Rated 4.27 out of 5 stars
This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It goes on beautifully and never smudges or runs. I highly recommend it.
I don't know why companies try to change an excellent product. I've used the refillable eye & lip pencils for 20 yrs. now they are not refillable or self sharpening. They tend to dry out between uses & then you have to sharpen them to draw a good line around your eyes. It works well & has great stay on power but I miss the refillable self sharpening ones. They last half as long as you sharpen them all away very quickly. I always break them sharpening.I wonder why EL changed them for the worst. Please bring back the refillable pencils.as my mom always said "if it ain't broke,don't fix it".
Jane from Salina, KS
Love this eyeliner, goes on smoothly, looks great, easier to apply than liquid eyeliners.
Maria Lujan from Woodhaven, NY
I'd give a 0 to this product. the pencil to be sharpened is of poor quality, every time I got to sharpen it, the tip gets broken, so the pencil is very small now. This product was not cheap.
from Clovis, CA
So far it stays on without smudging, smearing or running unlike some of the other expensive eyeliners
Jane from Salina
Great product, goes on easily, looks great!
from Rockwall TX
I've always loved this product and make a point of getting something I love to use.
Kristy from Hawaii
The best liner ever. I have tried pretty much every different liners from name brand to drug store brand and even different forms of eyeliner. This is the only liner that Stays and doesn't budge. I used the plum color seems to work the best. Its dark enough for a great tight line. People don't know that the darkest you go will probably get a smudge.
from Sugar Land TX
First eyeliner that I have bought in a long time that actually stays on and does not clump in the corner of your eyes.
Missing My Fav Eyeliner from Danville, KY
I used the Doublewear eyeliner pencil (in coffee) for at least ten years. This newer style is HORRIBLE! It constantly breaks, and wastes so much when sharpening. At this rate I would have to buy a new one every month or two. The old style was my favorite and truly stayed on until I washed it off. Makes me sad to have to look for another brand, but I just can't use this new pencil anymore.
Anon from Houston, TX
My eyes water and I have a hard time finding a product that will stay in place all day. This pencil delivers. The reason for 3 stars is the fact that I lose a decent amount of the product when I try to sharpen it. This is my second pencil and I've been using it for several weeks. I was afraid to sharpen it because my last one broke a lot. I thought maybe the first one was old and brittle, but I sharpened my second pencil today for the first time and it broke. Knowing breakage was a problem, I was careful and barely twisted it. It broke anyway. Then another chunk broke off. This pencil is pretty expensive, so I'm not happy that I'm not getting to use what I'm paying for. I reached out to customer service after the problems I had with the first one but never received a response. Sadly, I may have to continue my search for a eyeliner that stays in place.
Kim from Grand Junction, CO
This is the first time buying a twist up eyeliner. I have tried pencils and liquid, nothing comes close to this one. It goes on so smooth and stays all day. I am so excited I purchased this item. Will definitely be buying it again.
Not as good as I'd hoped from Denver, CO
I was looking for a replacement for the Double Wear Stay-In-Place Pencil that was discontinued. This eye pencil is inferior. It's difficult to get a nice point, the sharpener doesn't work well. If you put too much tip out to sharpen the whole tip breaks off and you lose a lot! With the old pencil I always knew how much I have left. With this pencil, the inner product which advances when you turn the barrel, is hidden - so I have no idea how much I have left. Forces me to always have a back up. This eyepencil does not hold on the eye as well as the old version. I often have smudges.
Dorleen from West Virginia
Drags across eyes and flakes off.
Kim from Sapulpa,OK
I have tried several eyeliners and this one seems to be my go to every time.
Dk from New York City
The sharpener doesn't work. It rather breaks them all and you cannot get the acute tip. It is not worth buying. I won't recommend to anyone.
Lotte from Texas
I have really sensitive eyes and am allergy prone. This is the only eyeliner I can sue without irritating my eyes. It holds well and does not smudge. The only con is it runs out quickly
Cheryl from Bradenton Fl
This liner goes on so well, stays all day and has a sharpener in the end of pencil! Great product 🥰
Debbie from Peoria AZ
Stays on all day.
Debbie from NC
Liner goes on easy
Vsd from Ny
Mary Ann from Port Saint Lucie
This eyeliner stays on all day. Doesn't smear. I love it!
Loyal Estee Girl from Smyrna, GA
Not sure why Estee Lauder discontinues beloved products like the eye pencil, only to put out inferior products. Color Espresso is fine, but on first application, eyeliner did not go on smoothly and flaked. When I tried to wipe it off with a kleenex, it was an even worse flakey mess. Threw out the delivery receipt and unable to return, but will be looking for another brand for an eye pencil.
Carolet from South Bend, IN
The product does what it says it will. My disappointment was in sharpening the eyeliner. I used an Estée Lauder pencil sharpener. I just couldn't get a clean trim. After several tries sharpening the pencil the pencil "whittled " down to a nub. Again, the liner stays in place. Color is beautiful. I just couldn't sharpen the pencil.
Katherine from NOVA
Worth the price. I bought the plum color — it's a pretty saturated color, easy to apply and has never smudged once in the months I've been wearing it. I'll buy it again, likely in a neutral color.
TACARVAJALZ from MIAMI
I LOVE BUYING ESTEE LAUDER PRODUCTS, BUT I RECENTLY RELEASED THE PENCILS AT THE START THEY WORKED WELL BUT NOT NOW THEY DON'T PAINT, THEY ARE BROKEN WITH NOTHING
Grandma5 from Kingwood Tx
Goes on easy and stays on all day!