Rated 4.1 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Unique and High Quality
I love this palette! Unveil is more burgundy than brown, which I personally love, and the pigmentation is unreal! If you're on the lighter side, Cameo is a great shade to set your eyeshadow primer and blank out your lid. Marble is beautiful in the inner corner and on the brow bone. Ash is the only mid-toned transition shade, so if you want a look that doesn't have true gray, you'll need to pull in another palette, which is unfortunate. The two metallic shades are absolutely stunning! My biggest gripe is that Moth doesn't show up at all, even on my very pale skin, so I'd imagine it would be hard to use for most people. I would have preferred Moth to be a mauve-y matte transition shade. Other than that, though, this is a great palette with stellar pigmentation (you honestly only need the smallest amount of the matte shades) and blends well, and wears beautifully (if you use a primer), and a refreshing change from all the warm-toned palettes!
Most Helpful Critical Review Quality is horrible!
I was so excited to get this product, the color story is just amazing. But when I received it -- oh Lord, no! Fall out city, chalky, dusty and dry, impossible to blend. I bought it, so I had to try it (removing my face make up to scrub out the fall out - yes, it was that bad). Disappointment grew: not only did the colors fade almost on application, they changed on me to entirely different shades than in the pan - light blue and light pink. Eww. Not what I expected at any price. I've had junky shadows that are 10 times better. Even with the bizarre color change, wear time (with UD primer) was only about 1 hour, TOTAL. Complete waste of time, money, and effort! Fallout continued even after setting spray, giving me raccoon eyes on a YouTube video. This is JUNK! Learned my lesson: From now on, if if doesn't come from UD, Tarte, Nars, Pat McGrath, or Natasha Denona I am not even bothering with it. I don't know how to return now with all the quarantine, but I must find a way - this brand is such a rip off and waste of time and money. What a disappointment that they continue to sell a palette like this - it will surely hurt the brand, it is that bad. No more Lime Crime for me, ever. This palette isn't worth even 99 cents.
Reviewed by 81 customers Disappointing
Ash from WA
The color story is perfect, I had been looking for a cool palette for a while and thought this was it. The quality sucks on the mattes though and it ruins the whole experience and makes applying the eye shadow frustrating. Anytime I try to use the mattes I always end up washing my makeup off and redoing it with a different palette. The shimmers in the palette are great, but only half of the palette is actually usable.
Ella H. from Michigan
It's just not nearly as pigmented as I thought it would be. The quality is pretty similar to like wet n wild. This is my first purchase from Lime Crime and I'm not impressed. However, I love the packaging, colors, and the names. Whole not very pigmented you can build up the color, and there wasn't very much fall out. So it's not terrible, it just wasn't as good as advertised, though I feel like this will be used quite a bit as its all the colors I routinely use in one palette.
i wanted this palette so bad
jewels from new hampshire
as a cool toned palette lover i rushed to buy this and i am so sad writing this because as much as i wanted to love this palette..it was a miss. there is just no pigmentation whatsoever. even the morphe cool toned palettes are much much more pigmented. i was disappointed. but the glow in the dark box is cool i guess... def would not recommend this to a friend and wish i had returned it. :(
Perfect for Goth and Grunge
Rei from Wilmington, DE
This had a lot of great colors to match as we move to plaid and Doc Marten season for me between lots of mattes and just a little bit of sparkle. Its been beautiful so far even just to go out in some summer dresses for the last days of summer.
Anna from Michigan
Truly awful. I have the original Venus and Venus II. This is nowhere near the quality. Even the shimmer pay off is bad like. I have Wet n Wild Palletes that sounds better. The mattes are chalky and don't blend at all. The shimmers need like 4 layers. Just, don't waste your money I returned it straight away.
swede from maine
so chalky, doesn't blend, once it's on that's it.. no consistency
Jaz from Chicago
I've been eyeballing this palette and all in all love it. Was worried a little bit my some of the negative reviews, but it works great for me. Shows up nicely on my melanin.
Love the pallette, hated the hassle of purchase
Lisa from Mesa, Arizona- Signal Butte
I find that these colors look particularly stunning when paired with a nude-pink lip color and peachy highlight.
Jessica from North Carolina
I very much prefer cool toned eyeshadows and it's pretty hard to come by eyeshadow palettes that are nothing but cool toned shades. Every time I do my eyeshadow I always use black in the outer portion and for some reason my left eye doesn't want to hold onto pigment very well, and this is the first black I've tried that actually sticks. These shadows blend pretty nicely, and I love that there is a number of shades to blend out the black. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is because I felt like some of the shades could've been a bit more pigmented for the price, but overall I'm very happy with it.
