Rated 4.45 out of 5 stars
I've been using eyeliner every day for school since the 6th grade, and until this year I haven't had an eyeliner that works so wonderfully for my needs. I wear it everyday for the whole school day (7-9 hours) without touching it up. If I go somewhere fancy later that day, I might touch up the end of the wing, but other than that, it stays. I even went to a pool party and went underwater and it stayed fairly well for a product that doesn't claim to be waterproof. I LOVE this eyeliner and I bought three pencils after I ran out of my first. And the price??????? Can't go wrong.
I applied the "Go Wild" color to my hand in the store to see if it would be good on my skin tone. Since I felt that it would be a match, I bought it! However, when I was able to get a moment at home to see how it looked on my eyeline, it was SO difficult to get any color to appear around this sensitive eye area. Unlike my hand, I can't treat my eyes with the same pressure that I would've needed in order to get some color to show up. But still, I wasn't using a lot of force on my hand either... I was disappointed to say the least and made a return on this product.
Ash from Waynesboro, PA
I use this all the time. It's exceptional quality for the price. Blends well and applies easily. Very creamy. Lasts all day and removes easy.
Tammy from KC, MO
I thought I'd finally found a new holy grail eyeliner at a great price! Sadly, I was wrong. The eyeliner was a bit on the dry side at first, but stayed all day with minimal fading. After 2 weeks of use it is almost completely dried out. I tried to use it this morning and had no luck. I have never experienced this with any other brand before. Maybe the eyeliner I received was just old? I may try another color just to see if I have the same experience.
00 from Los Angeles
Looks really good when I apply. I tried to be cheap and buy this one but it only last 1 hour! I have to apply all day when I wear eyeliner.
Buffy from Farmington Utah
I really love this eyeliner pencil because it stays on ALL DAY LONG!
Kristi from Mi
This really does last and is waterproof. This is a great product at a great price.
Honeybzzy from Chicago
Does not smudge under the eye. Stays put on the lid. Long lasting but not waterproof -exactly what I was looking for. Doesn't fade. Rich pigment! A great price. Essence line DEFINITELY keeps impressing me product after product.
Joan from Cleveland, Ohio
The best eyebrow pencil I've used
Keya from Woodbridge, VA
Absolutely loved the eye pencil by essence has been using it for years now.
It is super rich in color, lasts all day, does not smudge. Great price.
Sheila from Morton, Illinois
Such black intensity. Glides on smoothly. Waterproof and smudge proof. I grab 2 at a time. What's not to love?
kel from orange county
I LOVE THIS EYELINER ITS SO EASY TO USE
Kaven from Jefferson Ga
Went for the sparkly black, and it's actually sparkly! However I recommend not using this on humid days or days that you'll be outside a bunch, chances are it will fade/run
Bibi from lacey
very smooth gel color and prices are good
Vasilisa from Mountain View, CA
This product is a lot more long lasting than some of the other black eye pencils I have tried but this one markets as waterproof but surely is not. It slightly wears off after 2 ish hours and if you want that bold black waterline look, you would have to reapply.
Nola from Ct
I like it a lot it applies well and I love the brand and how it looks
I usually use CoverGirl ink it black for about $7 but this is like $3-$4 and much much better, no smudging dark bold black lasts all day!
yara from Ma
it's so fun and cute and i love all the fun and festive colors my favorite are the blue and silver. they work so well and i will be repurchasing this again. it's good for parties and hangouts.
Janice from Lafayette IN
This is the best eyeliner for staying on for 16 hours and you can't beat the price!! I have recommended to my friends and co workers!!
Nicole from Las Vegas
I got this on sale a few days before Christmas and this was the perfect color for the holiday. I love the festive pigment and it really is long lasting. It also glides on really smooth and didn't transfer even when I had a white eye shadow cream stick on my lids.
Yvette from Phx, AZ
This product is inexpensive, it works great and stays on all day, and it does not smudge. I've tried other expensive products and I'm not as satisfied.
Thank you for creating a makeup line that is affordable to limited income folks like myself.
Michelle from Peabody, MA
I was looking for a smooth, easy to apply eyeliner (not a liquid) that I could apply myself without too much fuss. I'm not a makeup person, so I do not typically apply much makeup other than eye liner & mascara.
Kate from Chicago, IL
The color is very nice but it comes off quite easily
Jean from Flowood,Mississippi
U get what u pay for. This wasn't worth it. I'd rather pay in 4 and stick to the prestige brands that won't smudge or rub off on my finger after 5 minutes