Rated 3.94 out of 5 stars
I have very light, straight invisible lashes. This is a side-by-side of my eyes with and without this mascara. Not all mascaras can tackle lower lashes, but just look! My one complaint is that for the first half hour of wear, I find smudges right below my eyebrows. But I love the result too much to care! I've been a Lash Sensational addict for years, but this gets my lower lashes looking amazing. I have a new HG!
I bought this Tuesday I was looking for a waterproof mascara and I wish that I had went with a different one cause this did clump my lashes together and it looked horrible! It's not going to stop me from trying another waterproof one, but any suggestions? Ive used Maybelline products since I was a teenager, just need to find the right waterproof mascara for me!
Nora from Kenosha, WI.
Leah from Houston, TX
I tried this product because of the long lasting claim appeal.
I have been doing my eyebrows for over a decade and am not an amateur.
First, the product is messy. Its extremely cakey and almost clay like.
I purchased the lightest shade "blonde" and the color came out a weird dark brown with a green undertone.
After one use, with little pressure, I needed to sharpen. The pencil is terrible to sharpen. It has a hard base that you have to force your sharpener over. The product just sludges off onto the sharpener. You're left with a square blocky mess.
Blending is next to impossible. Youre left with "Bald spots" when using the spooly even gently.
Overall it's a terrible product.
No precision, not blendable, not long lasting, messy, and just outright ugly color.
El from Omaha, Nebraska
I got this because i wanted fuller eyelashes and i would use it every night or every other night and i did not see a chage. Its been 2 months since i started using it and it has done nothing. Do not waste ur money
Haylee from Rhode Island
Always loved this product makes my eyelashes bomb but not clumpy and does a great waterproof job!!!
Kimberly from Chatham, IL
This adds the perfect amount of color without going overboard. The applicator brush is easy to use and it stays put until washed off. The color doesn't run, smudge or get on anything giving you all-day wear. Keeps your brows in place all day too! My brows look great!
Soraya from Dallas Tx
Giselle from San Diego
Never had an issue with this product and it always makes my lashes look good. Also one of the most affordable mascaras.
C from California
This is pigmented; too dark for me, & wesrs iff pretty quickly. I dont like thats its a chunky crayon - its hard to get it precise. Wont be buying again.
L from Ohio
I am very disappointed in this product. The actual brow gel is great. It's smooth and full coverage and it does last a long time. My only problem is that it is not a twist up top. I don't understand why they would make a brow pencil so soft if it does not sharpen well. I only got about 2 or 3 uses out of this pencil before I had to sharpen it. While technically yes, it does sharpen, it does not actually sharpen well, and the product starts to disintegrate as soon as you sharpen it. I have a titanium German made eyebrow sharpener that I spent a lot of money on so it's definitely not my sharpener. I have sharpened so many eyebrow and eyeliner pencils with my sharpener and I have never had this issue with a product Before. I will not re-purchase this until they redesign the packaging. The product is itself is great but I wasted money buying a product that I can only use twice.
chelle from Pittsburgh, PA
I wanted to really like this drugstore option fot mascara, but unfortunately I still ended up with smudging and "racoon eyes" by the end of the day.
redboek from California
one of the worst just because of thr false hope. at first i loved the way it looked, it made my lashes longer and bolder looking. then within less than 6 hrs I look like a raccoon. mind you not once did i rub my eyes and it wasn't one of my crazy days where im running around. i was literally inside an ac room all day basically doing paperwork, so its not as if i was sweating alot. super disappointed
Breezy from Southern Oregon
This is so dark! Like stain your eyebrows for two days dark. It is very very sad :(
Lisa from Annapolis, MD
Mascara is a good color and consistency. The wand is wobbly (some sort of a spring about 3/4" above the brush), so it makes it difficult to apply correctly, and when the brush "snaps," it spatters on your face and lids.
Deborah from MS
Mandi from Moses Lake, WA
I needed a quick waterproof, black-brown mascara so I grabbed this. It exceeded my expectations. Light, no clumping,
minx33 from SC
I consider myself a mascara expert. And this one is my essential base coat for length. And a nothing is as good at any price. Including Chantecalle, Dior etc. I always start with this mascara. And it makes nars and everything else perform much better because most of them are trying to build volume (and many clump) But I want length. I credit supermodel Cindy Crawford with telling me about this mascara...... otherwise I never, ever would have tried anything "Drug store." also removed bicely with no racoon hangover. price isn't always quality .... learned my lesson about that!
If on sale, I will order 5 at a time. You should do the same because you're gonna love it.
Addi from Indiana
Stephanie from Vermont
I bought this mascara to wear to a funeral and it stayed put throughout the tears. No smudging at all. I would give 5 stars but it's difficult to remove, even with micellar water like the company recommended in the Q&A above
Stelly from Santa Fe, NM
I've tried other, more expensive brands and always come back to this one! The brush is user friendly and not too bushy like some mascaras. It's easy to use and looks amazing on natural lashes. Non-waterproof is easy to remove.
Heather from Washington
This mascara is so good! Helps keep lashes curled and separated. My biggest pet peeve is clumpy mascara that applies clumpy but this one is very good. The silicone bristles help separate each lash and lengthens at the same time. Definitely recommend.
Sunnygrl115 from California
this mascara really gets the job done when it comes to length. for two coats there is minimal clumping and overall very natural looking lashes. I don't notice any shine, but I primarily purchased this for the lengthening effect anyways.
Ann from Florida
I after dry in it crack and they are black dot after my eyes
Hannah from Ohio
I have been using this brow gel for years. I have jet black (dyed) hair but naturally blonde brows and lashes. I use the darkest shade and it is a great match for my hair color. The formula is light but buildable and gives volume to my brows. Great for a feathery look. I also use it for my bottom lashes!
Did not clump and added lots of length to my natural eyelashes :)
Emily from philadelphia
I love this mascara and Ive tried them all. This is the only mascara that will hold a curl, I apply it after I curl my VERY straight lashes, and it holds my lashes up instead of weighing them down. A little difficult to remove but oh well. LOVE THIS