Rated 4.08 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing colours!
Purchased 6 colors 3 weeks ago. I was so excited to try some new colored eyeliner but was sorely disappointed. Before application, I noticed that the colors on the actual bottle don't match the box at all, so that there me off. When I applied it, it went on nicely but I had to go over it a couple more times since the pink, yellow, and lilac ones were almost transparent. The other colors were nice to put on. The one thing I hated was when it dries. First off, it doesn't dry as the same colour it totally looks different. Second, the texture was horrible, it dries like paint, chips like paint, and looked like paint (look at swatches pic w/o flash to see the paint like texture). Lastly, the brush is too thick in my opinion, it made it hard to do details on my liner.
Now, I'm not a professional mua, so take my review with a grain of salt.
Most Helpful Critical Review dry and flaky
I bought this eyeliner in the color 'vivid fire' a couples of weeks ago and when I used it today (for the first time) it immediately felt dry and by the time i had applied mascara and falsies it had flaked like paint. :(
Reviewed by 1091 customers Don't buy the green it smells :(
Jazzy from California
Very sad I should have checked reviews better but I bought the green because I thought it would look cool. It smells like chemical garbage. I can't describe it any other way it was really bad. I hear the other colors are great just avoid the green !
Bunny from USA
I was excited about this line the second it was announced. I currently have all the colors in this line save for halo, delight, and escapism. Every other color I own and they look so awesome! they are hyper pigmented so it goes on easy and its thick enough that one swipe is all it takes really. I love nyx but this is probably my new favorite make up set. I may never wear black eyeliner again! also worth adding that I put the eyeliner on today and was caught in an actual rainstorm a few hours ago, and it's still on. (even without a setting spray! but I would still recommend a setting spray!) :) ♡♡♡
Mar from New York
I bought 4,Blue,Green,Pink and light purple the pigment is nice but the green one smells so bad when u had it on my eye i was still able to smell it but the other ones weren't like that.I can't use it,it's horrible
Smell is awful for the green
Crystal from Killeen
I looooove all the colors! But the green smells AWFUL. I went to 2 different Ulta stores, purchased and opened all the ones they had and even had the employees smell how awful it is. Other than the smell these are amazing!
maya from ma
amazing quality for the price and very pigmented
Liz from CA
Love the vibrant color
my favorite eyeliner of all time
E from Atl, GA
Beautiful! I hope Nyx never discontinues this eyeliner like my old flame the teal felt tip.
Beautiful color but sadly I had an allergic reaction to it.
Sirius Borealis from Dallas Tx
I love this product because the color consistency is amazing and I don't have to use a lot to do both eyes.
Sadly I had an allergic reaction and I don't know if it was the pigment or the formula. My eyes got puffy and super red, they were that way for 3 days.
Good for me
jj from nc
Used this and other colors a few times on my upper lid. Never had any cracking. It was nice and smooth and lasted all day for me.
gabe from san diego
this eyeliner is pretty at first and really easy to apply. however after it dries it becomes super crusty and flaky and dry like the desert. I would not recommend.
Can't buy enough
Kate from Philadelphia, PA
I LOVE the vivid brights and tbh any NYX liners. Besides the fact that SOME shades cracks, overall they're amazing for detailed or simple eye looks. I just recently blended out the neon green on the inner corner and you would've thought it was a shadow!!
Carmella from Los Angeles
I wanted to buy color liner to do more color looks, let me tell you this!!!
They stink soooooo BADLY! Do NOT buy the green liner, it smelled old. They cracked a lot! I'm for sure returning them!
Kay from Fresno, CA
Very pretty colors, but they crack on the lids once dried. If you try to keep going over it to fix the cracks, it just looks worse. The colors are pigmented tho
5 stars for the color selection, but...
Alex from USA
...2 to 3 stars for the formula. It's really dry and cracks and fades easily. Wish there was a higher quality formula in these colors. Also, the pink dries down darker than it actually is, but the lavender and the blue stay the same.
Love it and hate it
Quesito from Al
I have a love/ hate relationship with this product. I love the color and how easy it is to apply. What I hate about this product it that I tried to layer up to make it more vivid but it just started to crack.
So far so good
Drea from Md
Looks real pretty in the summer makes your eyes pop with color. The formula is fine and for the price why not. I got the blue one.
More cracks than a sidewalk!!!!!
Aydrienne from Kentucky
The pigment is nice but it cracks sooooooo badly. I returned both shades I purchased with a QUICKNESS!!!
So easy to use and very pigmented I love them!
Montse from Laredo, Tx.
Favorite eyeliners ever!
Sara from Roswell,Ga
This is a great colorful product. I use this to do my eyeliner and different fun eye looks with more stay and precision!
This is okay
JessTheMess from USA
When taking out the applicator, it will probably splatter on you and everything around you. It removes very easily though. This applied darker than I thought it would. Almost like an off black color. This eyeliner isn't heavily scented. It did apply evenly and smoothly but it did not last. It didn't smear but just kind of faded away within hours. I've dealt with worse eyeliners than this but there are definitely better ones out there.
The color was NOT what was depicted
MarciM from San Antonio, Atx
I ordered the color "Envy", thinking I would receive a vivid emerald green similar to the color of the tube. It wasn't even close. It was a muddy, Olive/avocado green. Not "vivid" at all. It did glide on easily and it did stay put very well.
QweenLT13 from New Mexico
I love the vivid brights collection!! They are beautiful and amazing accent colors !!
a LOT of cracking
Sophi from Wisconsin
I like the color selection and it's cheaper than hydra liners but if cracking is a deal breaker for you these aren't for you.
Katherine from San Antonio
I purchased the yellow, green, and lavender shades. The lavender shade is great however the green and yellow look nothing like what I thought they would. They are a lot darker than the pic and the shade on the box. I was expecting something bright and these are dark and muted. They are opaque but I'm definitely disappointed with the shades.
5 stars for color/ 3 stars for formula=4 stars
k from california
I love the colors and the price is good, 5/5 stars for the shades. If you want to just make a cool look for pictures it's fine, but not for long wear. I have the yellow and the green, the yellow would probably look better on a deep skin tone, I have a light/medium skin tone and I wish it "popped" a bit more. They both flake and even wipe off too easily. Also the applicator is the kind that seems good because it's small/thin, but since it doesn't come to a point it's hard to make a wing or control the shape. I wish it had a better tip, the product can kind of get out of control because it's very wet.