body{margin-left:12%}Product ReviewsRated 3.81 out of 5 stars1149 ReviewsMost Helpful Positive ReviewBest wing ever.I bought this out of desperation on a trip after I forgot my eyeliner. I wear a heavy wing everyday and this liner Does. Not. Move. Seriously, the best I've ever found, goes on smooth, stays all day long and truly still does not come off (even after a shower) and unlike most liquid liners it doesn't irritate my eyes. 👍Most Helpful Critical ReviewTerrible!So the main selling point was/is this liner is H2O proof. Well it smeared all over my face with just water. The applicator tip was solid and felt hard as a rock. I haven't had any luck with finding a eyeliner that actually does what it says. They either smear & wipe off or they chip off after it dries. ANYWAYS don't waste your money on this junk because it lies!Reviewed by 1149 customersH2Oh No1Pixel8ed from undisclosedI bought this to have a waterproof liquid liner, and it failed. I wore it to a concert tonight and before I even got to the venue it smudged all over my lid and even traveled under my eyes. Very disappointed. Will not be buying again.Not waterproof, but good product!3faeriology from undisclosedDefinitely wasn't waterproof, however it is a good product! I have hooded downturned eyes, so naturally my eyes water and tend to smear my eyeliner.Long-lasting, smudge-proof black liner with no cracking5aliciakfoxyvoxy1 from undisclosedI purchase the black liner and it's absolutely long lasting. Does not smudge or budge and dries down completely. Does not crack. It does dry down very dry and crunchy tho and that is the only con. Lasts thru sweat, water and crying.Great eyeliner5Feelingfroggy from Griffin, Ga.I love this and very bright color. Its easy to use alsoHate the applicator3serendipvicky from undisclosedGreat eyeliner and is truly waterproof, but the applicator is rock hard so it just hurts putting around my eye. Wish it had the same applicator as the non waterproof liquid eyeliner.Try it5berling3e73 from undisclosedIf you have watery eyes like me I highly suggest you try using this product from Wet and Wild. In the past I have used the elf eyeliner which I liked but for me it would always mess up because my eyes are watery because of allergies.I'm sure the formula2laurat2b26 from undisclosedI'm sure the formula is okay but I do not like the applicator on this eyeliner at all!Eh36littlesofia from undisclosedFor the price I say give it a try! However the applicator is terrible. It's hard to not get too much product and when I try to wipe some off it ends up not being enough. The applicator is hard to work with and is uncomfortable in your hand. It really is waterproof and while doesn't react to water it doesn't really last all day.Never switching5Katie from Glendale ArizonaHad an emotional breakdown twice at work.5/5 stars it didn't even budge. Definitely my go-to eyeliner! You never know what the day is going to bring, at least you know your makeup is safe.Not waterproof or smudge proof1Sofie from New York, NYThe only aspect it's waterproof is that you need to triple cleanse to get it off! Also would not recommend for hooded eyes users. I'll stick to my waterproof essence liner.Don't overlook the gem!4saram737 from undisclosedWhen I think of wet n wild I don't usually think it's much worth my money. At least that has been my experience in the past. But something has happened here. Between this and their breakup proof, I am a believer! It last! It doesn't smudge. And it's inexpensive!!!Good product4lunar88990 from Rosamond,CAI have been using this eyeliner for about 2 1/2 years and it is one of my favorites. I have tried others but they never seem to work as good as this one. I have extremely oily eyelids and hooded eyes, and this eyeliner smears in the creases of my eyes. It also comes off very easily bc my eyelids are so oily but if you are not wearing this for 7+ hours everyday, I'd def recommend this for you. I wear it to school and take it off after 10+ hours so by the it is messed up but I love this eyeliner! The price is also great bc I've tried expensive eyeliners that had horrible quality.It's ok, not great3heathermarie_plus3 from undisclosedIt's ok if you're able to get it perfect the first time. But if you have to do another passover it cakes up and gets clumpy. So if you're perfect at it, it's great. But if you're like me a may need to go over it again to get it even you have to start all over, bc it will get clumpy and peel/flake offPERFECT WATERPROOF EYE LINER!5bvvb from Pittsburgh PaWATERPROOF means that it WILL be harder to remove, it is 'grease'-based, so it takes longer to dry, but it is the perfect waterproof eye liner. The stiff wand applicator is Perfect. You do NOT want a wishy-washy, flexible paint brush applicator----you simply cannot control it as well as a stiff applicator; paint brush applicators cannot smoothly traverse curves on an eyelid.It's a no from me2stellareviews_ from undisclosedThis is probably one of the worst eyeliners I've ever tried. The applicator is difficult to use as it is not a soft brush. The eyeliner is rather thick and is more like a gel consistency. After wearing, it tends to crumble and stick to my eyelashes. It's also difficult to completely remove without leaving little crumbles behind on my eye lids and eye lashes. The only good thing I have to say about this product is that the color is nice and opaque.Not easily applied1Cathy from Cda, idahoNot able to apply well. Brush too stiffThe color is there but not longlasting2Ashley from FloridaI bought this because my favorite eyeliner broke on me and I needed a quick fix so I went down and bought this but when i applied it in the morning the following day it gave me such a hard time cleaning it up because it would smear. The color was nice but i wouldn't buy it again because throughout the day it was smudging under my eyes and anything that brushed up against my eyeliner would smear it even after 10hrs of wear.Love it5whitelightloom from undisclosedSometimes I have to reapply after a couple of hours and it can be a pain. It's water proof ish though and applies to the wet line without getting onion tears from it. I still love it. Cheap, too.I miss the previous version3Jaded from TexasI have used this H2O proof liquid eyeliner for years and rated it a 5 star. Great price. Great product and very waterproof. But now the applicator is different and the liner is defined as "hydro fudge."Stayed put while sobbing5chloe from FloridaI was hit by a car and transported by ambulance to the ER. My clothes were torn, my body was beat, I even lost a shoe. I sobbed for nearly an hour, yet my signature jumbo eyeliner wings didn't budge. I still looked really cute in the hospital :)I love the sleekness4amrithas1 from undisclosedI love the sleekness of this eyeliner. It is very easy to apply and lasts a really long time. I use this eyeliner every week. I do wish the tip was a little bit easier to make a wing with. Overall it is a great liquid eyeliner for every day use. I would like a more felt tip.Best ever. Does not budge on oily eyelids.5Tequiilajane77 from Pittsburgh, PAThis is the best waterproof liquid liner, much better than Revlon Colorstay. I have super oily eyelids and this will not budge.My favorite5amandag528 from undisclosedThis is the first liquid liner I've ever used and it's one of my favorites. It lasts all day and does smear or smudge. I take it off with make up remover and it comes off smooth.Won't budge!5emmajae from undisclosedThis eyeliner lasts literally DAYS!! Although the tip can get chunky, the liner itself is long lasting and a little product goes a long way! I will always recommend this liner.Smudges, Messy1YellowJL from Naples, FLWas not a fan of this liquid eyeliner at all. It smudges and is very messy. It leaves black marks on my face that smear across my makeup. It's also a very runny product. The brush does not make application easy. I would not recommend.