Rated 3.77 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Ah-MAZING!! 😍
This mascara is truly amazing!! My lashes never looked soooo good!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Terrible application
With the hype of this mascara, I expected it to be a good one simply because Maybelline mascaras are usually good with the ones I've tried. However, this mascara doesn't seem to have good pay off on hold, length, or volume. It keeps my lashes pretty flat and the texture of it seems sticky for some reason. The wand doesn't help to disburse the product to coat your lashes. It either comes off clumpy and way too much to which your lashes stick together and become thick. Second coats aren't preferred either because it becomes a thick mess. Really disappointed in this and will be returning both I purchased.
Reviewed by 97 customers Yes I would buy this again
Ang from Chicago, IL
I use this all the time. I love it made my lashes look long and curled up
My go to
Rita from Nevada
This is a great mascara. Gives great volume and extending effect to your lashes. Easy to remove.
TRACI from MIDLAND MI
SMUDGED EASILY AND NEVER FEELS LIKE IT IS COMPLETELY DRY
Lilly from Racine
It is very waterproof and lasted through a very hot shower
Lilly from Racine
I've rebought this product multiple times and it's amazing
Would not buy again
Stephanie10172 from Miami, Fl
Haven't tested the waterproof. Prefer Maybelline Falsies better which gives you length and volume and it is buildable.
Wish I could give it 4 1/2 stars
Yellie from Brooksville, fl
Love how it goes on and builds volume and length with each layer. Doesn't clump and keeps eyelashes separated. It is VERY WATERPROOF!!!! Through swimming, crying everything. But my ONLY dislike is it EXTREMELY difficult to get off. I've tried Norwex makeup towel remover, waterproof eye makeup remover that has gotten all other off and coconut oil. The last two did something but still had quite a bit left over and rough on my lashes. I will try using a primer or non waterproof mascara under it and see if that helps. Because I love everything else about this mascara. And the price is awesome. I was using It Superhero and hated all others but this is a smidget less good but good enough for my picky taste with 1/3 the price.
Good volume..was looking for more length added possibly?
Annie from Hopkins, MN
Apply 1x a day to add volume..not extremely dramatic
I'll Never Purchase a Different Mascara
Laura from Tampa, FL
I've tried literally dozens of other mascaras and nothing ever works for me like this one does. All other mascaras flake off, clump, or make me look like a raccoon after a few hours of wear. This gives me length, volume, and it STAYS ON!!! ALL DAY!!! I cannot stress this enough. I wore this to a funeral and cried for two hours but this did not budge!! Comes off super easy with a cleansing oil too, which I love! This is the best mascara I've ever tried and such a bargain!
I will not buy this product again.
B from Salem OH
I do not like that it doesn't add any kind of length to my eye lashes and I felt like I had to use a second mascara to even tell a difference.
Best mascara out there, even better than high end
sarahmastergardener from California
I keep coming back to this mascara. I have compared it with Diorshow, Lancôme Monsior Big, Wander Beauty and many other award winning mascaras. This is the only one that lifts, curls, and lasts all day and looks amazing. Maybelline consistently has the best mascaras in my opinion.
baller21 from Pittsburgh
This is the best mascara EVER! It makes my lashes plump and dark, and the shape of the bristles prevents clumping.
Best Mascara I've Used
Asia P from St. Louis, MO
I'm never picky about my mascaras because I always get the same results, but this one is the best I have used for some reason. My lashes are not clumped together, and they look nice and defined and longer, same with my bottom lashes.
Kelly K from New Jersey
Very waterproof formula. Still makes lashes big and volume , but I wish the length was better. Repurchased a few times so it's worth it
Absolutely will buy again
Kris from Moreno valley, California
I really love this mascara!
Doesn't clump, voluminous affect
Jennifer J from Home
Does what it claims, awesome product .
LOVE THIS PRODUCT!!!
Lily from New York
ok so i LOVE THIS product. i recommend holding a finger under eye and blinking to wipe off any extra IMMEDIATELY after applying, just so you can have more separated lashes (but i do that with all mascaras)
Volum Express Mascara
Sammydany from Fontana Ca
I do not recommend this product
Els from Oakdale
The formula is completely different then the regular big shot that isn't waterproof. You'll want this mascara for very natural lashes that WILL NOT come off. Even after I shower with face wash my eyelashes still look the same as they did when I put them on. If you have watery eyes this could be something you'd want
Dupe for Lash Paradise & Better Than Sex
MiMi from New York, NY
This is a great mascara! Definitely a dupe for Lash Paradise & Better Than Sex mascaras just a cheaper price! Totally would recommend this mascara!
I love it!
Review.ista from United States
I had someone ask me if my eyelashes were fake because they looked so long and full! It's my go to daily mascara. 10/10 would recommend!
Mimi from Waldorf, Md
It's probably the worst mascara I've used. I don't know if they changed the formula but when I had received it as a complimentary item from a company when it first came out it was amazing. Now that I decided to buy it again it was the worst thing ever! It wouldn't come off with anything, soap & water, makeup wipes, makeup remover, etc. it was the worst thing ever. I do not recommend purchasing this mascara.
Mal from Florida
I love this i've bought it multiple times and i wear it not having to worry about checking up to see if it still looks good
We buy this one in multiples
Jbsjess from Kingsport TN
I buy this one for my daughter constantly. She loves this one and Too Faced's Better Than Sex. You can't beat this one for the price.
really good for stick straight lashes
olivia from ohio
i had been reading so many reviews trying to find a curling mascara to keep my long straight lashes curled, while adding volume. it took me awhile to figure out that waterproof mascara helps lashes keep their curl. i needed a new mascara for my first day of school, so i ran to kroger and grabbed a waterproof mascara mindlessly, which happened to be this one. i love it! it gives my lashes so much volume. and it gives them so much length that they hit my brow bone when i look up. incredible! and after trying dozens of mascaras advertised to hold a curl, this happened to be the one! after 8 hours they still held a perfect curl. the reason for 4 stars is cause i just have a tough time getting it out of my lashes, regardless of the type of remover i use.