Just not a good palette
G from Texas
I love the casing and the over all look of the palette, so the quality of the product wound up being extremely disappointing. Every shade just seems to be one pigment short of what it's supposed to be. But the biggest issue I had with it was it's inability to blend. And I tried with multiple shades different ways. Instead of creating a smooth transition of color it would just blend in to one big mess of a color.
I absolutely love this palette I didn't know I needed
Babybluegrrl from Flordia
I absolutely love this palette. I never knew or thought I would love this so much. The gray is gorgeous as a halo with the silver in the middle. Blended out with the white shade to the brow bone. The white shade is not as pigmented but it's meant to be this way. It's stunning when used properly. If you want to use it on your lid use a glitter primer/glue and build it up.
Sleek and Modern
Aleera the Vampire Queen from Cheyenne, WY
I really enjoy this pallette. You can go very neutral with it. I love the white and the black. They grey is also great. It is my go to for my regular gothic-y look. But it can be used in a lot of other ways too. I feel like it is so versatile. I love the formula is fabulous. I like the softness and the fact that they are really highly pigmented.
Perfect cool-tone pallette
Jessica J from Seattle
I've had a hard time finding a great palette that isn't too warm- I'm fair skinned and like the look of cool colors better on me. These shadows are beautiful and last without creasing (I use Nars eye primer), even after a 12 hour shift. Highly recommend this gem!
Soft, pigmented shadows
Phoenix PDX from Portland, OR
The newer Immortalis pressed shadow palette more than lived up to my expectations. I have two other Lime Crime palettes and I purchased this one for the color selection, knowing that some colors can be hit or miss. This selection seems to swatch and blend quite well. It has a good mix of matte, light shimmer, and high shimmer shades. The colors don't seem to be a common combination, though I feel that is a fantastic attribute.
Karyam from Texas
Absolutely love this palette. Huge Lime Crime eyeshadow palettes fan. Eyeshadows are pigmented, blendablea and they don't fade once on the eyes. Some kickback on the pans but no noticeable fallout.
Izzy from Grand Rapids, MI
I absolutely love this palette!! It's now my everyday go to palette I would definitely recommend this on my fellow brown eyed loves ✨😍
A beautiful cool-toned palette
Erin from Washington, D.C.
I've been wanting to order this palette for a couple of months now, but the negative reviews gave me pause. That said, I'm SO glad I decided to go ahead and buy this. I have been searching for a cool-toned grey palette for ages, and this delivered exactly what I've been looking for. I honestly haven't seen these colors anywhere else, so I can truly say that this was worth the money, as I don't have anything like it in my collection. With regard to quality, I personally didn't have issues with blendability. The shimmers do need a wet brush in order to truly pop on the lid, however.
TL;DR: If you're in search of easy to use cool tones, this palette is a good buy.
one of the worst palettes I've ever tried
beauty_cutie3.14 from Pennsylvania
shadows are way too firmly pressed. color payoff is minimal to nonexistant. definitely not worth the price. also the shade that looks burgundy/red in all the photos is just brown
Great high quality eyeshadow!
Bree from Wisconsin
This is my new favorite brand for eyeshadow. I've tried Urban decay and Too Faced in the past, they do not compare to this pallet! Never have I had eyeshadow that I didn't have to layer, never have I had eyeshadow that had absolutely no fall out, until this eyeshadow pallet! I highly recommend it, not only is the quality there with the eyeshadow, but the packaging is super cute too!
Jessica from Pennsylvania
Nice pallet but doesn't blend as well as their others... ends up patchy with some colors. Disappointed.
I love it--with some reservations
trainingbrawl from MI
I absolutely love this palette, but it is a little hard to use. The colors are gorgeous and cool, with several textures to choose from.
The drawbacks are that the mattes are tricky to blend with other mattes. Also, Moth, which is a gorgeous shifting topper, is really subtle until you learn to work with it. These drawbacks are totally surmountable and worth learning how to work with, in my opinion, given the beauty of the colors and the multitude of looks you can create with this palette.
If you love the vibe of this palette, you should get it because it is unique among the monochrome palettes available on the market. Just be prepared to spend a little time getting to know it--it's totally worth it.
Beautiful colors and apply very nicely
Mamamia0001 from Chicago, IL
Beautiful pallet, pigmented shadows, nice range of colors that are pretty neutral. You can use this for a casual day's makeup or for a dressed up night out out look. The pallet packaging is very cool and glows in the dark. I would recommend this to anyone.
Crystal from Aztec, NM
This has easily become my favorite palette out of my 20 others I own. The colors are perfection with my newly green hair. Love the way the colors blend.
swede from ct
I love this pallet so much... so pigmented
Cool Tone Color Palette
LML from North Eastern Pennsylvania
Cool color palettes are hard to find - this is a GREAT cool toned palette - very happy with this purchase.