Rated 4.21 out of 5 stars
I purchased this eyeliner in midnight gray and was expecting it to look like slate (not my preference). But to my surprise, the color turned out to be a beautiful soft matte black. The eyeliner was smooth and easy to apply. I have very oily skin and hooded eyelids, and the eyeliner smudged only a little at the corners of my eyes after several hours of errands today. In my book, this is a win because I almost always develop raccoon eyes with other natural eyeliners, which are often much more expensive. Overall good staying power, so I'm looking forward to buying more colors. Please add purple, blue, green, and gold to this eyeliner collection!
When I first put this eyeliner on I absolutely loved it. It goes on smooth and not waxy or hard. My biggest issue with it is that it tends to run on me. I am one that usually puts a liquid on underneath but like the matte look of the pencil so I run it over and in that way it works well, however, the first few times I tried this by itself (because would be so much easier not to do both) and I found that it ran into creases like many others I have tried.
C L B from undisclosed
Glides on easily, nice subtle color, comes off easily with micellar water
Jodroge331 from undisclosed
I thought it was ab eyebrow pencil. It is too dark for my eyebrows.
VV2023 from undisclosed
I ordered several items, but received only one of them. I got a small sized lotion. It was nice, but I never received my lip shimmers nor eye liner. I also never received an email updating me on a cancellation nor out-of-stock notice. Burt's Bees products are normally very good, but you failed on this order.
G1919 from undisclosed
I JUST RECEIVED MY EYELINER PENCIL. I LIKE TO USE IT FOR MY BROWS AND IT'S AS GOOD AS AVEDA'S PRODUCT. I'M SOOOO HAPPY I FOUND THIS PRODUCT AND WILL MOST DEFINITELY ORDER MORE OF THIS AND OTHER PRODUCTS.
Pam66 from undisclosed
Burt's Bees Warm Brown eyeliner is just that. It is a soft warm brown that looks great. If you want a smudged look it is easy to do with this eyeliner. Does not look to harsh at all. I have tried one other that was good also but honestly prefer Burt's Bees.
ParisianCTO from Cambridge, MA
it is the only one that does not bother me and I tried them from all brand and 3x the price. it is perfect, I buy a couple scared it gets discontinued.
ultafan from new england
An absolute must since they came out and I have all colors. Since their moisturizing I use them only for my top eyelids as bottoms can smudge. But I never line my bottom lids so for me it works.
Stephanie67 from Eugene, OR
I found this product at my local grocery store, I love love love it but I can't find it anymore. Please don't tell me you no longer make this...
jamiec170 from undisclosed
I am so glad I changed to Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil. It does not irritate my eyes or have harmful chemicals. It looks good and lasts all day. The price is perfect and lasts for almost two months with everyday use. Glides on easy. Yes I buy this all the time!
Joyful Lady from Lincolnton, NC
The nourishing eyeliner is nice. It goes on smoothly and seems to stay on well.
kendrasheart from undisclosed
I like to wear this on my upper lash line for a bit more defined eye before putting on mascara. Love this eyeliner product and the ingredients are pretty good. I'd recommend and would buy again!!
Have all shades but my favorite is grey, whish they don't sell at ulta. There a more shades on the Burts Bees website that I wish Ulta sold. I love these for no makeup days on sundays when I want barely any makeup but I am going out for lunch. Grey or brown eyeliner, stained blush, and burts bees tinted balm-done. I wish Ulta sold more if not all Burts Bees products. There are only a few here that every other store sells as well. Burts Bees website has so many other products for the whole family, I wish it all sold here too. Plus, ulta is always late with new Burts Bees products compared to other stores, wish they stocked sooner.
Susjane from Missouri
I can't say how much I love this eyeliner. It's soft, applies well, stays on all day long (even with my excessively watery eyes) but wipes off easily at night with a makeup remover cloth. I also LOVE the midnight gray color because it's less harsh than black and is the perfect shade for me to define my eyes more subtly when I want, or lay it on a bit thicker/more sharply for greater effect. I've never had any difficulty sharpening with a regular, cheap pencil sharpener.
I've been buying this eyeliner for years and after my favorite lipstick was discontinued (different brand), I came here today to buy several more pencils at once for fear of it disappearing someday too!
alexandram262 from undisclosed
I tried this and compared it to a more expensive liner by Elizabeth Arden. Both perform well and apply comfortably. Overall, Burt's Bee is a very solid brand and their products are of high quality. I am very impressed with the pencil, especially considering it is so affordable and comparable to other higher end brands!
kathyba from Portland, ME
Goes on smooth, might smudge after wearing all day but my skin doesn't break out like with other eyeliners.
murmel from Plymouth MI
Whatever sharpener I use, this is the second eyeliner pencil that can't be sharpened. I used two different make up sharpeners, the tips keep breaking. Waste of money!!! Otherwise it would be a good product, like the softness and colors
Jo911 from Berkshires
I like the bronze color, but how do I sharpen the tiny tip?
kellyw156 from undisclosed
This eyeliner went on nice and smooth and did not irritate my eyes. It did not smudge but yet was easy to wipe off with remover. I got several compliments from my coworkers since I don't wear eyeliner to work everyday. I love that it has all natural ingredients.
niknak from PNW
I don't know why I didn't listen to the reviews. Yes, I figured I wanted something gray so I could add a little depth to a look without going full black, but...it just doesn't last. I have taken to doing a light tightline and hoping for the best. At least it doesn't irritate my eyes, so I guess it is a good short-term solution to my problem!
katieh343 from undisclosed
My eyes are so sensitive I've had to stop using mascara and eyeshadow. Thank goodness I can still use this Burt's Bees eyeliner without issues. Burt's Bees products are great for my sensitive skin. Eyeliner stick lasts a long time and goes on my eyes fairly smoothly.
Kar from VA
I've seen a lot of comments about the pencil being runny or having to sharpen it a lot. I have been using these for years and have a hack, put it in the freezer for 30 mins to a hour before doing makeup. Sounds weird but it works trust me!
jennyl109 from undisclosed
I found this annoyingly difficult to use. It doesn't glide very well, and trying to get enough pigment across my eyes resulted in a thicker line than I normally prefer. Full disclosure: I don't consider myself a make up guru or anything, but I feel like I know how to apply some basic eye liner and this pencil literally made it feel hard!
MelK from Dallas, TX
This pencil glides on smooth and has a nice color deposit, but doesn't seem to stay all day.
Rena from Idaho
It went on smooth and well.
sandrah5541 from undisclosed
Looove Al Burt Bee Products! This pencil eyeliner works well for me. I love that their products are either organic or all natural. This works for sensitive skin and applies easily on the skin. I would recommend to family and friends and would definitely rebuy!