Product Reviews Rated 4.06 out of 5 stars
1145 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing colours! Purchased 6 colors 3 weeks ago. I was so excited to try some new colored eyeliner but was sorely disappointed. Before application, I noticed that the colors on the actual bottle don't match the box at all, so that there me off. When I applied it, it went on nicely but I had to go over it a couple more times since the pink, yellow, and lilac ones were almost transparent. The other colors were nice to put on. The one thing I hated was when it dries. First off, it doesn't dry as the same colour it totally looks different. Second, the texture was horrible, it dries like paint, chips like paint, and looked like paint (look at swatches pic w/o flash to see the paint like texture). Lastly, the brush is too thick in my opinion, it made it hard to do details on my liner.
Now, I'm not a professional mua, so take my review with a grain of salt.
Most Helpful Critical Review dry and flaky I bought this eyeliner in the color 'vivid fire' a couples of weeks ago and when I used it today (for the first time) it immediately felt dry and by the time i had applied mascara and falsies it had flaked like paint. :(
Reviewed by 1145 customers I have been buying this eyeliner for a few years. 5
Trina22 from Chicago, IL
I use this eyeliner after I finishing applying eyeshadow and prior to applying mascara.
Yes i actually purchased a second one 4
Lola from Lake county ca
Love this eyeliner easy to apply and it last the whole day.❤i had to purchase a second one 😁
1 star 3
megs from illinois
some of the colors are milky and don't show up after they dry down. it dries like liquid latex- super tight and uncomfortable on the eyes. they also crack and fall off almost instantly. absolute trash product
Eh 2
Sabrina from NJ
Some of the colors come out nice, but most of them oxidize badly, especially the light green. It becomes a lot darker and looks almost gray. Then when u layer these to get better payoff, the product cracks and flakes off. I would look into other colored eyeliner.
Good! 4
Kilika from Brokaw in SJ, CA
I love this eyeliner! I got 4 different colors. I will say though that the light green one had an odd smell. Also when I put this on my eyes they made them feel a bit dry.
meh 3
kyrie from santa barbara, ca
first colored eyeliner i've ever bought. i read the reviews but still decided to get just for fun. quality isn't great and cracks a bit, but my biggest issue is with the colors themselves. i got vivid delight, which looked kind of like a dusty pink color in the photos. well, it's a deep rust orange and doesn't look ANYTHING like the photos. still pretty, but i wish i knew beforehand. i also got vivid escape which looked like a matcha green color (my favorite) and it's more of a lemongrass color (more yellow). overall i would recommend going in person to see the colors versus buying online
Okay Liner 3
Jess from San Diego
The liner colors are beautiful a bit lighter than what is shown, no biggie. They apply very nicely, but you have to do several coats, the liner cracks so then it looks funky, they also have a nasty smell. I still like to use them but reapplying is annoying.
Is there a trick for it not to crack?
Color = great. Lasting power = trash 3
MT the Kid from Washington, DC
For short term looks, I LOVE the color pay off. No amount of primer or prayer keeps this on my lids longer than 2 hours. It cracks. It flakes. It's gone. I bought this to see if I would like pastels as a liner and for that it serves w purpose. But it has the worst lasting power of any product I've used.
still there 5
lcg925 from Alabama
I bought the blue and the red liner.
the red liner came off a bit easier but its probably because it barely touched my skin. the blue on the other hand...
I wanna start off by saying I put both on my hand after my shower. the blue is still on my hand hardly faded, 24 hours later. I clean houses so my hands are constantly in hot water or messing with chemicals, and it survived all that. A+ in my book for being able to stay on for as long as it has with little to no fading
Cracks instantly 1
Melissa from Maine
I bought the yellow and purple liners and while the colors are stunning they unfortunately start to crack INSTANTLY. I've tried both multiple times and every single time I haven't any luck with making them look even remotely wearable.
Pretty Good 4
Sabribri from Akron
I am fairly satisfied with this product. It is pigmented, but sometimes you have to apply twice to get the amount of color you want. It's also pretty heavy as far as the formula goes. But all that being said, it does last an entire day without rubbing off or crumbling.
Buy it asap! 5
Dafne from Nevada
I love these eyeliners , I already own the pink and blue eyeliners and both apply so perfectly! I now bought the red eyeliner and it looks so beautiful!! 100% recommend
Vivid Brights Eyeliner - Pink 3
E from MA
The applicator came a bit messed up, but it's fine. I expected more of a pastel color, it turned out to be a little hot pink-ish. I'm not sure if this is NYX's eyeliner products in general, but I do notice it cracks very easily. I have to apply multiple coats after a while so the cracks don't show.
I would buy this product again 4
Emmy from Visalia
This is a cute liquid eyeliner, The only thing is that the color oxidizes into a dark green which I was disappointed about ,but other than that I would purchase Again.
Stays put 5
Cuffs mom from Wisconsin
Bold, easy to use and very pigmented.
I don't buy this 1
This doesn't work at all save your money from Maryland
It suck waste of money
Great eyeliner! 5
Jenna from Portland, OR
This eyeliner is great for everyday wear. It gets a bit flaky near the end of the day but the color is great and it's worth the price I'd say.
Test it first. Had an allergic reaction 1
Molly from New England
Not worth the risk in my opinion.
purple eyeliner 3
B Marie from Scottsdale
I always use the black eyeliner but this time, I bought the purple eyeliner. it looks super awesome and wore it for 9 hours :). at the end of night, I removed and went to bed. I woke up with bright red eyes. it last for 4 days. I didnt wear make for a week after. then at day 14 since my first time with purple, I put it on again.
same thing happened; blood shot red eyes.
be aware.
Good product for what I bought it for 3
Aislyn from Richardson, TX
Hoes on nicely, and it bright. I've had problems with other liners and mascaras that did not have good color or were not applied easily, and this product was. However I've used eye makeup remover and face wash and there is still residue on my lash line after 3 days.
A new fave 4
B from New England
I love this product. It's a vivid color & glides on well. It does take a minute to dry, but it stays all day & doesn't smudge w/ my oily skin.
Warning - dangerous for your eyes! 1
DCGG from Philadelphia
🔴DON'T BUY 🔴 I want to start by saying I'm a fan of NYX eye pencils and this is my second attempt at using their Vivid Brights Eyeliner. First time, I got the light green and it cracked so much. This time, I got the beautiful red color and it's so dangerous for my eyes! After using it twice I must share my experience: my eyes hurt! They're red, almost like when you get pink eye. I removed it after 6 hours and it find help. It's been 24 hours since applying the eyeliner and my eyes are still bloodshot! Please be careful with this product!
Purple Eyeliner 3
NMKH from Nevada
The color is a bit lighter than shown on bottle. Still super pretty though. Getting on was normal. Not too streaky - but it made my eyes swell up and now they are irritated beyond belief. I am not sensitive- so use at your own discretion.
Drys fast and cracks 1
Ash from Phoenix Arizona
It started started drying and cracking a few minutes into wearing it.
Superior Eyeliner 5
MBKS from South Carolina
Very easy to use. The brush delivers the perfect line every time.
