Product Reviews Rated 4.29 out of 5 stars
21 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review New Favorite Natural Eyeliner I have really struggled to find a more natural eyeliner that stays put on my oily lids — happy to say I think I've found it! This eyeliner really lasts all day for me, doesn't travel, but also wears down well (fades ever so slightly, but does it evenly and still looks great). Application is smooth and doesn't tug on my eyes and appears to wash off well with my normal cleanser. I originally bought this in black, but I'll also be buying the brown in my next order. This will be replacing all of my sub-par eyeliners I've used in the past. I hope Pacifica keeps this one around for a long time!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not long lasting My first eyeliner from Pacifica. I love the color, it's a nice brown. My only problem is it states water proof however this tends to come off immediately. As soon as I apply it, it's patchy and by the end of my 4 hr shift it's practically gone. In the middle of my eyelid it always comes off automatically. I apply and reapply and it still smears off. I would not pay full price for this. Although I do love the color because black eyeliner tends to look harsh and doesn't suit my eyes. I am trying to find how else I can make this stay if it would I'd give it 4.5 stars.
Reviewed by 21 customers Smoothe! 5
LisaMarie from Fenton, MO
Goes on easy when applying. Stays on well enough. Sometimes it smudges a little but I think it is because I get a little carried away with the face oil when applying AND if I do not apply the face oil hours before my makeup, it tends to prevent the other products from staying on like intended. The eye pencil is one of my favorites but I may try the pen next time. I like the fact that the eyeliner is water proof but I have a difficult time sharpening it and grind it down quicker than I would like. So, if you have a good eye pencil sharpener, I would say this eyeliner is a good pick.
A little smudgy 4
Diabetic Dolphin from New Mexico
I've been using this one for a while, and I like it for general use and for smudgy looks. It does wander, even with a primer, so prepare for using it to smudge like khol. I suggest using it under the same brand of eyeshadow or other silky eyeshadows for a smudged look.
Best brown eyeliner 5
AnnieBeau from Vacaville, CA
I use this brown eyeliner everyday, in my waterline and on top of my lash line. It doesn't smudge, even when my eyes water or when my face gets oily. I love that it's vegan and natural. It's my absolute favorite.
Not the best eyeliner for me 2
Shelley R from Jacksonville, FL
This eyeliner skipped a lot. I had to keep going over the same spots. Not my favorite.
Easy on 5
Annieb from PTC, GA
Nice eyeliner, goes on smooth. Its soft/creamy so easy to apply. I did have to buy a pencil sharpener for it.
Works perfectly and Contact lens friendly 4
Nature Girl from Utah
I really like this eyeliner. It is easy to use, it does take a few minutes to set but when it does it last all day with no smudging.
Works great for me! 5
Lisa H from undisclosed
I think this works great! It all depends on where and how people apply their makeup, but for me, I'm a fan!
Lovely product 5
Rowan16 from Nashville
Beautiful shade! Stays on well, doesn't hurt coming on or off, looks great! Has no negative effect on skin.
Smooth application and rich color. 4
Beck from Northeast Pa
Smooth application and great dark color, lastee all day and came off easily too.
I'm differently hooked 5
Sharon Short from Redlands Ca
I love the way it just glides on and last for hours
Fallback product - not the worst, not the best 3
Hilary from Kentucky
This falls into the category of things I may use if I can't find my preferred eyeliner.
I've given it a good week test run but even though it's waterproof, just the amount of skin oils near my eye cause it to migrate more than my preferred eyeliner.
It DOES go on smoothly with no tugging and has decent pigmentation. Just not the best and not the worst as a waterproof eyeliner.
Love it! 5
AHartz from Oregon coast
Awesome eyeliner! Smooth, long lasting, great color.
Love it! 5
AHartz from Oregon
Awesome eyeliner! Smooth, long lasting, great color.
New OG Liner 5
Ash from Yuba City
I'm a huge fan of pencil liners and have stuck to Nyx for years. However, the latest formula seems to irritate my eyes and fades quickly. I ordered this on a whim while it was on sale and I am in love with it! It doesn't bother my eyes, stays put, and it's cruelty free. I'll buy this forever. Bonus points for cute packaging, too.
Eye eye 4
NetteM from Missouri
Good eyeliner thought it seems to smear easy
Not long lasting 3
Jass93 from California
My first eyeliner from Pacifica. I love the color, it's a nice brown. My only problem is it states water proof however this tends to come off immediately. As soon as I apply it, it's patchy and by the end of my 4 hr shift it's practically gone. In the middle of my eyelid it always comes off automatically. I apply and reapply and it still smears off. I would not pay full price for this. Although I do love the color because black eyeliner tends to look harsh and doesn't suit my eyes. I am trying to find how else I can make this stay if it would I'd give it 4.5 stars.
Not the best 3
Anna from Waco, TX
It goes on smoothly and the color is perfect, but smudges easily and wears off throughout the day
Amazing Eyeliner! 5
Jamie from Newport News, VA
I really like this eyeliner, I have extremely oily eyelids, it will still smudge, unfortunately however, with as oily as my skin this is to be expected. It ends of giving me more of a smokey eye effect without even trying, lol! Plus it comes off perfectly at night when i use my coconut oil as my only eyemakeup remover.
New Favorite Natural Eyeliner 5
Kat C. from Raleigh, NC
I have really struggled to find a more natural eyeliner that stays put on my oily lids — happy to say I think I've found it! This eyeliner really lasts all day for me, doesn't travel, but also wears down well (fades ever so slightly, but does it evenly and still looks great). Application is smooth and doesn't tug on my eyes and appears to wash off well with my normal cleanser. I originally bought this in black, but I'll also be buying the brown in my next order. This will be replacing all of my sub-par eyeliners I've used in the past. I hope Pacifica keeps this one around for a long time!
Good, but not the best..But will use it for sure.. 3
CatherineKittyKat from Sacramento
Love your company and products I've tried and want EVERYTHING...LOL!...So it's hard to give your eyeliner less than all the stars. I like it and it goes on easy, but starts to relax under my eyes on the outer corners. I have to keep checking and do some wiping. Because it's water proof it doesn't rinse off in show but spreads around, but I just get some coconut oil and rub around and wipe off, which is fine. I prolly think just cause water proof doesn't mean oil proof and that's why blends down under eye.
Swim-proof 5
Bethany from Albuquerque NM
Definitely stays on and looks nice! It's sharp but is easily smoothed out if I want a more blended look. I can go swimming in it and look perfect. The only thing is it's hard to remove at the end of the day, but that only makes sense.
