Rated 2.53 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best I've ever had
I love this eyeliner and it's one of the few that doesn't smear with my hooded eyes. It's a little different to put on than most liquid, it glides on, which is great but it took a few tries to get use to it. Hands down, this is my new eyeliner!
Most Helpful Critical Review Dried Out.
I've tried out kat von d eyeliners before and I've loved the formulas and how smooth they apply. This one does not apply smoothly at ALL. It separates and skips as your applying & just over all doesn't leave a nice clean finish at all. Would not recommend & when I first got it no product came out so I had to get another one because it was completely DRIED OUT.
Reviewed by 57 customers If I could leave 0 stars, I would
Nicole P. from NY
I used to love KVD beauty, and I stopped buying once all the Kat Von D. controversy began. Finding out she was bought out attracted me to giving this brand another shot! I used to swear by their liquid liner, and man oh man, this is not the same.
I still would like to try out the regular liquid liner, but with this felt tip, nothing is leaving the pen to apply to my eye. I have never seen anything so bad. Please don't buy this, they need to work on the design and clearly didn't test it trying to see if it'll even apply!!!
Horrible waste of money
Zoe from California
Accidentally grabbed this liner instead of my go-to tattoo liner. I love the tattoo liner so much I figured it wouldn't be that big of a deal
Boy was I wrong. This is the worst eyeliner I've ever bought. I've used drug store brands that are better than this liner-and not just better, but blows this liner out of the water. Can't believe they sell something so horrible. The felt tip doesn't even work, so if you ever want a nice, fine, line....don't buy this. Buy her tattoo liner instead, or any drug store brand.
AWFUL, Nothing like the original
Beth from Arkansas
I was honestly mind-blown at just how bad this was. I've used the regular Ink Liner for years, and I love it. My local store was sold out of the regular, so I decided to try this. BIG mistake. It was dried out, right out of the package. I tried a few typical tricks to get the ink going, which did absolutely nothing. I even gave the liner a second chance and tried it again, in case the first time was just a bad fluke or something. I don't know, I just couldn't seem to bring myself to believe the liner was THAT bad, surely something just went wrong the first time? ..... Nope. It most definitely WAS that bad.
I returned it. Now after reading these other reviews, I'm realizing it wasn't just me, there is truly something wrong with this product. It is NOTHING like the regular Ink Liner. This ranks in the top 3 (or bottom 3?? haha) of biggest makeup disappointments I've had.
This eyeliner is terrible
julia from Pittsburgh, PA
This eyeliner was described as "ultra black", but it is literally the most unpigmented eyeliner I have ever used. Even though it's brand new, I feel like I'm using an old, worn out eyeliner and just praying that there's enough product left to finish my eye. Don't buy this.
I would NEVER buy this product again.
Kim from TX
Felt tip is too short and liquid is watered down. I had to reapply an old liquid eyeliner over it just to get the definition that it claimed to have. I've used KVD eyekiners before and was very happy, however, this certain style is a dud.
Does not draw a black line. This product sucks
Kim from Columbus, in
I tried to do a black winged eye and this doesn't look black and doesn't do a solid line
Madt from California
It's the absolute worst KVD product I've ever bought
This product does not work well
alex from lancaster, PA
This especially does not work on any thick eyeshadow or full look, but it flakes and smears. The felt tip does not provide accuracy AT ALL!! I have tried to give the benefit of the doubt, but my cheap elf eyeliner works SO much better than this. I have yet to be impressed with any of this companies products and do not understand the hype. The black is also not even very dark, especially over eyeshadow. It also is Not long lasting in any capacity.
Jenn from Mississippi
This is the most expensive and worst eye liner I have ever used in my life! Bought it after a friend recommended this brand. I used it for the first time on my daughter to do Halloween witch make-up. The tip was so dry I couldn't get it to draw a line. Tried holding it tip down for a minute to see if the ink would come out better only to have the ink seeping out of the seam of the pen and all over my daughters face, costume and my hands. Truly awful experience. Sent a message directly to the customer service of company that makes it and haven't heard a single response so the company must not care about quality of their product or their customers.
Where has this been all my life???
HarlowX14 from Sacramento California
The way this glides on is just perfection. I'll never use anything but this again!
not a favorite.
anonymous from Georgia
It did not apply well at all. I got this product on accident when meaning to get the normal tattoo liner which I know I prefer now. I wore KVD primer and it still bled to my upper eye lid in less than an hour
Erin from WA
I tried this on my hand after buying it and am extremely disappointed. Its already dried out and it switched gray and splotchy. I regret buying this over my usual liquid liner.
Chey from PA
Felt tip is always dry, formula is streaky and goes flaky when it dries down. Super disappointed.
Toi from Baton Rouge
This was the second time I purchased this product and it was very dry both times right after opening.
Single Handedly Crushed My Dreams
Spiraling Sarah from Prattville, AL
I was ecstatic to try this "holy grail" product. I've heard about it for YEARS. Let me tell you— top 3 worst eyeliners I have ever encountered and I braved the Wet N Wild liner once. For any product to come out, you have to carve into your skull. The tip of the pen did not ever leave product. In trying to fill in the line, it erased prior applications. All in all, this eyeliner is so bad it sent me into a spiral trying to get ready for my birthday dinner. Do not recommend.
definitely not liner x
Mandy from chicago
I purchased this as my normal tattoo liner was out of stock at my local store. I was excited because I was one of the people who purchased liner x when it was available for testing. liner x was great very pigmented no skipping and matte. this liner skips, is dry, and removes liner if you try to go over it. the tip is wonderful, but that's all that I liked about it. this definitely is not liner x that I used previously. very disappointed.
My new favorite
Lindismf from Honey Grove, TX
My old eyeliner was out and I needed a new one. I thought I would have to try out a few before I settled on one but no. This is one is amazing.
I wouldn't buy this again. Tip was dry and too short/thin
Kay from Palm Desert, CA
Not what I was looking for in a felt tip liner. Drew a nice line but the tip was dried out without ever being open before. And not good for filling in cat eye. Wouldn't recommend.
holly from stearns ky
I absolutely love this liner. Its smooth and so easy to work with. Great quality and it lasts all day.
Don't Buy This Liner
Alyssa from Apple Valley, MN
I gave this liner a try and was sorely disappointed. I always apply my liner last. I was able to get one corner wing with the tip but when I tried to line my lid, I had to hold it horizontally to get an even line which was still spotchy. When I tried to fix the spotchy spots the tip failed to coat it. Now, I don't know if this is because I had shadow on already or not but even testing the liner on my hand with the tip and next to nothing showed up.
Ashley from MA
Took a risk on this liner instead of picking up my beloved Tattoo Liner. Sadly it didn't meet my expectations. The ink does not come out evenly like the original. You have to lean down on one of the sides to get it to spread but it never quite reaches the point and/or when lining it doesn't come out consistently. I don't know if the one I got was faulty but I went and exchanged it for the original Tattoo Liner.
Mickey from VA
Used this once and the sponge was drying out during application will be returning.
Desi from Augusta, GA
Tried to use this on the same night I purchased it. No liner comes out. It is completely dried up. I attempted the next day with no shadow on the eyes, hardly anything. The little bit I was able to get lasted less than an hour before it looked smudged and faded. I am horribly disappointed and hope I can return it.
Dries Out Super Fast
Shai All Day from Fort Oglethorpe, GA
I really wanted to like this eyeliner, but it is awful. It dried out the first time I used it. I had to go over my eye several times to get it somewhat close to dark enough. I will be returning it.
Denise from Rockford, IL
I bought it and it was super dried out... so disappointed.