Rated 3.59 out of 5 stars
Definitely love this product! This was the first liquid eye liner I ever tried, Its so easy to use! I'm just a bit disappointed to see that elf is beginning to raise up the prices on their essentials products.
I've been using this eyeliner in black for years, and have literally recommended it to all of my friends. Then, all of a sudden, it changed. I bought a new black one recently and it wouldn't go on in a solid line. Even if I tried to go over it to make it darker, it was too runny and wouldn't go on in a solid line. I thought it was a fluke, so I bought another, but I had the same problem. Bring back the old formula, whatever it was... :(
Be from Florida
Easy to use.
Nini24 from undisclosed
Good for beginners/pros.
Good formula as no allergies have occurred.
Great price! For the bottle and lasts a long time when applied.
The applicator brush is a little long.
The formula is streaky, two applications need to be made a little time consuming. So far it has been good
Jolieg from Missouri
This is my go to black eyeliner! It stays on all day!
Alula from undisclosed
I bought it the first time because it's inexpensive and have been buying it again and again since. I do a baby wing with mine for a light makeup look, but it also works for full glam, and I just think it works so well that there's no point trying any more other black liquid liners now that I've found this one.
Bella from Portland, Or
I love elf but
The good thing about this product is that the liner has a pretty good pigmentation, like a lot. So its very pigmented but if you dont set it (with setting spray) it comes off very easily. Also another con about it is that its a liquid liner..i mean i should have known it wasnt an ink liner but its extremely hard to apply liner with liquid liner. Like when u apply it the stick thing above the liner brush touches your skin and leaves an annoying mark of eyeliner and like i said it very pigmented so it will ruin the rest of your whole makeup look. Also a bit runny.
Lil from Las Vegas
It was affordable and wanted to try it out. Even once it dried, it would bleed and smudge my eyelids after an hour of having it on. Applicator is a bit too flimsy for my liking. Wont be purchasing again.
Ashe from Colorado
i am into eyeliner bcuz it makes me feel good, & this one does work good, but it smudges 😭
i still love it but fix the formula por favor!
Queen from Florida
This is the only eyeliner i use. I love liquid liner because it last longer then liquid pencils. If you are not familiar with using liquid eyeliner like this then i don't recommend for beginners. This takes practice and time. But once you got it..youll love it! However its not a 24hr wear kind of liner. It has faded over 12 hours maybe
Maren99 from Seattle, WA
Love this! Somehow it comes off easier at the end of the day, but still stays in place better than other liquid liners.
NyaB17 from undisclosed
I had small eyes so this definitely works for me! The only eyeliner tool I use
Juliene from undisclosed
My favorote go to liner for everyday uses!! I suggest using primer
clear from Los Angeles, CA
its fine but it got a rating of 45/100 on mu yuka app
Alexajjensen from undisclosed
I bought this eyeliner for my Halloween makeup. As soon as I went to apply it, the eyeliner dripped down and pooled into the inner corner of my eye turning it completely black, it was so runny. After cleaning out my eye I reapplied it but it made my eye lids burn. My daughter came and tried it and it made her eyes burn as well. A few hours after removing it I noticed my eye (the one it ran into) felt funny and when I looked in the mirror it was swollen. I rinsed it out with saline solution. The next morning it was more swollen and very painful. I had to go to an on call optometrist and get a script for whatever it did to my eye. I've never had issues with liquid eyeliner before but several reviews I've read people are having the same reaction. Stay away from this product!
Chris from NYC
I cant believe people rate this poorly. I have been using this liner for years and nothing compares. I went through a phase where i wanted to find a high quality one but this IS the highest quality. The brush is perfect and the eyeliner stays liquid until you use it all up. I like marker liners but hate how they dry up so quickly. This is the BEST liner for wings. Wish they did more colors
Skylovesfood from Philadelphia, PA
I've been using this for years! It doesn't smudge and goes on easily. And it's easy to remove.
ariyayababna from undisclosed
new to using liquid eyelinee but the size of the brush makes it so easy to get a straight line and a sharp tip. its very pigmented and dries a little slow tho but once it dries it doesnt move much when rubbed (also i dodnt set it so keep that in mine! if set i think it wouldnt budge)
Nickelo1980 from Huntsville, AL
This is the first liquid eyeliner I've ever purchased and Iike it a lot. I bought the Charcoal shade and it's a nice dark grey, charcoal is a good name for it. The brush is the best part for me, it's thin and that makes it easy for me to use. Very happy with this purchase.
Kalley from Pittsburgh,PA
I have always used this product, i dont think anything is as perfect as this. It's affordable guys! I bhave been using it since i could even do makeup, and now im great at it. Its one prodcut i never gave up. You can even cryyyy hunny and it stays! GET IT
Kirk27 from undisclosed
I was recently trying to do my makeup with this liner and it started burning like crazy. After I took it off and rinsed my eye it was all puffy and still hurt. I had to come to the website and check the ingredients and I'm not allergic to anything in it. On top of that it was messy, didn't dry, and was hard to use. I do not recommend
sabertooth from undisclosed
Perfect eyeliner for me. Lasts all day and super easy to put on!
Prigirl9 from Toronto, On
I have oily eyelids and it works well. The only problem is the brush. I would prefer a thicker brush that offers more control during application. Otherwise it's fine.
heowkaoa from undisclosed
it's very pigmented and is super easy to apply I have it in midnight color
T from Tuscon, Az
I use this liquid eyeliner EVERYDAY i am in heat, ac, and wear it for long periods of time i love this product and its affordable. The only bad thing it does wear off throughout the day if you wear it long enough.
eternalblu from undisclosed
as someone who draws on giant winged liner, this eyeliner never fails me. idk if i would recommend if u don't wear a base tho!