Rated 2.96 out of 5 stars
I got the shade brown as part of J.Cat's eye vault and this eyeliner is fantastic. It puts down a smooth line and blends out as little or as much as you want. The color stays all day and I don't have any issue with it smudging throughout the day. This doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes like a lot of other eyeliners so I am very happy with it. I wish it had a sharpener but that is my only complaint. I am definitely buying more shades.
The quality kinda goes with the price. I got the white color thinking it would be great to put on my waterline, later finding out, I could barely get any color on there. Its not that creamy and pretty stiff, so you have to press down hard to get the color you want but its still streaky and doesn't give you a solid line. You can wear it as an eyeliner if you can press hard enough on your eyelid, but its not really worth it.
dlynnnnnnn from oregon
I got two colors light blue and the hunter green to replace my green Jordana one and they are great! very good price for them too
Erin from Burbank, CA
this product has absolutely no staying power. it smudges so easily, it's worth it to spend a little more on a better liner
Jess from Reno, NV
You get what you pay for. This product is very cheaply made.
rachel from Franklin, TN
the green is a deep, vibrant hunter green but it wears off/fades quickly
Full Glam Queen from Idaho
This did everything it was supposed to do and I have no complaints about it at all.
Aly from Valencia
It was darker in image than in person. Pigmented and Brighter than expected. Kinda sad its not darker.
baddieb from chicago
Ummmmmmm it's not the best but it gets the job done. for the moment.
MsMorticia from Ny & Ma
This was a light pigmented eyeliner so it was very visible. I was not expecting a lot, so it didn't disappoint me. I really haven't had very good luck with this brand. I rated it a 3 because you are getting exactly what you paid for.
Olivia from TN
Not pigmented at all and drags across the skin when trying to apply.
Bri from everywhere
all I can say is "eh". I wouldn't recommend.
allyb from Custer SD
all 3 browns are literally the exact same color side by side on my hand. light orange brown, to be exact. they don't show up well and they smudge off SUPER easily. the only reason they're "water resistant" is because of the coconut oil in them. there isn't anything to keep it on your eye. the wear time in it is terrible.
DSTO from Oakland
The tip was dry and kept breaking. I wasn't even able to draw 1 line w it! You're better off with Wet n' wild if you're looking for something better within this price range.
nish from new york
not my fave. pencil tip was too thick
Ginny from San Francisco
I bought Hunter Green to use in the waterline, hoping it would be a deep rich emerald green. It's not creamy at all and is very sheer. Super disappointing since you can't even build it up. The only pro is that it seems to last well in the waterline. Stayed on for about 8 hours, but you can't even see it.
Sasha from Durham, NC
I love that J.Cat makes such awesome products at affordable prices. You can easily compare their products to department store brands at a fraction of the cost. I love this eyeliner! It just glides right on, and it's so easy to apply. I love that it has a little sharpener if you need to do more detail (although I barely use it...I'm not that fancy =P). It's a great eyeliner for basic, everyday makeup.
Tori from Beaver Dam, WI
Very nice eyeliner for a reasonable price.
Jaz from Albuquerque NM
I love this liner!! I got it in Dodger Blue Hunter Green Lavender and Ash Silver. The Blue is Such a bright Vibrant Color, It is my go to color. The hunter green is a nice color not super dark but still a good color. I was hoping the Lavender was going to be darker but it is true to the Lavender name. The ash silver isnt Sparkly like I was hoping, more like a light gray color. Overall I really love the color and pigment. I do put a bit of Concealer on my eyelids as a primer which help keeps it from running.
LM from Texas
Bad product; dried out...wouldn't really apply.
Jojo from Andalusia, Alabama
Love the color! Especially on those days when I'm tired! Awakens the eye!!!!
elle bea from CT
This liner is garbage. When i tried it on my hand, colors were good and glided on fine. I went to put it on my lid, it doesn't show up. It is useless. and one of them broke on first use. complete garbage product. Wet n Wild is better
Donna K from Washington
This color is definitely better than other colors in thus line but still goes on light and it takes many swipes to get true color payoff. Also fades and moves throughout the day.
It went on patchy and I had to apply 4-5 times to get true color from liner.
not a makeup artist from Arvada, Co
I bought this because i was around $3 away from free shipping, so i just searched for cheap makeup. Because it was so cheap to buy, i was thinking that it wouldn't be that good at all. I was wrong. Its a nice black eyeliner. I said it smudges or runs simply because i do put it in my upper water line, which transfers onto my bottom line. However, i don't mind this and i have never had an eyeliner that didn't do the same. I also like that the tube is a twist up, but doesn't "unwind" when you're using it. Some eyeliners, as you use it, it unrolls or unwinds on its own... if that makes sense. Kind of like some writing pens do, and you constantly have to twist it back up or hold it a weird way.
Megs from Vegas
I thought it would be easy to apply but I had to rub it a lot of times .