Rated 4.43 out of 5 stars
It's the best mascara I've used. I've tried a lot of different products and always feel like they're missing something but this one does it all. You can really feel the mascara wake up your eyes for that wide awake look. It also doesn't crumble which I always find the biggest problem with most mascaras.
Thanks Eyeko for creating my perfect mascara!
I haven't noticed a single negative review of this product online, and I've looked! I may be unlucky, but I;'ve had issues with smudging that I'll describe in this review.
I've used tubing mascaras before. In fact, L'oreal's is the only one that I've ever found that doesn't smudge. I used it for years but wanted something that would do more for my lashes. Enter Eyeko. I purchased two formulas and tried this one first for a less dramatic day, look.
The curved brush does as some lift but not much. My lashes are incredibly straight, however. Someone did comment that they were still straight while using this mascara.
Lash Alert does more for length than volume. It's not super clumpy, Neither is it very dramatic. It's definitely a day look.
Within the first couple hours, I noticed a bit of flaking. But my eyes had been a bit watery. I wiped it away, and it seemed okay. During the day I blotted and applied more powder because I felt oily.
However, this had smudged within seven hours. That's not even a full work day and a far cry from the advertised 12! No one else seems to have this issue, but I did.
Also, it doesn't wipe off like a tubing mascara -- you know, the clumping with water. It comes right off with a makeup wipe or remover. Except for the part that stays on my skin.
I've paid much less for products that work the same. I am not even sure if this actually is a tubing mascara from my experience. I guess it's on to the next one!
Syd from Bothell, WA
This does lift and curl beautifully. The wand is small and curved which helpes separate and lift well. This is a thin formula that spreads easily and evenly. It does not add volume which makes this better for layering or only on the lower lashline for me rather than on its own.
taryn from central california coast
For me this mascara really stayed on, similar even to kiss me heroine mascara. Nice definition and volume and it didn't irritate my eyes. oh and this is not a tubing mascara, not sure why anyone thinks that
Allie from Minnesota
I have very fine and short eyelashes, so I'm trying tubing mascaras to try and get the length and volume I'm looking for. This looked good when I applied it and it stayed on pretty well (a little bit of smudging but no flaking). But taking it off was really hard for me. I used micellar water and then tried waterproof makeup remover, but neither did a great job for me. It stayed in sticky clumps on my eyelashes, and would cling for a day or two after wearing. Don't know if I got a weird tube, but the gross feeling of day-old mascara clumps was too much for me.
lashes95 from Pittsburgh
I got this because I wanted to try a new tubing mascara. It definitely does not tube. Within an hour it smudges under my eyes. I tried this product for a full two weeks to see if I could get it to work, but no matter what ends up a mess. If you don't have issues with mascara normally smudging, it might be good for you. My lashes do look so pretty at first, but unfortunately does not work for me personally
Gabbi from Columbus, OH
this is my favorite mascara. i've been using it since 2019! love the shape of the brush and the flexibility of the tube is great. whenever i recommend a mascara go someone i always tell them about this hidden gem
Amy from Chicago, IL
I like how this mascara makes my lashes look, but I've never had so much smudging and flaking from a tubing mascara as I have with this one. Unfortunately after a couple of hours, I have raccoon eyes.
BeachLover from Cary, NC
Stays on all day without flaking or smudging. Tube lasts much longer than the cheaper brands.
julianahuliana from Connecticut
Black Magic is a much better mascara. At the price, there are much better mascaras. This mascara didn't have great separating power and really did not legnthen my lashes that much. I expected much more from eyeko since they are usually so fantastic. Not a favorite for me.
Autumn from Cleveland, OH
Though I did not purchase from Ulta, I wanted to share my review! This mascara is GREAT, buildable, not clumpy, easy to remove. I did notice improvement to my lashes as far as length and softness after using continuously. The one tiny downfall is that the product does run out or dry up quicker than usual mascaras. I wonder if its the tube plastic packaging? No matter, I've repurchases and really like this one! :D
Andi from AL
i have used only a few times so far, but it doesn't smudge or flake and it lengthens well. best mascara and i have used many top brands. my current favorite!
MIAD#lovemascara from Austin TX
It is so amazing it literally curls ur lashes so much it's crazy buy this‼️‼️
Mimiluv26 from Minnesota
Best mascara ever! Lengthens my lashes while nourishing them. Non-clumping and non-irritating formula. Highly recommend and definitely will repurchase.
ABH from Grand Rapids, MI
I had high hopes for this mascara since I love the other Eyeko mascaras. Sadly, this doesn't hold up to it's counterparts. This mascara seemed pretty dry from the second I opened it and doesn't not add length or curl to lashes, in fact it seems to make them straighter somehow? Half way through the day, it starts to flake and dries out even more.
CS from New York, NY
This mascara is one of the best for me. The biggest plus is that it holds a curl without using a curler! It does everything else too... lengthens and thickens and it lasts all day and night for me (and no I don't always take off my makeup at night).
Short lashes from Los Angeles
Doesn't flake, irritate, smudge, or budge.
It definitely lengthened my short lashes, added curl, volume, etc. love this product highly recommend.
Beckiesays from Dallas TX
It's okay for about 2 hours and then just starts flaking off. Wand isn't difficult but it definitely gets clumpy by like the 2nd swipe out of the tube if that makes sense, because I think it dries too fast during application.
I've used another tubing mascara (blinc) on and off for years and was expecting similar results. I don't understand how this is so different but I am probably out on this brand.
Removal is easy, at least, and expected for a tubing mascara.
I was so hopeful but it's not for me and definitely poor quality for the price.
Oli from Sheboygan
I don't have nothing positive to say about this mascara , reviews are fake. I was using it with and without eyelash primer and it clumps a lot both ways. Not really black. Doesn't curl lashes, it makes them actually strait. Taking mascara off is difficult because it crumbs all over the face. Is better if you first remove it with fingers buy rubbing them between finger and than use eye make up remover.
Jen K from Jackson, MS
I have officially gone through 3 tubes! this mascara wakes up my lashes and stays in all day!
Dee from Ormond beach
It's clumpy and it gives raccoon eyes by the end of the day. I will not buy again.
Karen from Minnesota
A couple swipes and my lashes are full and voluminous! Love this stuff.
ACS from SC
I don't like heavy mascara. This is just enough with no clumps!
Cin from Los angeles
This is one of the best mascaras I have ever tried. It doesn't smear, it stays on all day. The formula doesn't burn my eyes, I do wear contact lenses and I know I can count on this mascara. The wand is amazing it leaves long and short lashes just how I like it. I found my new all time favorite.
Evita D. from Massachusetts
I received a sample of this product in my Birchbox months ago and milked it for as long as I could. I love the applicator/brush; it spreads the product on the lash nicely without any clumps or extra product. The formula is smooth and truly makes you look awake. My fav mascara at the moment! Absolutely recommend for an everyday, done up look!
Donna from KS
This is my second time purchasing this mascara because it is my absolute favorite one. I get compliments on my lashes when I wear this and I don't wear fakes. I recommend this to anyone who asks me about mascara!