stay on all day
Buy if you want to look like a panda 1
Office panda from Pittsburgh PA
I applied before work in the morning and it seemed promising. Went on well and looked great! But when I went to the restroom mid-day, it had run so badly, I had huge dark rings under my eyes. So embarrassing bc I'm not sure how long I had been walking around like that. I came home and threw it right in the trash. Never again.
One of my favorite mascaras! 5
Audrey G from Boston, MA
One of my favorite mascaras that I've ever tried! The best thing about it is that it's impossible to clump your lashes together. You can put 10 coats of this stuff on and there's no clumping and no spider lashes. If you want the false lash effect or crazy volume, you might not like this mascara, but if you prefer the more everyday look, you'll love it. I definitely recommend curling your lashes first for the best results and to really get defined and pretty lashes.
Doesn't clump 3
Cc from USA
This mascara is okay. I wish it added a bit more volume and was more dramatic. It's great for people who like a more natural look because it's lightweight and not too dramatic.
Good 4
Carrie from Florida
Goes on well, builds up nicely and doesn't clump. doesn't run if you cry, unless it's a lot of crying . Washes off easily.
My go to 5
AL from IL
I've tried most of Maybelline's mascara and other drugstore brands and ALWAYS come back to this one. It's been my go-to for years and the brush size is perfect for a natural, full look. Other Maybelline formulas tend to cause more of my lashes to fall out than normal for whatever reason but have never experienced that issue with this one.
Absolute Fav of all time! 5
Nina from Visalia, Ca
I seem to find myself always coming back to this one. It's buildable the consistency is more on the watery side so it won't clump lashes together. Def gives length and defines.
Best Mascara! 5
KC from Naples, FL
Does not clump, inexpensive, really plumps up the eyelashes.
Formula change??? 2
Kelsea from Cincinnati Ohio
I have been using this mascara for yearsssss like probably 8-10 years now. It has always been my favorite go to even when I tried other high end brands and even other low ends brands. This past month when I bought a new one I had noticed after a week of using it, it seemed like it either went old fast or there was hardly any product left. I usually have this mascara for a month before I buy a new one. This is the second one I have purchased that has acted this way. I don't know if they changed the formulation or what but unfortunately I think I won't buy this again... it's an end of an era. Time to move on and try something new.
Flaky 1
CF from Apple Valley CA
I have the Glam Black not waterproof version. It flakes immediately. It stays soft enough to use a lash comb which is what I want in a mascara but it's so flaky I will go back to the regular pink & green tube which I love.
Just OK 3
Bec from MN
I picked this up hoping to get good volume and easy application. The wand is a little big for my taste but definitely manageable. It lasts on my lashes and gives adequate volume and darkness with a couple of coats. However, I can't get over the smell. It's not a bad scent per se, but it is heavily fragranced. It irritates me in a matter of minutes! I wish they would reduce the fragrance.
Still my favorite after 10+ years 5
Christy from Simi Valley
I've been using this mascara for over 10 years, and I love it. This last year I decided to try a few prestige brand mascaras. Nope, this is still my fav. It's not clumpy and really accentuates my lashes.
My favorite go to mascara 5
Artdiva89 from Boise, ID
This is my favorite go to mascara and it's reasonably priced! It's very easy to apply.
V disappointed 2
Natalie from Los Angeles
I've heard friends rave abt this mascara. It was just over hyped. First few wears were good. As time passed, it began to apply unevenly, it would flake through out the day, it would clump.
Mascara 4
DebbieBG from Hoover
As directed...
I'm sold 5
SmilinJenE from Chandler, AZ
I've been spending $85/year on mascara that I thought was my favorite. pft. silly me! got this as a sample and I'm glad I tried it instead of giving it away. now I'll spend $30 or less with coupons and sales and can now use my mascara budget on something more fun!
Best mascara !!! 5
Bre from Orange, CA
I use this mascara on a daily basis and it is just the absolute best. No clumps, the actual mascara consistency is smooth and feels good on my lashes, and it comes off with a makeup remover very easily and doesn't leave residue. BEST mascara!
Didn't work for me 1
Chelsy from Ohio
Didn't really give much volume. Wouldn't re buy
