Rated 3.96 out of 5 stars
As for the Total Temptation™ Washable Mascara, I'm such a fan!
What the product claims to do: Total Temptation™ Washable Mascara builds lashes for full and soft volume. Build on bold volume to create irresistibly soft, separated, and dense lashes coat after coat. Features a creamy and whipped formula infused with coconut extract.
-The product didn't clump. I hate when mascara's clump and my eyelashes end up sticking together.
-The packaging is bomb! How cute?!
-The mascara comes in the shade blackest black. I love dark mascara
-My lashes had instant volume, but they weren't crazy hard and stiff looking.
None as of yet :)
I received this mascara, along with a few other goodies from Influenster, and being totally honest, it's not my favorite. I'd read a ton of reviews on this saying that it was amazing, and it may be holy grail status for some, but it just wasn't a perfect fit for me. That being said, it's not a horrible product by any means. For me, this is a great lengthening mascara. I have long lashes to begin with, but this definitely helped to add even more length. But, in terms of volume, this just didn't cut it for me. I found that this mascara was more likely to clump up on me, and didn't really make my lashes look any fuller.
Chelle from MI
I dont normally post bad reviews unless I feel strongly about it and this happens to be a product that I really did not like. I loved how it initially makes my lashes look but it takes forever to dry and smudges almost immediatley under the eye. Doesnt stay on theough the day either as im constantly wiping under my eyes fo remove smudged peoduct.
Becca J from St. Louis, MO
I've bought cheaper mascara that doesnt smudge at all. I got raccoon eyes after just a few hours of wear. The brush could be better designed, too much access product comes out on the spoolie. I won't be finishing the tube.
MissRx from undisclosed
I don't usually feel strongly enough negatively about most products to write a review …and the formula isn't necessarily terrible- but the brush is so lumped full of the product EVERY time you take it out of the bottle. It's horrible. It's more work to actually wipe down the brush than anything. The formula is a tad clumpy though despite that. Just not really easy to use. Desperately needs something on the bottle to keep from a ridiculous amount of goop on the brush.
Mackenzie from Atlanta, GA
This mascara smudges onto my lower lid by the end of the day every time.
Meghan_e_neal from undisclosed
Sobbed extensively watching a very depressing TV show and it didn't streak at all (and this isn't even the waterproof version). Highly recommend for regular criers like myself, or those who might find themselves in emotionally riveting situations.
Basia from NJ
Fave go to mascara went I don't feel like spending a ton. Works great!
Aditt from Tx
Very wet, clumpy, eyelashes stick together, runs after about 2hrs. You get what you pay for.
I love Maybelline products but this one is by far the worst mascara I have tried from them. Purchased a few days ago and I love the application, and how it made my eyelashes look after applying, however it is just sticky goo and the mascara never dries and it ends up clumping all of my lashes together.
KayDMic from Kalamazoo MI
I love this color and formula so much! There is nothing like it out there. PLEASE BRING IT BACK!!😫
Tiffany from Springfield MO
Makes your eyelashes look amazing but sometimes hey clumpy
Fattyma from Brooklyn, NY
I've never gotten such amazing volume and lift from a drugstore mascara ever. ITS BOMB. It actually holds the lift all day, even if I didn't curl my lashes. One thing is that it's a little smeary so be careful if you sneeze before it dries. I use another old mascara wand to separate my lashes and remove some of the wetness (which really isn't a lot, it's just to separate). Otherwise it's amazing! I have the mini from a sample but I will be buying the full size.
Cartwheel22 from New York, NY
A true washable mascara just needs a little hot water, virtually no rubbing to come off. This one takes a lot of backs and forths with a waterproof mascara remover. That's not what I thought I was buying. It's also thick and clumpy. If you want long clean lashes without thick clumps, this is not the mascara to buy.
Lin from DMV
I have long lashes naturally &
Elie from undisclosed
I just purchased Total Temptation mascara for the first time. Blackest Black is great-I love the formula, goes on very smooth, doesn't feel heavy. However, the applicator handle needs to change. I found it difficult to use with one side being flat while the rest was round. Two sides should be flat or have it be all round, this would make it easier to hold and use.
Laikyn from Kentucky
This product is good when you just want a minimum amount of mascara, but I will say that it does smear pretty bad and by the end of the day I looked like a raccoon.
Sami from Kingsford
I liked the way it made my eyelashes look but I don't if it was just for me but the brush bristles were so sharp like it hurt to put it on I would stab my waterline but a good formula
cmg from california
this mascara was awful! it was extremely clumpy, didn't lengthen or add volume, and smeared all over. honestly it was like they mixed black dye with vaseline and put it in a mascara tube. just horrible, and the brush was weird and scratchy.
Beca from Chicago
I love this mascara for my daily makeup. It lasts all day without smudging or flaking. It doesnt give my lashes much length and volume, compared to other mascaras ive used, which is why i prefer it for my minimal routine.
Simple and classy from Kansas
I have used Maybelline Total Temptation mascara for over a year now, and as I went to open another new tube, it occurred to me that I might share my satisfaction with the product with others by writing a review. The formula is everything that I could want at an affordable price--lightweight, easy-to-apply, quick-drying, and washable (yet doesn't flake off to darken the area under one's eyes during the day). Best of all, it results in a very natural-looking effect which is perfect for everyday wear. It helps to accentuate one's eyes without looking distractingly heavy or fake.
Lauren from Las Vegas NV
This mascara bottle is awful. The inside doesn't scrape off any excess mascara so you're left with gobs and gobs on the wand.
Euniceadi from Banbury, UK
I have worn this several times and it is a waste of money. It flakes off and when my eyes water in this cold weather, the mascara runs, making my eyes look messy.
Brenda from Southern Pines NC
Doesn't make my lashes look thick, dried out mascara, didn't look like I put mascara on
MSJR from Biloxi
I'm taking back my previous positive review. This mascara is horrible! I ended up with an eye issue because of this mascara, took months to resolve! It's a shame because I loved the color brown in this product.
CS from NY
bought it today, came pretty much dry. save your money